Sept. 14 TEXAS----new execution date Execution date set in Bell County case A man convicted of a Bell County murder is the 1st scheduled to die in 2008 from Texas' death row. Judge Joe Carroll with the 27th District signed the death warrant for 41-year-old Denard Manns, scheduling him to die on Jan. 24. Texas has thus far executed 23 inmates and has 6 more scheduled for 2007. A 7th, who was scheduled to die Thursday night, had his death warrant withdrawn at the request of the Dallas County district attorney's office. A Bell County jury convicted Manns and sentenced him to die in March 2002 for the November 1998 slaying of 25-year-old Army medic Christine Robson. "All the basic appeals have been exhausted unless there's an extraordinary appeal," Carroll said. After Ms. Robson, with Fort Hood's 21st Combat Support Hospital, didn't report to work on Nov. 19, 1998, 3 of her fellow soldiers came to her house. Inside, they found her dead - kneeling and face down inside her bathtub - killed by 4 gunshot wounds to the head. The woman, clad only in a bra, had her hands tied behind her back with an electrical cord. Testimony during the trial showed Manns' DNA matched DNA extracted from a semen stain on the bra. Manns had lived 2 doors down from Ms. Robson, in the same 4-apartment complex about 4 blocks from the Killeen Police Department. Manns had a prior record from New York, where he had served 2 sentences for armed robberies, and was out on parole in 1998 when he murdered Ms. Robson. Carroll said there would still be a chance for a last-minute appeal. "We'll continue to monitor it and if it doesn't happen in January we'll set another day for it," he said. "Hopefully it will not be reversed and we will not have to try it again." 2 death row inmates from Bell County have previously been executed, including one for which Carroll also signed the death warrant. Christopher Black Sr. was 43 when he was executed on July 9, 2003, for killing his 17-month-old granddaughter Katrese Houston on Feb. 7, 1998. Carroll sentenced Black to death after a jury found him guilty and deserved the death penalty in August 1999. Black also had been charged with killing his wife Gwendolyn Black, and 5-month-old-daughter Christina Black. After shooting them, he called 911. When officers arrived, he was holding his dead daughter in his arms. Thomas Barefoot was 39 when he was executed on Oct. 30, 1984, for killing a Harker Heights police officer to avoid arrest on Aug. 7, 1978. Barefoot was wanted in New Mexico on charges of sexually assaulting a 3-year-old girl. (source : Temple Daily Telegram) ***************** Court stops execution at district attorney's request----Dallas County: He says defense didn't get all evidence during trial Joseph Lave A twice-convicted murderer was spared lethal injection Thursday after the Dallas County district attorney's office asked that the execution be halted because evidence was not turned over to Joseph Roland Lave Jr.'s attorneys. The request by District Attorney Craig Watkins came after his office discovered that long-requested information about a second polygraph test by a co-defendant existed despite the previous district attorney's administration saying it did not. Court records show that in 2004, prosecutors told Mr. Lave's appellate attorneys and a federal court that a second polygraph was never taken. Mike Ware, who oversees the district attorney's conviction integrity unit, said the district attorney's office found the results of the second polygraph in its files. The second polygraph was taken at the request of the district attorney's office. Mike Ware, special assistant in the Dallas County Attorney's Office Conviction Integrity Unit, announced Thursday the withdrawal of the execution date of Joseph Roland Lave. "We did not feel it would be right to allow the execution to go through without disclosing this information to Mr. Lave's attorneys," Mr. Ware said. "It appears the rule of law was not followed. ... Misrepresentations were made." The co-defendant, Timothy Bates, did not testify against Mr. Lave, but his statements to police were introduced as evidence. Although the district attorney's office would not detail the outcome of the polygraph, officials said the results directly address Mr. Bates' credibility. Mr. Ware said he became aware of the 2nd polygraph earlier this week but did not realize its significance until Wednesday. That's when state District Judge Andy Chatham signed the order that halted the execution. Mr. Ware said it's too soon to tell whether further investigation of Mr. Lave's case could result in a new execution date or a new trial. It's unclear whether Mr. Bates' statements would have been allowed or objected to at trial if Mr. Lave's attorneys knew about the 2nd polygraph, Mr. Ware said. Richard Franklin, the lead defense attorney at Mr. Lave's trial, said he believes he had the results of the second polygraph, but he was not certain. "I think I had that information, but I'm not sure specifically what form it took," Mr. Franklin