-Caveat Lector-
4.Market Access
The mandate of the Negotiating Group on Market Access
is to select a methodology and timetable for the
elimination of all remaining tariffs and "non-tariff" barriers
and agree upon the pace of tariff reduction. Tariffs are
border taxes; under both NAFTA and the WTO, they
have largely been eliminated in Canada and the Americas.
Non-tariff barriers are all the rules, policies and practices
of governments, other than tariffs, that can impact on
trade. Non-tariff barriers can potentially include
everything governments do, including delivering services
and protecting the health and safety of their citizens.
Their inclusion in the mandate of this Negotiating Group
expands the scope of NAFTA market access provisions
considerably.
These provisions are expanded in another important way.
Under NAFTA, market access is subject to national
treatment. This means that imported goods coming into
a country from another NAFTA country must be treated
"no less favourably" than domestic goods. But national
treatment in NAFTA did not extend to government
procurement or to domestic subsidies and was applied to
services only in a limited way. This protected most
government programs from national treatment challenge.
Under the proposed FTAA rules, however, it appears that
services will be covered more fully by the market access
rules. As well, government procurement restrictions that
allow governments to protect local providers will be more
open to challenge from an expanded mandate of the
government procurement provisions. And the ability of
foreign for-profit service corporations to use the national
treatment provision to challenge government services
monopolies will be greatly expanded under a proposed
new agreement on services.
Further, the Negotiating Group on Market Access has
also been charged with identifying and eliminating any
unnecessary "technical barriers to trade" in line with the
WTO.
The WTO Technical Barriers to Trade (TBT) Agreement is
an international regime to harmonize environmental and
other standards which effectively creates a ceiling but no
floor for such regulation. Under its rules, a nation must
be prepared to prove, if challenged, that its
environmental and safety standards are both "necessary"
and the "least trade restrictive" way to achieve the
desired conservation goals, food safety or health
standard. This means that a country bears the burden of
proving a negative - that no other measure consistent
with the WTO is reasonably available to protect
environmental concerns. The WTO TBT Agreement also
sets out an onerous procedural code for establishing new
laws and regulations so arduous that it is very difficult for
any nation to meet.
While there are provisions in NAFTA on technical
standards, they are not as stringent as those found in
the WTO TBT Agreement. NAFTA does require that
technical barriers not constitute "an unnecessary obstacle
to trade." However, NAFTA acknowledges the right of all
parties to maintain standards and regulatory measures
that result in a higher level of protection than would be
achieved by measures based on international standards
as long as they apply these standards in a way that does
not discriminate between national and domestic goods.
By choosing the stronger provisions of the WTO, FTAA
negotiators have introduced tougher restrictions on the
governments of the Americas and their right to regulate
in the best interests of their citizens.
5.Agriculture
The mandate of the Negotiating Group on Agriculture is
to eliminate agricultural export subsidies affecting trade
in the hemisphere, based on the WTO's Agreement on
Agriculture (AOA); "discipline" other trade-distorting
agricultural practices; and ensure that "sanitary and
phytosanitary measures" are not used as a disguised
restriction to trade, using the WTO agreement as a
model.
The FTAA's AOA agriculture provisions set rules on the
trade in food and restrict domestic agriculture policy,
down to the level of support for farmers, the ability to
maintain emergency food stocks, set food safety rules
and ensure food supply.
The WTO Agreement on the Application of Sanitary and
Phytosanitary Standards (SPS) sets constraints on
government policies relating to food safety and animal
and plant health, from pesticides and biological
contaminants to food inspection, product labelling and
genetically engineered foods. As with TBTs, the WTO SPS
Agreement goes further than NAFTA.
The NAFTA provisions do not in themselves impose any
specific standards; they set out a general approach to
ensure that SPS measures are used for genuine scientific
reasons, not as disguised barriers to trade. Member
countries are still allowed to take SPS measures to
protect human, animal or plant life and health at the level
they consider "appropriate." While NAFTA "encourages"
the parties to harmonize their measures based on
relevant international standards, the WTO seeks to
remove decisions regarding health, food and safety from
national governments and delegate them to international
standard-setting bodies such as the Codex Alimentarius,
an elite club of scientists located in Geneva, largely
controlled by the big food and agribusiness corporations.
