Oct. 20
KENTUCKY:
Ky. Human Rights Commission: End death penalty
The Kentucky Commission on Human Rights has called on the state to end the use
of the death penalty, saying it is often applied unfairly against minorities
and the poor.
The commissioners, who enforce state and federal civil rights laws, urged
Kentucky lawmakers in a resolution last week to repeal the law that allows the
use of the death penalty in some murder cases.
The resolution unanimously passed by the commissioners will be submitted to Go.
Steve Beshear and to each state legislator.
As of April 1, Kentucky had 35 inmates on death row. Kentucky last executed an
inmate in 2008.
State Sen. Gerald Neal of Louisville told The Courier-Journal that lawmakers
have considered abolishing capital punishment, but have never passed
legislation doing so.
(source: Associated Press)
CALIFORNIA:
Saturday Forum letters; Letters from our readers
Death penalty is morally wrong
I'll vote to abolish the death penalty, as almost all modern societies have
done, and not just because it is fiscally imprudent with unsustainable costs
versus a life sentence without possibility of parole. More importantly -- just
as we all agree, "Thou shalt not kill" -- it's morally wrong.
Making us and the state murderers -- through exercising the death penalty --
is a pure illogicality akin to saying "two wrongs make a right."
Worse, because juries and evidence are fallible, my Christian belief tells me
it is better that we let 1,000 guilty murderers get life sentences than we kill
even one innocent defendant.
We know 139 death-row inmates have been exonerated since 1973 and the death
penalty is inconsistently and capriciously applied to minorities far more often
than whites committing the same crime.
Lastly, with mandatory and spurious death penalty appeals stretching this
sordid process out for 25 years or more, victims' families are denied closure.
It is wiser to abolish the death penalty.
Ed Chainey----Richmond
******
Opposes repeal of the death penalty
If the death penalty proposition was modified to state that murder committed in
the heat of the moment or the result of uncontrollable emotion is not subject
to the death penalty, I would support it.
However, some crimes are so heinous -- premeditated murder; murder for profit;
murder during the commission of another crime; rape/murder; child rape and
murder; torture/murder; murder during terrorist activity; and kidnap/murder --
the perpetrators do not deserve to be allowed to contaminate our society, even
in prison, with their presence.
Nevertheless, great care must be exercised that the accused is, in fact,
guilty. It is a sin against the tenets of our civilization, and of God, to rush
into a conviction that is not supported, beyond all doubt, with
incontrovertible evidence.
Although most convictions of murderers are justified, there have been too many
cases of passion, rather than facts, convicting a person. This must not be
allowed to happen and a law that sends a falsely convicted person to death row
or life in prison is not an acceptable solution.
Ernest Hampson----Pittsburg
****
Alternative is too expensive
I will be voting for the death penalty.
The alternatives to the death penalty are too expensive. It's cheaper to kill
someone and not pay someone to guard them for the rest of their lives. And the
appeal process costs too much; change that.
The argument that you might kill the wrong guy might have been valid 20 years
ago when DNA was new, but now we can be 100 percent sure it's the right guy.
The only way the death penalty will ever be a deterrent is to use it.
Bill Jones----Pleasant Hill
****
Mother of slain teen wants to keep penalty
As the mother of a teenager who was senselessly murdered, I will vote no on
outlawing the death penalty in California. Enough said.
Gloria Gates----Fremont
****
Outlawing would send wrong kind of message
Outlawing the death penalty is eliminating a deterrent to commit major crimes.
What kind of message would this send to criminals?
Jerry Collins----Antioch
****
Should not fight for the 'disgusting' murderers
The reason why it costs so much to execute convicted killers is that the ACLU
and other left-wing organizations keep fighting for every disgusting murderer.
We should make those organization reimburse the taxpayers for all the extra
costs, and the press should not actively solicit their opinions.
Gary Lavagnino----El Sobrante
****
A person who kills should be put to death
I will vote no on the measure to repeal the death penalty. To kill another
human being is against the law and the person who killed another person should
receive the death penalty.
My sister was murdered and the person found guilty was given 25 years to life
in prison. He will be up for parole in 2015. The district attorney said he will
be denied and will never leave prison.
She was killed in Nebraska, where the death penalty is only given in the case
of a horrendous crime. In my eyes, death by strangulation is a horrendous
crime.
He should have been put to death because her family and mine suffered a great
lose. I will never forgive him and I will never get over the loss of my dear
sister.