said. "It wouldn't have changed the way we did anything because we didn't believe Bates was telling the truth anyway." AN UNUSUAL CASE What happened: A death row inmate's execution was halted at the request of the Dallas County district attorney because evidence in his case was not turned over to his attorneys. The attorneys had previously been told that the evidence results of a lie detector test did not exist. What's next: Joseph Roland Lave Jr.'s attorneys and the district attorney's office will examine the legal ramifications of the evidence not being turned over. Officials said it's too soon to know whether Mr. Lave could get a new trial or if another execution date will be set. The district attorney's office will look into whether there was prosecutorial misconduct. Mr. Lave's current attorneys could not be reached for comment Thursday. Unusual case The district attorney's office declined to name the attorneys who did not hand over the information. They are no longer with the district attorney's office, and it's unclear whether the information was overlooked or purposely withheld. The district attorney's office will look into whether prosecutorial misconduct took place. The 2004 federal court finding shows that the district attorney's office under former District Attorney Bill Hill told the court that only one polygraph was taken. Mr. Lave's attorneys said this was not true but could not present any evidence of this except for comments from Mr. Bates to an investigator who interviewed him after the trial, court records show. Mr. Bates said in the interview that he may have taken more than one polygraph. The district attorney's office said the U.S. Supreme Court could have granted a stay based on this information, but officials did not want to wait. Dan Hagood, the original prosecutor in the case who is now a defense attorney, referred all questions to the district attorney's office. Southern Methodist University law professor Fred Moss said he can't recall another case where a district attorney has requested a stay unless there was clear evidence a defendant was not guilty. "In my experience, it's rather unusual where a stay has come from the prosecution," Mr. Moss said. "It seems consistent with the policies Watkins has instituted to make sure all convictions are safe convictions." Mr. Franklin, the original defense attorney, praised the district attorney's office. He doesn't think former district attorneys would have raised the question. "I think they would have said, 'No, that's good enough,' " he said. Mr. Moss, a former federal prosecutor, called Mr. Watkins' request "commendable." "Death is, after all, final," Mr. Moss said. "What's the harm in checking?" Law of parties Mr. Lave, a former delivery driver, was convicted of capital murder for the robbery and double murder on the day before Thanksgiving in 1992 at Herman's World of Sporting Goods in Richardson. Mr. Lave was convicted under the state's law of parties. The law makes anyone who is involved in a capital crime eligible for the death penalty. Last month, Gov. Rick Perry blocked the execution of a man convicted under the law of parties and commuted his sentenced to life in prison. Kenneth Foster was the getaway driver in a 1996 armed robbery spree that ended in the death of a 25-year-old San Antonio man. In the Richardson case that led to Mr. Lave's conviction, 3 men including an employee used a key to get inside the sporting goods store. The robbers bound store employees Angie King, 22, Frederick Banzhaf, 18, and Justin Marquart, 18, with duct tape on their wrists, mouths and eyes. All three had their skulls fractured with a hammer, and their throats were slashed. Mr. Banzhaf and Mr. Marquart died. But Ms. King survived. She freed herself and called police. Ms. King identified the store employee, James Langston, 26, who was shot and killed the day after the murders when he tried to run over a police officer with a car. In his clothing, police found a telephone number for Mr. Bates. Mr. Bates, who was sentenced to life in prison, led authorities to Mr. Lave. Mr. Franklin has insisted that Mr. Lave thought he was in on an after-hours burglary and blames Mr. Langston for the murders. Mr. Lave was sentenced to life in prison for one of the murders and received a death sentence in the 2nd trial. At trial, Ms. King described the voice of the man who cut her as sounding like Donald Duck, a description that seemed to fit Mr. Lave, Mr. Franklin said. He said the reprieve would probably postpone Mr. Lave's execution. "I think it's just a delay," he said. "I don't think it will result in a commutation. But I guess it depends on how his appellate lawyers intend to frame the issue, if they're going to suggest something intentional." (source: Dallas Morning News) ******************** Inmate set to die wins reprieve----Dallas DA, citing new evidence, withdraws execution request. Condemned prisoner Joseph Lave was spared execution Thursday when the Dallas County district attorney's office withdrew its request that he be given a lethal injection for his part in the gruesome slayings of 2 sporting goods store workers during a robbery 15 years ago. It's the 2nd execution in recent weeks to be stopped in Texas. 