The WTO SPS Agreement has been used to defeat the
use of the "precautionary principle," which it held not to
be a justifiable basis upon which to establish regulatory
controls. (The precautionary principle allows regulatory
action when there is risk of harm, even if there remains
scientific uncertainty about the extent and nature of the
potential impacts of a product or practice.) By choosing
the WTO SPS Agreement over the NAFTA SPS
provisions, the drafters of the FTAA are moving to totally
remove the right of individual governments of the
Americas to set standards in the crucial areas of health,
food safety and the environment.
6.Intellectual Property Rights
The mandate of the Negotiating Group on Intellectual
Property Rights is "to reduce distortions in trade in the
Hemisphere and promote and ensure adequate and
effective protection to intellectual property rights."
Intellectual property refers to types of intangible property
such as patents which generally grant their holders an
exclusive power. Trade rules on intellectual property
extend this exclusive right, often held by corporations, to
the other signatory countries to the agreement. As of
January 1, 2000, all FTAA countries are now subject to
the rules of the WTO Agreement on Trade Related
Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS).
This agreement sets enforceable global rules on patents,
copyrights and trademark. It has gone far beyond its
initial scope of protecting original inventions or cultural
products and now permits the practice of patenting
plants and animal forms as well as seeds. It promotes
the private rights of corporations over local communities
and their genetic heritage and traditional medicines. It
allows transnational pharmaceutical corporations to keep
drug prices high; recently TRIPS has been invoked to
stop developing countries from providing generic,
cheaper drugs to AIDS patients in the Third World.
The FTAA Negotiating Group on Intellectual Property has
speculated that it might go beyond the WTO TRIPS
Agreement in certain unspecified areas. Certainly,
through the additional powers of Chapter 11, the
investor-state clause, intellectual property rights in the
FTAA will have the additional enforcement powers of cash
fines and harsh penalties.
7.Subsidies, Anti-dumping and Countervailing Duties
The mandate of the Negotiating Group on Subsidies,
Anti-dumping and Countervailing Duties is to "examine
ways to deepen existing disciplines provided in the WTO
Agreement on Subsidies and Countervailing Measures
and . . . to achieve a common understanding with a view
to improving, where possible, the rules and procedures
regarding the operation and application of trade remedy
laws in order not to create unjustified barriers to trade in
the Hemisphere."
The WTO Agreement sets limits on what governments
may and may not subsidize. It has been strongly
criticized by many developing countries as favouring
northern countries and large agribusiness concerns. As
well, Article XXI of the GATT exempts activities in the
military sphere, including massive government research
and export subsidies, in order to protect governments'
"essential security interests." Because the security
exemption shields the war industry from WTO challenge,
it spurs government spending on the military and any
industry related to national security. Since the majority of
global military spending is concentrated in the economies
of a few northern countries, the WTO security exemption
gives these countries an enormous competitive edge over
other, smaller countries.
8.Competition Policy
The mandate of the Negotiating Group on Competition
Policy is to "guarantee that the benefits of the FTAA
liberalization process not be undermined by
anti-competitive business practices." The Negotiating
Group has agreed to "advance toward the establishment
of juridical and institutional coverage at the national,
sub-regional or regional level, that proscribes the
carrying out of anti-competitive business practices" and
"to develop mechanisms that facilitate and promote the
development of competition policy and guarantee the
enforcement of regulations on free competition among
and within the countries of the Hemisphere."
Basically, the goal of competition policy, relatively new to
trade negotiations, is to reduce or eliminate practices
that appear to protect domestic monopolies. Canada is
proposing that each country adopt measures and "take
appropriate action" to "proscribe anti-competitive
business conduct."
Ostensibly, the aim is to promote competition, but the
result, particularly for developing countries, is that they
are often forced to break up their existing monopolies,
only to find that they have given foreign-based
transnational corporations golden opportunities to come
in and pick off the smaller domestic companies and
establish a whole new monopoly protected by WTO
agreements such as the TRIPS and the Financial Services
Agreement, both of which protect global mega-mergers.
9.Dispute Settlement
The mandate of the Negotiating Group on Dispute
Settlement is "to establish a fair, transparent and
effective mechanism for dispute settlement among FTAA
countries" and to "design ways to facilitate and promote
the use of arbitration and other alternative dispute
settlement mechanisms, to solve private trade
controversies in the framework of the FTAA."
