A NOTE has been added to this issue. ====================================================================== http://www.dbmail.org/mantis/view.php?id=725 ====================================================================== Reported By: bslagter Assigned To: paul ====================================================================== Project: DBMail Issue ID: 725 Category: IMAP daemon Reproducibility: always Severity: minor Priority: normal Status: feedback target: ====================================================================== Date Submitted: 02-Sep-08 22:06 CEST Last Modified: 24-Feb-09 11:01 CET ====================================================================== Summary: Fix Thunderbird and ACL shared folders Description: Shared personal folders (in IMAP #Users namespace) won't show up in the Mozilla Thunderbird "Subscribe" window.
This is confirmed to be a bug by Paul Stevens on the dbmail mailinglist: [quote] It's a dbmail bug. If you issue a simple 'x LIST "" *' mailboxes the current user has 'l' permissions on below #Users will show up nicely. This is what SM does. However, TB uses 'x LIST "" #Users*' which is currently not allowed by dbmail. It should be however. TB also tries to fall back to addition variations, but those also fail. Please file a bug someone. ====================================================================== ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (0002610) casper (reporter) - 02-Oct-08 16:01 http://www.dbmail.org/mantis/view.php?id=725#c2610 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Is this going to be fixed in the 2.2 branch? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (0002611) paul (administrator) - 04-Oct-08 22:32 http://www.dbmail.org/mantis/view.php?id=725#c2611 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- fixed in the 2.2 tree ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (0002622) bslagter (reporter) - 14-Oct-08 09:10 http://www.dbmail.org/mantis/view.php?id=725#c2622 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 1. Shared folders do show up in the "Subscribe" window now, but subscribing doesn't work. I can select a folder, hit subscribe, but nothing happens (nothing is changed in the dbmail_subscriptions table. 2. In the "Subscribe" window, hitting refresh will cause a part of the shared folders to disappear. It seems that only users with folders I'm already subscribed to will stay. 3. If I subscribe to the folder manually (by INSERTing into dbmail_subscription), it works, but only after deleting and creating my e-mail account. So the fix was an improvement, but it is far from perfect yet! If I can help with testing, let me know! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (0002623) paul (administrator) - 25-Oct-08 16:16 http://www.dbmail.org/mantis/view.php?id=725#c2623 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- would you mind testing the attached patch on top of rc2 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (0002624) bslagter (reporter) - 04-Nov-08 14:03 http://www.dbmail.org/mantis/view.php?id=725#c2624 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Thanks Paul for your work on this issue! We've downloaded and compiled the RC3 tarball. Unfortunately the problem isn't solved yet. A shared folder (in dbmail_acl) won't show up in the subscribe window. If I manually subscribe (using dbmail_subscription), the folder is available immediately in Thunderbird, and removing a subscription works perfectly as well. Hope you have a clue how to get that to work? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (0002625) paul (administrator) - 04-Nov-08 16:56 http://www.dbmail.org/mantis/view.php?id=725#c2625 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- I tested this using the setacl imap command and using TB to validate the results. What are you inserting into dbmail_acl? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (0002626) bslagter (reporter) - 04-Nov-08 18:30 http://www.dbmail.org/mantis/view.php?id=725#c2626 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Our mailbox administration app inserts a row with the user_id, mailbox_id and all flags set to 1. We assumed this would be correct since other mail clients (Evolution and Outlook) can subscribe to these shared folders without any problems. