I read draft-levine-dns-mailbox-01 with interest and have the following editorial comments (and one technical comment):

Section 1:
Many systems allow "extensions" such as john-ext or mary+ext

The term used in the vernacular is "sub-addressing" (in everything that I have seen), and the term in [RFC5233] is "subaddressing" (no hyphen) or "detailed addressing" (with space). "Plus addressing" (occasionally "plus-addressing") and "minus addressing" or "'minus' addressing" has also been seen in the wild. I would change that sentence to say that:

Many systems allow for subaddressing, such as "john-ext" or "mary+ext", where "john" or "mary" is treated as the effective local-part, and "ext" is passed as detail information to the recipient for further handling. See [RFC5233].


Section 4.1:
and synthesizes an key record,

change to:
and synthesizes a key record,


Technical:
Abstract
"and the DNS design that only does exact matching."

I thought that DNS uses ASCII labels, which are matched case-insensitively, and that there are no other modern options. [RFC4343] [RFC6891] False? See also Sections 3 and 4 in the I-D.

Sean

On 9/20/2015 8:54 PM, John Levine wrote:
I've sent in a new version of draft-levine-dns-mailbox-01 that
describes a bunch of ways to encode mail address local parts in ways
that don't need canonicalization or address guessing.

Take a particular look at section 5, which publishes regular
expressions to match a domain's mail addresses.

* Can represent any plausible local part syntax including case
folding, noise characters, multiple ways to write Unicode characters,
suffixes where some are ignored and some aren't, BATV, and VERP.

* Reasonably fast lookup (max of one query per localpart character)

* Works fine with static zones served by ordinary name servers .

* Doesn't make bulk addresss harvesting easy.

If you really want to do experiments in publishing mail info in the
DNS, I think this would be a rather interesting one.

R's,
John


Attachment: smime.p7s
Description: S/MIME Cryptographic Signature

_______________________________________________
dane mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dane

Reply via email to