It is yet to be seen whether the FTAA dispute settlement
mechanism will mirror the NAFTA model or the WTO
model. However, the Negotiating Group's mandate
includes "taking into account inter alia the WTO
Understanding on Rules and Procedures Governing the
Settlement of Disputes." If this is the case, then the
FTAA dispute settlement system between governments is
more likely to resemble the more punitive system of the
WTO than the NAFTA.
Under NAFTA, a country that loses a case before a
dispute resolution panel must either accept the ruling and
offer "appropriate compensation" to the other
government or risk retaliation of "equivalent benefits."
NAFTA does not create a common set of trade laws for
the member countries. NAFTA dispute panels rule on the
basis of the domestic trade laws of the importing
country.
The role of a WTO dispute panel, however, is to decide
whether a country's disputed practice or policy is a
"barrier to trade," and to overturn the offending practice
or policy if it is deemed to be. Under the WTO Dispute
Settlement Body, a country, often acting on behalf of its
own corporate interests, can challenge the actual laws,
policies and programs of another country and strike
down its domestic laws. A losing country has three
choices: change its law to conform to the WTO ruling;
pay permanent cash compensation to the winning
country; or face harsh, permanent trade sanctions from
the winning country.
Dozens of nation-state health, food safety and
environmental laws have been struck down through this
WTO process. Needless to say, the rulings affect poor
countries differently than wealthy ones. Sanctions
against a country that depends on one or two export
crops for survival can be devastating. It is little surprise
that the majority of WTO challenges have come from
wealthy countries. In fact, the United States initiated
almost half of the 117 WTO challenges launched between
1995 and 2000.
Of course, the recourse to private "investors" (i.e.,
corporations) in NAFTA's Chapter 11 does not exist in
the WTO. It would appear that the FTAA negotiators will
choose to retain the powers of private dispute
settlements contained in the investor-to-state provisions
of NAFTA, while opting for the more stringent conditions
of the WTO to settle state-to-state disputes. This would
be in keeping with the other proposals for the FTAA;
whichever existing (or even proposed) model has the
strongest "disciplines" is the model of choice for the
FTAA.
The three non-negotiating committees have also been
meeting.
The Committee on Small Economies has "recognized the
asymmetries" between the different countries of the
Americas and the need to come up with a plan "in order
to create the opportunities for the full participation of the
smaller economies and to increase their level of
development." However, the plan appears vague,
consisting mostly of providing "a database of technical
assistance needs of smaller economies." Nowhere in this
committee's mandate is there an acknowledgement of the
enormous disparity between the wealthy and the poor of
the hemisphere, both between and within countries.
The Committee on Civil Society acknowledges that "civil
society has emerged as a new actor in the trade
dialogue." Although its mandate is "to receive inputs from
civil society, to analyze them and to present the range of
views to the FTAA Trade Ministers," the purpose of any
dialogue is "to maintain transparency in the negotiating
process and to conduct the negotiations in such a
manner as to broaden public understanding and support
for the FTAA." It appears that the Committee's real role
is not to listen, but to keep up the appearance of real
dialogue. In fact, says Stephenson, the benefit of this
Committee's work "may diffuse pressures related to
issues of labour and the environment."
The Joint Government-Private Sector Committee of
Experts on Electronic Commerce, on the other hand, is a
very important committee whose subject has all the
hallmarks of an emerging sector. Electronic commerce
has exploded in recent years. United States E-commerce
sales were close to $30 billion (US) in 2000, up 75
percent in one year, and may account for one quarter of
world trade by 2005, the year the FTAA is to be ratified.
The U.S. has identified a goal of adopting worldwide rules
for a global non-regulatory, market-oriented E-commerce
regime. Many billions of dollars every year could be lost if
taxes are removed from this kind of trade, leaving
governments with even more reduced funding bases for
government programs.
The committee, heavily dominated by the most powerful
corporate producers of Internet hardware, software and
communications equipment, such as Microsoft and AT&T,
has already carried out extensive analyses of
E-commerce issues and is exchanging views with other
organizations such as the WTO and the OECD. It has
mandated several key studies on all aspects of trade and
E-commerce, and is clearly a growing powerhouse within
the FTAA family.
Finally, the FTAA Trade Negotiations Committee has
identified three areas for "early harvest agreements" - on
forestry, energy and fisheries - which it hopes will be
agreed upon at the April 2001 Ministerial Summit in
Quebec City. This means that, in these areas, agreement
could be reached before the 2005 deadline for full FTAA
ratification to remove tariffs from these environmentally
sensitive resources, with no opportunity for public input.