2 weeks ago, Gov. Rick Perry commuted Kenneth Foster's death sentence to life in prison on the rare recommendation of the Board of Pardons and Paroles. Perry said he objected to Foster having been tried with his co-defendant. Lave's commutation request to the board was rejected Tuesday, 7-0. Unlike Foster, Lave was tried alone in Dallas County, but both he and Foster were convicted under Texas' unique law of parties, which makes eligible for execution anyone involved in a capital crime. State District Judge Andy Chatham signed the request from Dallas County District Attorney Craig Watkins as the U.S. Supreme Court was considering an appeal from Lave's attorneys to halt the punishment. "We're gratified with the action of the district attorney's office," said David Botsford, one of Lave's lawyers. Mike Ware, special assistant in Watkins' conviction integrity unit, said Thursday that prosecutors discovered evidence that had not been turned over to Lave's defense attorneys. The evidence, a 2nd polygraph test given co-defendant Timothy Bates, came to light within the past few days, Ware said. Though Ware wouldn't describe the polygraph results in detail, it "goes to his credibility," he said. Lave's lawyers had been requesting the information for years as part of the post-conviction process, and Ware said it appeared that the administrations of two previous district attorneys failed to turn it over. Watkins became Dallas County district attorney in January. The two slaying victims, Justin Marquart and Frederick Banzaf, both 18, along with the store's assistant manager, Angie King, were surprised by three intruders who got into the store in Richardson, a north Dallas suburb, just after it had closed the night before Thanksgiving 1992. Marquart and Banzaf's heads were pounded with the claw end of a hammer and then they were nearly decapitated with a knife slashed across their throats. King, then 22, survived. She identified one of the attackers as co-worker James Langston, 26. Hours later, Langston tried to run over a police officer attempting to question him and was shot and killed. Inside his boot, police found a business card from the store with the name and phone number of Bates written on the back. When Bates was arrested, he implicated Lave, who surrendered a few days later. King was among the prosecution witnesses, identifying the robbers as Bates and Langston, who had worked at the store for about a year. King told of hearing a third voice, which prosecutors said was Lave's. Items from the store were found at his home, and blood was detected on his clothing. Lave's appeal to the Supreme Court focused on what his lawyers argued was his trial attorneys' inability to cross-examine Bates and challenge damaging statements from him. Bates refused to testify for Lave, and a police officer told jurors of his interview with Bates. Lave's attorneys said new procedures under a Supreme Court ruling, issued after Lave's conviction, wouldn't allow such testimony now and should be made retroactive. Bates took a life prison term, agreeing in a plea bargain to cooperate with prosecutors. Lave was tried 1st for Banzaf's slaying, turning down a plea deal, and got the life sentence that prosecutors sought. In a 2nd trial, for Marquart's murder, jurors gave Lave death. (source: Associated Press) *********************** Execution Stayed - Reason's A Stunner The 1992 crime in question was horrific. 2 employees in a Richardson sporting goods store were brutally murdered in what began as a robbery. A lone survivor, left for dead on the bloody floor, called police. Who within hours, tracked down, then killed, James Langston, as he tried to run officers down with his car. Langston had worked at the store. Police then arrested Timothy Bates, who led them to Lave. According to attorneys, it was unclear in the trial whether Bates and Lave handled weapons in the murders. The witness identified Langston and Bates, not Lave. Bates took a plea deal for life in prison. But he also took several polygraph - or lie detector - tests. Yet the 2nd test, according to Mike Ware, Assistant Dallas DA investigating this case, was never turned over to Lave's lawyers. Michael Ware, Assistant Dallas DA: One of biggest problems we had with non disclosure of this polygraph is that Mr. Lave's attorneys had consistently requested this polygraph and in fact it appears that misrepresentations were made to the courts in the post conviction proceedings - by attorneys no longer with this office, in the prior administration - that the polygraph didn't even exist. Zeeble: Ware said results of that test could've raised serious questions about the believability of Bates, who testified about Lave's involvement in the crime. Ware also said prosecutorial misrepresentation about this 2nd polygraph test affected Lave's court appeals. Ware: We didn't