Earnie Boyd wrote:
> I see it's time for me to chime in. We the cygwin-apps developers must > insist that all X11 packages use --prefix=/usr/X11R6 because it's possible > for an X11 package to be both Win32 and X11, E.G.: rxvt. And I the user > could want to use either depending on the moode (spelling intentional) I'm > in. Bad example, Earnie. The current rxvt package is, itself, in a single binary, BOTH Win32 AND X11. It is fine right where it is (--prefix=/usr). Now, if you want to distinguish between, say, and XEmacs that is built using native MS windowing only (which should go into --prefix=/usr) and an XEmacs built using X11 windowing (which, depending on how this discussion ends, MIGHT go into --prefix=/usr/X11R6), then that's a different issue. However, even in that case, I'm not sure I agree with you. Suppose there WERE two tentative "XEmacs" packages. Should a user be able to install both at the same time? Then he would be duplicating all 50Meg of the elisp code -- which is identical -- in /usr/share/xemacs/ and /usr/X11R6/share/xemacs/. The two packages would have to have different names -- XEmacs-MS- and XEmacs-X- ? Or should these two packages be coordinated -- XEmacs-MS- (which contains binary and libs), XEmacs-X (ditto), and a separate XEmacs-elisp (which both use, and installs the 50M of elisp into --prefix=/usr.) But in that case, the XEmacs-X package isn't really "--prefix=/usr/X11R6" -- it's "--prefix=/usr --bindir=/usr/X11R6/bin --libdir=/usr/X11R6/lib". This is a messy issue. Basically, what I am getting at is you are raising a whole nother can of worms: (1) programs that can exist in EITHER "native" or "X" forms. That is a different issue than (2) programs which are simultaneously, within the same binary, BOTH "native" and "X" (e.g. your rxvt example) and it is a different issue than (3) programs that exist ONLY in "X" form. Let's limit this discussion to group (3), okay? On group (1), anybody want to check how Red Hat separates/enables coexistence of packages that are either X or SVGAlib, and take that to a different thread? We already know that (group 3) almost all X programs (with very few exceptions) go into --prefix=/usr on RHL. --Chuck