What Is Canada's Position on the FTAA?
Canada has taken a leading role in the FTAA process (as it has
in the MAI, the WTO and the GATS). The Canadian
government has become an enthusiastic champion of NAFTA
and its expansion, and has been pursuing individual free trade
and investment agreements with Latin American countries like
Chile, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras and Nicaragua.
Canada chaired the initial 18-month phase of the FTAA
negotiations set up in Santiago in April 1998, and is on record
in its support of extending a model of deregulated trade and
privatization to Latin America.
At a March 1999 meeting of the Standing Committee on
International Trade, George Haynal, Assistant Deputy Minister,
Americas, Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAIT),
said: "The hemisphere has gotten its act together. It has some
way to go, but our engagement is with an area that is ready to
engage us on our terms." Added Bob Anderson,
Vice-President, Americas, Canadian International Development
Agency (CIDA): "Virtually all of the countries have bought into
the Washington Consensus in some form or other. That
Washington Consensus implies a whole series of sequenced
reforms. What we in CIDA have tried to do is identify those
kinds of reforms where Canada has some particular expertise,
some comparative advantage."
DFAIT has been strongly criticized by civil society, labour,
human rights and other non-governmental organizations for
its past lack of consultations with any groups but business.
For instance, when citizens groups in Canada heard about the
MAI in late 1996, they were told by DFAIT that no such treaty
existed. After they got a hold of a copy of the text in March of
1997, the groups acquired a list of government MAI
consultations; it showed that DFAIT had been meeting with the
Canadian Chamber of Commerce and the Canadian Council on
International Issues - the international arm of the BCNI - as
early as 1993, four years before the government later admitted
it was even involved in such negotiations.
So on December 13, 2000, when DFAIT announced that it was
releasing the government's negotiating position on the FTAA,
calling it an unprecedented act of transparency, many groups
were very pleased. At last, a meaningful consultation could
begin. However, so much is missing from this document that,
only months before the Quebec City meeting, it is impossible
to gauge Canada's position on the most contentious of the
issues.
Four areas - investment, services, dispute settlement and
intellectual property rights - are missing altogether, and many
questions remain in a number of other key sectors.
Areas of Concern
Investment
The Government of Canada says that it has made no
submissions to the Negotiating Group on Investment to
date. This is hard to believe. Canada was chairing the
process during the period that the Negotiating Group on
Investment came up with its mandate and spelled out a
very ambitious position on investment (set out in detail
above) that includes national treatment, services and
investor-state compensation provisions.
As well, in its introduction to its published negotiating
position, DFAIT states its clear support for an investment
agreement in the FTAA: "In recognizing that investment
is the main engine for growth, Leaders further committed
themselves to creating strengthened mechanisms that
promote and protect the flow of productive investment in
the Hemisphere." Then, in its own draft Preamble, DFAIT
calls for all governments to commit to "establishing a fair
and predictable framework for promoting and protecting
investment."
International Trade Minister Pierre Pettigrew has said that
he will not sign the FTAA if it contains the investor-state
clause (Chapter 11) of NAFTA. This appears to be in
direct contradiction to the commitments that have been
made by his department's negotiators. There is an
urgent need for the government to clarify its exact
position on investment immediately.
Services
Similarly, DFAIT says it has made no submissions to the
Negotiating Group on Services either. Again, Canada was
chairing the hemispheric Negotiating Group that came up
with the sweeping definitions of services, including
national treatment, universal coverage and extended
market access.
It is clear from the introduction to Canada's position that
the Canadian government looks favourably on including
services in the FTAA: "Specifically, they (the Leaders)
noted that the elimination of impediments to market
access for goods and services among our countries will
foster collective economic growth." In the draft Preamble,
Canada calls for "enhancing market access for trade in
goods and services" and acknowledges "the importance
of regulatory reform to advancing trade liberalization."
Certainly, if Canada takes a position at the FTAA similar
to its position at the GATS, it will be promoting
negotiations in which, as the government's own WTO
position paper states, "nothing is off the table, a priori,
including the politically sensitive areas of health and
education."