feel it would be right to allow the execution to go through without disclosing this information to Mr Lave's attorneys. Zeeble: Those attorneys are now going over the new evidence, which Ware said came to light in the just the past few days. That's why Dallas DA Craig Watkins requested the execution stay. It surprised Steve Hall, director of the Standown Texas Project which opposes the death penalty, & advocates for best practices in the criminal justice system. Steve Hall, Director of the Standown Texas Project: That's very unusual. I can't recall the last time in Texas it's happened. Zeeble: Supreme Courts stop executions. So do governors. Rick Perry did a few weeks back, when he commuted Kenneth Foster's death sentence to life without parole But DA's usually don't. They push the death sentence. Attorney Richard Franklin, Lave's first defense attorney, is satisfied by the news Richard Franklin, Lave Defense Attorney: Bates is serving life in prison. I think Bates and Lave should get the same punishment. There's no reason in the world for Lave to be executed and Bates not. Zeeble: For now, he won't be. It's up to lawyers and more investigators before any decision's made to re-try Lave, maintain the execution stay, or issue a new execution date. Lawyers say this case raises questions about the state's Law of Parties, which finds all participants equally guilty of heinous crimes. That law was an issue in this case, and the one in which Governor Perry commuted a death sentence. (source: KERA News) ********************************* Did Texas Execute an Innocent Man? Who Cares! A judge has blocked prosecutors from destroying a hair found at scene of the murder for which Claude Jones was convicted, and executed in 2000. DNA testing will now be done to determine if it matches Jones. It's not just any hair. It's the hair that prosecutors matched to the defendant at trial by way of a hair fiber analyst. Hair fiber analysis is, to say the least, an imperfect science. It has led to wrongful convictions before, and professional prosecution hair fiber witnesses have a history of exaggerating the certitude of their findings. I haven't read enough about this particular case to have an opinion on it. I note it mostly because of the following passage, which I find absolutely inexplicable: The groups, represented by attorneys at Mayer Brown LLP, filed the court motions Friday after the San Jacinto District Attorney refused to agree to DNA testing - and also refused to agree not to destroy the evidence while courts consider whether DNA testing can be conducted. Emphasis mine. Now, I can think of some reasons why a prosecutor would want to destroy a piece of physical evidence that could prove that the state executed an innocent man. But none of them are compatible with...um...being a human being. Perhaps, for example, the prosecutor was one of the prosecutors who worked on the case, and doesn't want the stain on his career that might come with a wrongful execution. Perhaps he wants to avoid the inevitable stain on Texas' already execution-happy reputation that would come with proof that the state executed an innocent man. Perhaps he knows that proof of a wrongful execution will make it much more difficult for him to win death penalty cases in the future. But here's the thing: While I can perhaps see a prosecutor harboring such sentiment deep down inside, I can't possibly conceive of anyone actually making these sorts of arguments publicly. Or with a straight face. Because, you see, if Texas did execute an innocent man, all of those things should happen. Because...well...because Texas...would have executed an innocent man. And if Texas did execute an innocent man, that Texans might find out about it-and subsequently raise understandable questions about the morality and efficacy of the death penalty-isn't something to be avoided, it's something that damned-well ought to happen. Because-at risk of repeating myself--Texas would have executed an innocent man. What possible not-devoid-of-all-morality argument could a prosecutor possibly make for being permitted to destroy evidence that might prove an innocent man was executed? I really can't think of one. (source: Radley Balko, Reason Online) ************************** DA's office remains on death row case The Tarrant County district attorney's office will not be removed from the appellate case of Death Row inmate Chelsea Richardson, at least for now. On Thursday, visiting state District Judge Steven Herod denied a motion by Bob Ford, Richardson's appellate attorney, to have the district attorney's office thrown off the case on allegations that prosecutors improperly asked state District Judge Everett Young to sign an order while Ford was on vacation. But the issue is far from over. Ford has cited a second reason why he thinks the district attorney's office should be removed from his client's appeal: prosecutorial misconduct. Herod did not take up that issue on Thursday and, instead, reset the hearing for Jan. 30. Here's a summary of the case and