Those who want to repeal the death penalty have not experienced the pain of
having a loved one taken.
Robert V. Beaudreau----Fremont
****
Death penalty is not a deterrent
I've been opposed to the death penalty for about 60 years.
It's a subject I've researched exhaustively. Rarely have I succumbed to the
intense passion that's unavoidable when murder is discussed.
Unlike most people who support this punishment, I can discuss it intelligently
and factually, and without the sarcasm and exaggeration that's usually an
integral part of this argument.
There's no evidence capital punishment is a deterrent to murder. Its inherent
flaws make it impossible to administer it without prejudice and to the
exclusion of error.
Strident supporters of executions dismissively ignore the stark terror
experienced by an innocent person who waits for the state to commit judicially
sanctioned murder.
It's inarguable that substituting life imprisonment without the possibility of
parole protects society, genuinely punishes murderers, and eliminates the
dreadful possibility of executing an innocent person.
I flatly refuse to have the execution of an innocent person on my conscience.
That moral judgment dictates my affirmative vote for Proposition 34.
Ronald Entwistle----San Pablo
(source: Mercury News)
**************************
Time for California to kill the death penalty
Closure, by definition, should not be open-ended.
So it's beyond sad that the death penalty is no death sentence in California.
Closure? The state with the most death row inmates - more than the next 2
states combined - offers something closer to torture for the victims' loved
ones: It can take decades to exhaust a convicted killer???s appeals.
Here's a much more timely appeal for you: End capital punishment in California.
Do it by supporting Proposition 34 in the Nov. 6 election. The statewide
measure would replace capital punishment with life in prison without the
possibility of parole, proactively and retroactively. It would eliminate the
myth of closure and, more importantly, a huge drain on California's coffers.
It's time to turn California's capital punishment into what it effectively is
now: A life sentence in prison without parole - a punishment that remains a
deterrent for most people contemplating heinous crimes.
Let's put this in perspective: California has executed just 13 people since
reinstating capital punishment in 1978. It has 726 people on death row now, 40
from San Diego County.
At that rate, these inmates will all suffer their sentenced fate in just about
1,900 years. No, that's not possible. The point is this: Most will die of old
age, not their choice of lethal injection or gas.
Exhibit A for that argument? 57 death row inmates have died of natural causes
while awaiting capital punishment in California since 1978. That's more than 4
times as many as have been killed on command.
Over that same span, 3 death row inmates were exonerated as innocent.
It's this possibility, along with the promise of due process and protections
against killing an innocent person, that have combined to extend the California
appeals process for decades.
The 1st person sent to death row after California restored the death penalty 34
years ago? He's still there, pursuing his appeals.
The last inmate to be executed was killed 23 years after his conviction.
More recently, the number of death row inmates has gone up instead of down
because of a judge-imposed moratorium on executions in place since 2006.
These lengthy prison stays are not cheap.
By 1 count, it costs about $90,000 a year to house a prisoner on death row,
more than 3 times the $28,000 average cost of incarcerating other prisoners.
In all, the state has spent $4 billion on administering capital punishment
since 1978. Do the math: That's $308 million per execution.
It takes so long for inmates to be executed that a 2011 study projected the
state's capital punishment tab would top $9 billion by 2030. The study
estimated California spends $184 million a year housing inmates on death row
beyond what the state would spend if they had life sentences.
If passed, the measure would mean the state must direct some of that money -
about $100 million over 4 years - to local law enforcement for more DNA
testing, crime labs and other tools used in police investigations.
Supporters say that priority shift will be a boon for a state that typically
doesn't solve about 1/2 its murders and more than half its rapes. Opponents
counter that the change would weaken public-safety laws.
Fact check: It wouldn't. No prisoner would be released to kill again.
Condemned inmates may not live in private cells if they get off death row, but
that's a far cry from being free. They'll stay in prison without the state
paying for special housing or, more importantly, attorneys' fees.
Look, we can all agree that arguing over the death penalty on a philosophical
level is counterproductive, especially with prosecutors, cops and victims who
see it as a deterrent and an eye-for-an-eye punishment.
But weighing its worth on a financial level? That's a conviction to share.
Here's an idea: Take the money that California would save without the death
penalty and spend it on law enforcement to cut down on murders.
Better yet, spend it on education to cut down on murderers.