To see what Canada is likely to support, we can look to
the existing GATS agreement as well as the proposed
additions. The GATS currently covers all service sectors
and modes of supply as well as most government
measures, including laws, practices, regulations and
guidelines - written and unwritten. No government
measure that affects trade in services, whatever its aim,
even for environmental or consumer protection, for
universal coverage or to enforce labour standards, is
beyond the scope of the GATS.
Essentially, the agreement prohibits discrimination
against a foreign supplier in all covered areas
notwithstanding the conditions under which services are
provided and regardless of the human rights or
environmental record of the provider. Parties have also
agreed that some rules apply "horizontally" or across the
board, whether or not the area has already been listed
with the GATS. One "horizontal" rule is that all
regulations in any given sector, including social services,
must be "Least Trade Restrictive" and all member WTO
countries must be prepared to include market
mechanisms wherever possible, even in social programs.
At present, public services provided by government are
technically applicable for exemptions. Hence, some
countries have claimed exemptions for their publicly
funded social security programs. But under GATS article
1.3C, for a service to be considered to be under
government authority, it must be provided "entirely free."
That means that the sector in question must be
completely financed by government and have no
commercial purpose. All government services supplied on
a commercial basis - even if it is not-for-profit - are
subject to GATS rules, as are government services
publicly supplied but in competition with commercial
suppliers. Since hardly any service sector in the world is
entirely commercial-free, this exemption is increasingly
meaningless.
In the new round of negotiations, GATS officials will
attempt to expand access to domestic markets and
governments will be under great pressure to list more of
their services and exempt fewer. The powerful northern
countries will be pressing for more binding market access
provisions, pressing developing countries for guaranteed,
irreversible access to their markets and eliminating many
more policy options.
As well, GATS officials are seeking to place severe
restraints on domestic regulations, thereby limiting
governments' ability to enact environmental, health and
other standards that hinder free trade. Article VI:4 calls
for the development of any "necessary disciplines" to
ensure that "measures relating to qualification
requirements and procedures, technical standards and
licensing requirements do not constitute unnecessary
barriers to trade." This provision would also apply
horizontally. Governments would be compelled to
demonstrate that regulations, standards and laws were
"necessary" to achieve a WTO-sanctioned objective, and
that no less commercially restrictive alternative was
available.
Further, the new talks are aimed at developing new GATS
rules and restrictions, intended to further restrict the use
of government subsidies, such as those used in public
works, municipal services and social programs. A
particularly threatening development is the demand for
an expansion of the "Commercial Presence" rules.
Commercial Presence allows an "investor" of one GATS
country to establish a presence in any other GATS
country and compete not only for business against
domestic suppliers but for public funds against domestic
publicly funded institutions and services.
All of this is taking place under Canada's leadership;
Canada's WTO Ambassador, Sergio Marchi, is chairing
the WTO GATS negotiations. There is no reason to
believe that the Government of Canada would take a
substantively different position on services in the FTAA.
Intellectual Property Rights and Dispute Settlement
Again, the absence of Canada's position on these two
crucial areas from the document is very disturbing. As
with services and investment, Canada was in the chair
during the negotiations that led to the proposed
mandate outlined above. The notion that the Canadian
government is not in full compliance with the Negotiating
Group on Intellectual Property Rights and the Negotiating
Group on Dispute Settlement is not credible.
Technical Barriers to Trade
Canada is proposing a new and separate chapter on the
subject of Technical Barriers to Trade (TBTs) based on
the TBT provisions of the WTO. (These are the rules that
state a nation must be prepared to prove, if challenged,
that its environmental and safety standards are both
"necessary" and the "least trade restrictive" way to
achieve the desired conservation goals, food safety or
health standard.) These rules are of great concern to
Canadian environmentalists and groups concerned with
food and animal safety, as they have been used to strike
down health and safety regulations around the world.
DFAIT says there is a need for a "broader framework" of
discussion and commitment than exists in the proposed
FTAA and recommends establishing a new Committee on
TBTs which would meet regularly and provide technical
assistance to the developing countries of the Americas in
order to assist them to deregulate "unjustified use of
government regulatory powers that have an undue (more
restrictive than necessary) or discriminatory impact on
trade."
Canada's Preambular language expressing its hope of
finding ways to "better protect the environment" is
negated by the strong anti-environmental language of its
position on TBTs.