what is going on: The crime Richardson, 23, is on women's Death Row after being convicted of capital murder in the brutal slayings of her boyfriend's parents, Rick and Suzanna Wamsley. Officials have said Richardson, her boyfriend, Andrew Wamsley, and friend Susanna Toledano killed the couple so Andrew Wamsley could collect his parents' estate. Toledano and Wamsley are serving life sentences. Richardson, portrayed as the mastermind in the plot, received the death penalty. The appeal Ford, who is Richardson's court-appointed attorney, filed a post-conviction writ of habeas corpus, which basically alleges that Richardson was illegally convicted because of legal errors and misconduct. He wants to eventually win Richardson a new trial or have her sentence changed to life in prison. Among other things, Ford contends that the judge was biased, the defense attorneys were ineffective and the prosecutors were dishonest. Ford filed two separate motions seeking to have the district attorney's office removed from Richardson's appeal. Ford lost the first issue, which accused prosecutors of improperly asking Young to sign an order denying Ford a subpoena while Ford was on vacation. The second issue, which has not been decided, deals with alleged prosecutorial misconduct by prosecutor Mike Parrish. Ford alleges that Parrish interfered with Richardson's attorney-client privilege before her arrest when he failed to reveal to a judge or a grand jury foreman that he had been indirectly receiving information from her attorney's legal assistant about the case. Prosecutors Chuck Mallin and Steve Conder have not filed a response to Ford's allegations in his writ, but have said they are without merit. The prosecutors have 120 days from the date Ford filed his writ -- July 16 -- to file their response. They indicated Thursday that they plan to ask for a 60-day extension. What is next Judge Herod, an Eastland County judge appointed to hear the issues, wants Mallin and Conder to file their response to Ford's writ before he holds a hearing on whether to remove the district attorney's office from the case. He has recessed the case until Jan. 30. (source: Fort Worth Star-Telegram) *************************** SAPD is taking a bruising over reports of pummelings by cops The toughest job in the city might be trying to mask the black-and-blue face of the San Antonio Police Department. I don't know if there's enough makeup in South Texas to cover the bruising. The latest blow comes from the arrest of officer Bryan Baldwin. He's been charged with assaulting a man in a North St. Mary's Street parking lot. The arrest affidavit says Baldwin repeatedly punched Rogelio Romero in the face. True or not, allegations of officer misconduct are hitting San Antonio like the rat-a-tat-tat of an assault rifle. For those struggling to keep up: Ten women recently sued the city, alleging female officers subjected them to humiliating strip searches without cause. 4 men say one officer subjected them to illegal body cavity searches. SAPD recently fired detective Keith Alfaro after he was charged with assaulting an 18-year-old woman. SAPD placed officer Shane Sizemore on administrative duty in July after he was charged with assaulting his girlfriend. The city agreed 2 weeks ago to pay $80,000 to a 25-year-old man who was shot by a police officer. "I think the shooting was unjustified and shouldn't have been done," Mayor Phil Hardberger told the Express-News. "I think we were in the wrong." Now there's something you don't often hear. We were wrong. SAPD seems to have a hard time saying that. The department did not say it after former Assistant Chief Jerry Pittman alarmed police with an extramarital, bloody motel sheet incident. SAPD let Pittman "retire." The department did not apologize after auditors said former Assistant Chief Tyrone Powers obstructed a review of a multimillion-dollar computer disaster. SAPD allowed Powers to "retire." The department did not blush when it promoted a man who slept with a prostitute to assistant chief. Instead, Police Chief Bill McManus defended his new hire. The department did not admit to wrongdoing after an officer was reprimanded for an improper strip search. The chief wrote to the victim, saying "corrective action" had been taken. I could go on, but this is a column - not an encyclopedia. Suffice it to say that complaints of officer abuse, assaults, unlawful search and seizures and racial profiling are piling up, and SAPD reacts predictably: We'll look into it. For the record, citizens filed 133 formal or serious complaints with Internal Affairs from Jan. 13 through Aug. 23. Officers say many others were lodged but never found their way to Internal Affairs. Out of this muck steps Tamara Vaughan, an 18-year-old who says an off-duty detective assaulted her at a community pool. After she appeared on TV with a bruised face, SAPD hastened an Internal Affairs investigation of Alfaro. Alfaro lost his job. He still faces criminal charges, but that's not all. Vaughan is black, and says Alfaro used