(source: San Diego Union-Tribune)
COLORADO:
The other death-penalty decision facing the new DA
This week's feature, "Lethal Election," explores how the race for district
attorney in the 18th Judicial District has drawn a national spotlight because
the winner will have to decide whether to pursue the death penalty in
prosecuting James Holmes, the suspect in the Aurora theater shootings. It's a
hot topic, with one candidate accusing the other of "politicizing" the Holmes
case on his Facebook page. But there's another life-or-death call pending in
that district that nobody's talking about -- one the incoming DA will have to
make shortly after taking office.
All 3 of the current occupants of Colorado's less-than-active death row were
convicted in Arapahoe County, the most populous of the 18th's 4 counties. The
state hasn't executed anyone since 1997, but there's a good chance Chuck E.
Cheese killer Nathan Dunlap could have a date with the lethal injection gurney
next year, after nearly 2 decades of legal wrangling. Fighting against his
appeals, and those of fellow death-row inmates Robert Ray and Sir Mario Owens,
is primarily the job of the Colorado Attorney General's Office -- although
claims of prosecutorial misconduct in the Ray and Owens trials may yet drag the
DA's office back into the fray. At the same time, current DA Carol Chambers's
capital crimes squad has been leading the charge to put 1 other convicted
killer on death row: Edward Montour, Jr.
In 2002 Montour, already serving a life sentence for killing his infant
daughter, fatally attacked correctional officer Eric Autobee in an apparent
effort to improve his bottom-feeder status at the Limon prison. He pleaded
guilty to 1st degree murder, but the Colorado Supreme Court threw out his death
sentence for that homicide in 2007 because it hadn't been imposed by a jury.
Chambers's office has been seeking to get the death penalty reinstated in his
case for the past 5 years.
A resentencing hearing is scheduled for February -- and the new district
attorney will have to quickly decide whether to keep pushing for death, given
the brinkmanship and hardball tactics of Montour's defense team. "We are on the
cusp of filing a motion to withdraw his guilty plea," says Montour attorney
David Lane. "That would put us all back at square one. It would be foolish, in
my estimation, for the DA's office to jeopardize an in-the-bag 1st-degree
murder conviction just for all the fun of trying to kill Edward Montour."
Lane says his client has offered not to contest his murder conviction and "stay
in a little supermax cell for the rest of his life" if the prosecution will
forego its quest for execution. The arrangement, he says, would save the state
considerable time and money in future appeals: "They can end it now, or they
can continue to pursue the death penalty, which would probably prolong it for
another 20 years."
Such an ultimatum may not have much traction with either candidate, Republican
George Brauchler or Democrat Ethan Feldman, who have declined to speak about
what they'd do in specific cases until after the election. In public forums,
both men have stressed the importance of keeping the death penalty as an option
in the most heinous cases -- and hang the cost, so to speak. But it's been ten
years since Montour committed his last bit of heinousness, ten years in which
his ultimate sentence -- life in isolation or execution? -- remains unresolved.
And, as Nathan Dunlap's experience demonstrates, in Colorado one can be
condemned to die and still live on -- and on -- for decades to come.
(source: Denver Westword)
GEORGIA:
Gwinnett death-penalty trial opens
A blind and mentally challenged woman, an 11-year-old girl, a 19-year-old man
and a 28-year-old woman lay dead or dying behind her when Gifty Kargbo fled in
stark terror from a house in Lawrenceville on Aug. 27, 2009.
On the witness stand Friday, Kargbo shakily pointed toward a defendant wearing
a gray suit, blue shirt and red tie and identified the man, Richard Ringold, as
the person she said shot them all. On the 1st day of testimony in Ringold's
death-penalty trial in Gwinnett County, prosecutors told jurors Ringold went on
a shooting rampage after arguing with his girlfriend, Atania Butler.
Ringold had moved his belongings into Butler's house the day before, and on
that day she learned that he had been 2-timing her with another woman for about
a year and a half, prosecutors said.
Kargbo, a close friend of Butler's, said Butler was upset about her boyfriend's
philandering. Just before the shooting, Butler and Ringold had been arguing for
about an hour outside Butler's home on Clairidge Lane in Lawrenceville. As
Butler stepped across the threshold to come back inside, she called out for a
friend who was in the living room, Kargbo said.
Ringold was a step behind her with a gun, Kargbo said.
"He shot her in the back of the head and he kind of hesitated," said Kargbo.
"Once he did that, he walked through the house aiming and shooting at everyone
else."