Agriculture
The Government of Canada is a hawk on the issue of
agriculture. It is calling for the total elimination of export
subsidies for agricultural products "as quickly as possible"
and to prevent their re-introduction "in any form." It is
also calling for the "maximum possible reduction or
elimination of production and trade-distorting domestic
support," even though the elimination of farm subsidies
has had a devastating impact on Canadians farmers, and
it wants to "accelerate the elimination of tariffs for
originating agricultural products." It is bullish on
non-tariff measures and regulations, calling for a
zero-tolerance policy on restrictions on imports.
DFAIT also strongly endorses the WTO Agreement on
the Application of Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures
(SPS) in the FTAA. (The WTO Agreement on SPS sets
constraints on government policies relating to food
safety and animal and plant health, from pesticides and
biological contaminants to food inspection, product
labelling and genetically engineered foods.) Like TBTs,
these rules are seen by many as a way to reduce or
eliminate government regulations that protect human and
animal health in favour of private interests.
As with TBTs, the Government of Canada wants to
"facilitate" day-to-day SPS activities within the
hemisphere and proposes the establishment of a
"Consultative Group on SPS" to provide a "regular forum
for consultations, problem-solving and institutional
cooperation." The committee would look at
harmonization, risk assessment and transparency,
among other things. Canada's strong leadership on this
form of deregulation, particularly in light of the
deteriorating environment of the countries of the
hemisphere, as well as the lowered standards resulting
from giant corporate farms, is great cause for concern.
Government Procurement
The Government of Canada is also a hawk on the issue of
government procurement in the FTAA, calling for full
transparency and the publication of all laws, regulations,
judicial decisions and administrative rulings to do with
government procurement. "Canada agrees that making
public the rules and administrative measures related to
doing business with a government is an important aspect
of the Free Trade Agreement of the Americas."
But DFAIT goes further, calling for a prohibition of "any
type" of offset. Offsets, DFAIT explains, are "measures
imposed or considered by an entity prior to or in the
course of its procurement process that encourage local
development or improve its balance of payments
accounts by means of domestic content, licensing of
technology, investment, country-trade or similar
requirements." In other words, DFAIT supports the
elimination of all the ways in which governments ensure
that foreign investment return some local good to a
community in return for the profit transnational
corporations gain from such access.
If Canada followed this formula proposed by DFAIT, all
sorts of affirmative action, community investment and
local hiring programs would have to be eliminated when
dealing with foreign-based transnational corporations.
Competition
Canada is calling for very strong language around
competition policy in the FTAA "to ensure that the
benefits of the FTAA liberalization process are not
undermined by anti-competitive business practices."
However, DFAIT is strangely mute on the question of
"official monopolies and state enterprises." Its hawkish
position on government procurement coupled with its
strong position on competition, as well as its apparent
pro-services bias, may put Canadian public institutions,
such as the CBC, in jeopardy.
What Impact Will the FTAA Have on Canadians?
Social Security
The expanded powers proposed for the FTAA in combination
with Chapter 11 of NAFTA and the introduction of "universal
coverage of all service sectors" pose a grave threat to
Canada's social programs. Universal health care, public
education, child care, pensions, social assistance and many
other social services are now delivered by governments on a
not-for-profit basis.
Until the recent GATS negotiations, and now the FTAA
negotiations, Canada has always maintained that these social
programs were a fundamental right of citizenship for all
Canadians, and have exempted them from trade agreements.
However, with these two agreements, the Canadian
government is opening up itself, and every other level of
government, to trade-sanctioned threats by transnational
service corporations keen to break down the existing
government monopolies in the hemisphere.
Services is the fastest growing sector in international trade,
and of all services, health, education and water are shaping up
to be the most potentially lucrative of all. Global expenditures
on water services now exceed $1 trillion every year; on
education, they exceed $2 trillion; and on health care,
expenditures exceed $3.5 trillion. In Canada, the service sector
accounts for 75 percent of all jobs.
These and other services have been targeted by predatory and
powerful entrepreneurial transnational corporations that are
aiming at nothing less than the complete dismantling of public
services by subjecting them to the rules of international
competition and the discipline of the WTO and the FTAA.
(Already over 40 countries, including all of Europe, have listed
education with the GATS, opening up their public education
sectors to foreign-based corporate competition, and almost
100 countries have done the same in health care.)