a racial slur before attacking her. The FBI initiated a Civil Rights violations case against Alfaro and has forwarded its findings to the U.S. Attorney's Office. When will this end? The case of 18-year-old Erin McCutchen is just beginning. McCutchen says she got drunk, passed out and knocked out the window of a patrol car. But she also has swollen black eyes and broken facial bones from a police beating while she was handcuffed. The officer says he struck McCutchen in the head to protect her from oncoming traffic. Whatever the truth here, the beatings are taking a toll. If you haven't noticed, SAPD looks a lot like McCutchen's pummeled face. (source: San Antonio Express-News) ********************* U.S. sues Dallas County, sheriff over jail conditions Federal prosecutors allege in a lawsuit that inmates at the Dallas County Jail are at risk of harm because of unsafe jail conditions and a lack of proper health care. The U.S. Attorney's Office asked the court to require Dallas County to take actions to correct deficiencies at the jail, among the largest complexes in the country. In a lawsuit filed Wednesday, the federal government contends Dallas County and Sheriff Lupe Valdez have known about problems at the jail for some time but have failed to address them adequately. By failing to fix the inadequacies, the rights of the inmates were violated, the suit said. "Through the acts and omissions...Defendants have exhibited deliberate indifference to the health and safety of Dallas County Jail inmates," the suit said. The federal government says court action is necessary to effect change. A telephone message left Thursday afternoon for a sheriff's spokesman was not immediately returned. A message left Thursday evening at the office of Dallas County Judge Jim Foster wasn't immediately returned. Federal officials contend the jail hasn't provided adequate medical and mental health care to inmates and hasn't ensured a safe and sanitary environment for detainees, the lawsuit contends. "This problem has been simmering and festering for at least 10 years," said David Finn, a Dallas attorney and former judge. Earlier this year, county officials approved a nearly $1 million settlement with the families of three mentally ill inmates who were denied medication while in the jail. A little more than half of the award went to James Mims, a jail inmate whose psychiatric medications were withheld for two months in 2004. Mims nearly died when water was shut off in his cell for two weeks, said Finn, who represented the inmate. The problems aren't just in dealing with mentally ill inmates, but also extend to people who require medication, such as diabetics, said Finn. "We're talking about basic health care. If people treated animals this way, they would be ... prosecuted," he said. A federal report sent to Dallas officials in December said the jail violated the constitutional rights of inmates by failing to provide adequate medical and mental health care. A separate report from February 2005 found that lapses in medical care in the Dallas County jail system resulted in undetected illnesses, excess costs and risks to the public. That report was produced at the request of then-County Judge Margaret Keliher. The Texas Commission on Jail Standards warned the county earlier this year to fix jail staffing problems or face possible closure. Jail officials said then they want to get the population down to about 6,000. They've held as many as 7,770 inmates. Valdez, who was elected more than 2 years ago, is responsible for the county's 5 jail facilities. The complex houses both detainees awaiting trial and sentenced inmates. (source: Associated Press) *************************************** Texas death row inmate wins another appeal----Court says jury did not get proper instruction in Houston case The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals has for the second time handed convicted killer Raymond DeLeon Martinez, sentenced to die for the 1983 robbery-murder of a Houston tavern owner, a chance to avoid execution. In a unanimous ruling handed down this week, the court invalidated Martinez's 1989 death sentence and remanded the case to the trial court for another punishment hearing. If Martinez is sentenced to life, he would be eligible for parole consideration. Writing for the court, Judge Barbara Parker Hervey found that state District Judge Bob Burdette's charge to the jurors in 1989 failed to provide them with a vehicle for considering possible mitigating evidence, specifically Martinez's history of mental illness. The ruling marks the second time the high court has intervened on Martinez's behalf. In 1988, the court overturned his 1984 capital murder conviction and ordered a new trial, citing irregularities in jury selection. Martinez, 61, described by authorities as a one-time leader in the Texas Syndicate prison gang, was condemned for the July 1983 murder-robbery of Herman Chavis. Prosecutors in the 1989 trial argued that Martinez and his accomplices, James Kirtley and Antonio Rojas, robbed