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (0002628) paul (administrator) - 14-Nov-08 11:08 http://www.dbmail.org/mantis/view.php?id=725#c2628 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Please test the attached patch. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (0002790) Lord (reporter) - 23-Feb-09 17:05 http://www.dbmail.org/mantis/view.php?id=725#c2790 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- After Upgrading from 2.2.11rc3 to 2.2.11 I got a problem with a Blackberry Internet Service. After tacking the problem down I think its because this patch http://git.dbmail.eu/?p=paul/dbmail;a=commit;h=4198e041af8e5d2356ca2a9fb30a6a41e4f80b6c added the \noselect option to the LIST reply of INBOX RC3 returns: * LIST (\haschildren) "/" "INBOX" so the Blackberry returns a SELECT "INBOX" and starts to fetch Mails in 2.2.11 Final it gets: * LIST (\noselect \haschildren) "/" "INBOX" the Blackberry returns a LOGOUT and don't fetch mails... I think that the Blackberry Server think it can't joins the INBOX and don't select the INBOX and so don't get the trigger to fetch Mails the question is, who's wrong ;-) And is a workaround possible? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (0002794) paul (administrator) - 24-Feb-09 09:14 http://www.dbmail.org/mantis/view.php?id=725#c2794 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Could you please provide the LIST command sent by your blackberry? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (0002795) Lord (reporter) - 24-Feb-09 11:01 http://www.dbmail.org/mantis/view.php?id=725#c2795 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- the broken version of the communication: ---------------- Read from: 172.22.14.197:143 --------------- l OK LOGIN completed ---------------- Read from: 216.9.253.136:34047 --------------- l LIST "" % ---------------- Read from: 172.22.14.197:143 --------------- * LIST (\hasnochildren) "/" "Drafts" ---------------- Read from: 172.22.14.197:143 --------------- * LIST (\hasnochildren) "/" "Gesendete Objekte" * LIST (\haschildren) "/" "INBOX" * LIST (\hasnochildren) "/" "INBOX.Gesendete Objekte" * LIST (\noselect \haschildren) "/" "INBOX" ---------------- Read from: 172.22.14.197:143 --------------- * LIST (\hasnochildren) "/" "Junk-E-Mail" ---------------- Read from: 172.22.14.197:143 --------------- * LIST (\hasnochildren) "/" "Sent Items" * LIST (\hasnochildren) "/" "Vorlagen" l OK LIST completed ---------------- Read from: 216.9.253.136:34047 --------------- l LIST "" "%/%" ---------------- Read from: 172.22.14.197:143 --------------- * LIST (\hasnochildren) "/" "INBOX/sub" ---------------- Read from: 172.22.14.197:143 --------------- l OK LIST completed ---------------- Read from: 216.9.253.136:34047 --------------- q LOGOUT PS: its not my blackberry its the vodafone internet pushservice in austria for A1 Mobilephones Issue History Date Modified Username Field Change ====================================================================== 02-Sep-08 22:06 bslagter New Issue 02-Oct-08 15:58 casper Issue Monitored: casper 02-Oct-08 16:01 casper Note Added: 0002610 04-Oct-08 22:32 paul Note Added: 0002611 04-Oct-08 22:32 paul Assigned To => paul 04-Oct-08 22:32 paul Status new => resolved 04-Oct-08 22:32 paul Resolution open => fixed 04-Oct-08 22:32 paul Fixed in Version => 2.2.11 14-Oct-08 09:10 bslagter Status resolved => feedback 14-Oct-08 09:10 bslagter Resolution fixed => reopened 14-Oct-08 09:10 bslagter Note Added: 0002622 25-Oct-08 16:15 paul File Added: 0001-more-fixes-for-725.patch 25-Oct-08 16:16 paul Note Added: 0002623 04-Nov-08 14:03 bslagter Note Added: 0002624 04-Nov-08 16:56 paul Note Added: 0002625 04-Nov-08 18:30 bslagter Note Added: 0002626 14-Nov-08 11:08 paul Note Added: 0002628 23-Feb-09 17:05 Lord Note Added: 0002790 23-Feb-09 17:10 nethzt Issue Monitored: nethzt 24-Feb-09 09:14 paul Note Added: 0002794 24-Feb-09 11:01 Lord Note Added: 0002795 ====================================================================== _______________________________________________ Dbmail-dev mailing list Dbmail-dev@dbmail.org http://twister.fastxs.net/mailman/listinfo/dbmail-dev