In the United States, health care has become a huge business,
and giant health care corporations are registered on the New
York Stock Exchange. Rick Scott, the president of Columbia,
the world's largest for-profit hospital corporation, says that
health care is a business, no different from the airline or
ball-bearing industry, and he has vowed to destroy every
public hospital in North America, as they are not "good
corporate citizens." Investment houses like Merrill Lynch and
The Lehman Brothers predict that public education will be
privatized in the hemisphere over the next decade the way
public health has been, and say there is an untold amount of
profit to be made when this happens.
If services are included in the FTAA, as they so clearly appear
to be, foreign for-profit health, education and other social
service corporations from anywhere in the hemisphere will have
the right to establish a "commercial presence" anywhere in
Canada. They will have the right to compete for public dollars
with public institutions like hospitals, schools and day care
centres. Standards for health, education, child care and social
work professionals will be subject to FTAA rules and review to
ensure they are not an impediment to trade. Degree-granting
authority will be given to all hemispheric-based education
corporations. Foreign-based telemedicine services will become
legal in Canada. And Canada won't be able to stop the
transborder competition of low-cost health and education
professionals.
If any government at any level in Canada attempts to resist
these developments and tries to maintain these services in
domestic control, every service corporation of the hemisphere
will have the legal right to sue for financial compensation for
lost revenues under the investor-state provisions of the FTAA.
This is not speculation; in areas covered by the current NAFTA,
there have now been many precedents of governments
reversing decisions and paying onerous compensation
packages to private interests affected by public policy.
As well, there is already a disturbing precedent in health care
under the existing investment provisions of NAFTA. A March
2000 legal opinion by Canadian trade expert Steven Shrybman
shows that when Alberta passed Bill 11, which permits
for-profit corporations to compete with public hospitals for
public funding to provide health care "services," it gave
trade-sanctioned rights to U.S. for-profit foreign corporations
to set up shop not only in Alberta, but in any province in
Canada and to sue for compensation if denied this access.
"While in theory a government could retreat from contracting
out health services to private companies, that government
would face the full force of foreign investor compensation
claims for not just present, but future losses. The costs of
compensation resulting from re-establishing a public system
would be prohibitive."
The reality is simple: once privatization is established in any
public sector, it would be almost impossible to reverse. With
time, Canadian governments would no longer be able to afford
to publicly fund health care, social security programs and
education as they would have to be prepared to give equal
access to such funding to private contractors from the other
FTAA countries.
Canadians have already seen a steady erosion of their social
security under the new rules of economic globalization and
trade agreements like NAFTA and the WTO, as Canada's
economy has merged into the American orbit and American
rules. Socially, Canada now looks more like the U.S. than in any
time in its history, with its huge gaps between haves and
have-nots. In Canada, as in the U.S., while great prosperity
abounds in some quarters, great poverty is growing in others.
In fact, Canada has experienced the highest rise in child
poverty in the industrialized world in the last decade - the
same years in which the number of millionaires has tripled and
corporate salaries have grown at an average of about 15
percent a year. In the very free trade years that corporate
salaries skyrocketed, workers' wages rose just 2 percent, less
than the rate of inflation.
The cuts to social programs and Employment Insurance (only
one third of unemployed workers now receive EI benefits they
have paid for, compared to almost 80 percent in 1989) have
been so deep that Standard and Poor says that the myth of a
"kinder Canada" must be put to rest. For the first time in
1999, says the New York-based ratings institute, Canada
spent less on its elderly and unemployed than did the United
States.
With the proposed FTAA, the assault on social security will
dramatically escalate.
end pt. 2
<A HREF="http://www.ctrl.org/">www.ctrl.org</A>
DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER
==========
CTRL is a discussion & informational exchange list. Proselytizing propagandic
screeds are unwelcomed. Substance�not soap-boxing�please! These are
sordid matters and 'conspiracy theory'�with its many half-truths, mis-
directions and outright frauds�is used politically by different groups with
major and minor effects spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought.
That being said, CTRLgives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and
always suggests to readers; be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no
credence to Holocaust denial and nazi's need not apply.
Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector.
========================================================================
Archives Available at:
http://peach.ease.lsoft.com/archives/ctrl.html
<A HREF="http://peach.ease.lsoft.com/archives/ctrl.html">Archives of
[EMAIL PROTECTED]</A>
http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/
<A HREF="http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/">ctrl</A>
========================================================================
To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Om