Chavis' tavern to raise money to set up a methamphetamine lab and a marijuana-rowing operation. Kirtley was sentenced to 25 years in prison; Rojas, 50. Assistant District Attorney Lynn Hardaway, who has represented the state in the case's most recent stage, said the decision on whether to again push for the death penalty will be made by District Attorney Chuck Rosenthal. "This was a bad case," she said. "His own family testified against him." At the time of his 1984 trial, Martinez also had been charged with capital murder in the death of Moses Mendez, a Houston bar patron; aggravated robbery in a Houston tavern stickup; murder in the Fort Worth deaths of his sister, Julia Gonzales, and her boyfriend, Guillermo Chavez; and murder in the Houston killing of Tracy Lynn Pelkey. All those crimes occurred in 1983. In its latest ruling, the court of appeals noted that evidence at Martinez's 1989 trial revealed that he had been imprisoned 14 years prior to being paroled in December 1982. In the next eight months, prosecutors argued at the trial, he left "a trail of bodies everywhere." Evidence presented at trial suggested Martinez committed the crimes to enhance his standing in the prison gang. In 1967, a Comanche County jury found Martinez not guilty of a burglary charge by reason of insanity. He was sent to Rusk State Hospital, where he was treated until October 1968 when he was released after his sanity was deemed "restored." He was treated 3 times at the Wichita Falls State Hospital between December 1966 and October 1968. Texas Department of Criminal Justice spokeswoman Michelle Lyons said Martinez will remain on death row at Livingston's Polunksy Unit until court orders are forwarded to prison officials. (source: Houston Chronicle) ***************************8 Suspect named in girls death Navarro County law enforcement officials announced the arrest of Kevin Wayne Anders, 32, of Purdon for possession of child pornography and named him as the "primary suspect in the sexual assault and murder of Hanna Mack." Mack is the 6-year-old girl found dead Monday morning, hanged in the garage at her family's residence. A medical examiners preliminary findings, released Wednesday, confirmed that a sexual assault had also taken place and listed the cause of death as "homicidal violence." Anders was arrested late Wednesday evening after NCSO officials discovered pornographic images of children on a computer from the crime scene. It is likely the same computer the Daily Sun reported had been taken Tuesday to the crime lab of the Texas Department of Public Safety in Waco. "Anders was the male residing in the same house with the family of little Hanna Mack, who was found murdered this past Monday," Cox said, reading prepared remarks to a crowd of local and Dallas Metroplex media representatives at a press conference held in the justice of the peace courtroom. "Anders was located at a residence in western Navarro County and was taken into custody without incident." Precinct 1 Justice of the Peace Vicki Gray issued the arrest warrant Wednesday and arraigned Anders on the child pornography charges Thursday morning, setting the suspects bond at $100,000. "He remains in the Navarro County jail and is the current primary suspect in the sexual assault and murder of Hanna Mack," Cox said. "Investigators are continuing to follow all investigative leads in the case as they await details from the crime laboratory." The crime lab reference likely refers to DNA evidence law enforcement officials have had ample time to collect, and would be a necessary next step in the investigation. Typical DNA analysis and comparisons take up to 6 weeks before results are returned to the requesting agency. Hanna Mack's death qualifies under the capital murder statute and could be subject to the death penalty. Anders' present child pornography charge is a 3rd degree felony. Anders will likely claim to be indigent and request legal counsel be appointed. Only 2 Navarro County lawyers are certified to represent a criminal defendant in a death penalty case Rob Dunn and Kerri Anderson Donica, both Corsicana attorneys. It is believed that Donica handled the last such case, that of Michael Zoch, who was accused of sexually assaulting and killing his stepdaughter, 10-year-old April Bryant. (source: Athens Review) ******************************* Defendant's relative weeps for cops, They're talking everywhere else in West Texas and Eastern New Mexico about last weekend's slayings of 3 Odessa policemen but still not much above a whisper in this traumatized city, where a tearful, grief-bowed relative of the man charged with the slayings read a brief statement and fled an 11 a. m. Thursday news conference without taking questions. Patricia Burke, who said she is a cousin of Larry Neil White's wife Judy but declined to say where she lives, had called reporters to a perhaps symbolically weeping fountain in Nol Heritage Park Plaza on West Fifth Street near downtown to express sympathy for the families of slain OPD Officers Scott