Hello Jens,

Jens Wagner writes:

>
> Basically, we are looking for nameservers, that:
>
> 1. allow you to add, remove and update zones online, anytime
> 2. do not 'stutter' or even stop resolving while getting updated, no 
> matter if single records are updated, or new zones added
> 3. do not need to keep all zones and records in memory
> 4. support DNSSEC + NSEC3
> 5. use internal caching for performance reasons


NSD, BIND9 and Knot should all satisfy the above, except for 3. YADIFA
might also, but I have no experience with it so far.

Is memory really an issue these days?

Microsoft WinDNS 2012R2 satisfies all points above, but has other
issues (no support for TLSA-RRs).

>
> PowerDNS provides all of the above, BIND9+DLZ does everything but 5., 
> MyDNS does everything but 4. (and is outdated).
> Most servers that are written for TLDs fail at 2. and or 3. Do you
> know any other products? Still hope for BIND10/Bundy.

Bundy-DNS would be an alternative satisfying all your requirements, but
it might not be "polished" enough in its current state. Bundy-DNS today
does not have full-time developers, no sponsor and is moving
slow. Please contact me off-list if you (or anyone) is interested to
testdrive Bundy-DNS or change the situation for the Bundy-DNS project.

--
Carsten Strotmann 
Email: [email protected] 
Blog:strotmann.de

_______________________________________________
dane mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dane

Reply via email to