Gardner, Arlie Jones and Abel Marquez. "On behalf of our family, all we can say is that our thoughts and prayers are with the families of the officers," Burke said. "We're still in shock over what happened Saturday." Breaking into tears and barely able to finish her handwritten statement, the woman sobbed, "We are fully cooperating with the law enforcement and trying to deal with this tragedy. We would appreciate any respect for our privacy that you can give us." When asked if she could provide more insights about White, a Marine Corps Vietnam veteran with a reported drinking problem, Burke said, "We may be able to offer further information later." She arrived and left with KOSA TV, Channel 7, reporter Melissa Correa, who said White's wife has been staying with relatives "in the area" since leaving her 2912 Ventura Ave. home just inside Loop 338 near West University Boulevard, where the shotgun shootings took place in the backyard. Mrs. White had called 911 at 6:01 p.m. Saturday to say her husband was intoxicated and had been beating her, according to OPD records. Ector County District Attorney Bobby Bland is awaiting a report from the Texas Rangers but indicated Thursday afternoon that he expects to seek White's execution by lethal injection in the Texas Department of Criminal Justice. "Until I get the Rangers' file, I can only tell you I will seek justice for these fallen officers," Bland said. "I can't make a formal decision until then, but I can say there is a reason the death penalty exists. "The Rangers are being very thorough and they have been good about keeping us updated on the investigation. The next step will be presenting the case to a grand jury. "The community is heartbroken and devastated, but we have come together to support the Odessa Police Department and law enforcement. I think with time, we'll slowly get better." The defendant's court-appointed lawyer, H.W. "Woody" Leverett Jr. of Midland, said he must of necessity limit his comments. Named on Tuesday to defend White by 70th District Court Judge Denn Whalen, Leverett is one of fewer than a half dozen Permian Basin lawyers qualified by the State Bar of Texas to represent someone against whom the death penalty is being sought. "It's difficult for everybody," said Leverett, acknowledging he had just met with his client at Ector County Jail but declining to tell anything more about him or his current state of mind. "I know there is a lot of curiosity and interest in this case, but if I start trying it in the media, there will be no end to it," said Leverett Thursday. Thousands of mourners, many in uniform from throughout the region and beyond, attended Wednesday's funerals of Jones and Gardner and lined Odessa streets en route to Sunset Memorial Gardens. A Hubbard Kelly Funeral Home spokeswoman said services were pending there for Marquez, who died at 3:10 p.m. Wednesday at University Medical Center in Lubbock just as Jones' services were being completed with full police honors. "The family has not come in and the body is not here yet," she said. White is accused of shooting all 3 men in the head with a 12-gauge shotgun firing heavy buckshot. Gardner and Jones were found dead in the backyard, but Associated Press reporter Betsy Blaney said Marquez spoke with his mother on a cell phone on the way to Medical Center Hospital, got out of the OPD patrol car in which he was transported and incredibly walked under his own power into the emergency room before finally losing consciousness on a table, never to regain it. (source: Midland Reporter-Telegram) **************************** Rubio's Lawyer Speaks Out About Court Decision----Man accused of murder will return to Valley In Brownsville, an attorney for John Allen Rubio still insists his client was insane at the time he murdered his 3 children. An appeals court overturned Rubio's conviction. Nat Perez says he never agreed with the death penalty verdict. He was Rubio's court appointed attorney. The prosecution's evidence included written and videotaped testimony from Rubio's common-law wife, Angela Camacho. Perez says, "When we went to trial, the state didn't seek to admit just one confession from Camacho. They admitted all 3. And from her statements, each said something different. And so it's right there - face value that you have unreliability," The Texas Court of Appeals says that evidence shouldn't have been allowed at all, since the defense wasn't able to challenge the statements or Camacho herself. Since the conviction was overturned, Rubio is no longer on death row. He'll have to be tried all over again. He's expected back in Cameron County sometime soon. We've learned Perez is still Rubio's attorney of record. But as of right now, it is unknown whether or not he'll represent Rubio in his retrial. (source: News Channel 5)
[Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS
Rick Halperin Fri, 14 Sep 2007 17:03:34 -0500 (Central Daylight Time)
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin
- [Deathpenalty] death penalty news-----TEXAS Rick Halperin