Butler's daughters Jhane, 11, and Nhaje, 4, had been playing video games in the
living room while Kargbo relaxed nearby with her boyfriend, Rico Zimmerman, 19,
who also lived with the Butlers; and LaKeisha Parker, a 30-year-old blind and
mentally challenged woman that Zimmerman was hired to care for.
Ringold is accused of shooting all of 5 of them except Kargbo, who escaped out
the front door and ran to a neighbor's home a few doors down for help. The only
other survivor was 4-year-old Nhaje, who was shot 2 or 3 times.
Gwinnett County District Attorney Danny Porter said Nhaje told the officers who
came to the house, "Rich shot my family." The little girl, who is expected to
testify Monday or Tuesday, did not appear to be bleeding very much, and she
didn't want to take off her T-shirt because it was one that her mother had
given her, Porter said.
Ringold's capital defense attorney, Gladys Haynes Pollard, told jurors in her
opening statement that she would call into question some of the witnesses'
credibility. She said the woman who was in an 18-month relationship with
Ringold will testify he wouldn't have had the opportunity to be in a
relationship with Butler at the same time.
She said the 9 mm handgun used in the slayings was never found. She urged
jurors to keep an open mind.
"There's 2 sides to every story," Pollard said.
A court-appointed defense attorney who represented Ringold for a brief period
shortly after his arrest has previously said that Ringold had an alibi for the
day of the slayings and that he was playing video games with friends when the
crime occurred. However, Pollard made no mention of an alibi on Friday.
Prosecutors said Ringold could be the 1st person sentenced to the death penalty
in Gwinnett County in a decade.
Ringold's case is the 1st death-penalty trial in Gwinnett County since 2005. In
that 2005 case, a jury convicted Wesley Harris of the November 1999 murders of
22-year-old Whitney Land and her 2-year-old daughter, Jordan, but deadlocked in
a 10-2 vote when trying to decide if Harris should be executed. Harris was
sentenced to life in prison without parole.
Ringold's trial is projected to last about a week.
(source: Atlanta Journal-Constitution)
MONTANA:
Montana execution protocol to be put on trial; Cdn Ronald Smith on death row
A Montana judge has scheduled a trial for next summer as the state attempts to
bypass a requirement that it needs to get approval from its legislature to
change the way it carries out executions.
A ruling by Montana District Court Judge Jeffrey Sherlock in September declared
the state's method of execution unconstitutional, giving hope to Canadian
Ronald Smith, who is facing execution for the 1982 murders of 2 young Montana
men.
But the State of Montana has convinced Sherlock to hear its arguments in an
attempt bypass a requirement to get approval from the legislature to change the
way it carries out its executions.
"The state had indicated they believed they could change the protocol and
comply with the statute," said lead lawyer Ron Waterman of the American Civil
Liberties Union in an interview with The Canadian Press.
"I don't think that's possible but nevertheless that's what they've told the
court so the judge said, all right, we can have a hearing on that."
Waterman said a three-day hearing has been scheduled for July 22, 2013 but it
is likely the matter will be resolved through a request for a summary judgment
from Sherlock before then.
The ACLU filed a civil lawsuit in 2008 on behalf of Smith and another death row
inmate that argued the lethal injection the state uses is cruel and unusual
punishment and violates the right to human dignity.
In his Sept. 6 ruling Judge Sherlock pointed to problems such as lack of
training for individuals who administer the drugs and a discrepancy over
whether 2 or 3 drugs should be used. He also questioned the method used to
determine if an inmate is actually unconscious before receiving the lethal
injection.
"The Montana protocol has problems," Sherlock said in his 26-page judgment.
"All 3 of these concerns create a substantial risk of serious harm violative of
the plaintiff's right to be protected from cruel and unusual punishment."
Sherlock indicated the state legislature needed to rejig the statutes to bring
the execution protocol into line with Montana's constitution -- something the
Attorney General's office is now hoping to avoid. The legislature route is
complex and both Waterman and legislators have indicated it might be a steep
hill to climb to get the changes through.
"It's one of those sort of things that's a little bit irritating. The fact of
the matter is that what the judge said was it's not the question of whether the
death penalty is unconstitutional -- it is the question of whether the protocol
is unconstitutional," Waterman said.
"That always means that they could amend the protocol on the statute. There's
always that potential."
Smith, originally from Red Deer, Alta., has been running out of legal options
since he was convicted in Montana in 1983 for shooting Harvey Madman Jr. and
Thomas Running Rabbit, while he was high on drugs and alcohol near East
Glacier, Mont.
He had been taking 30 to 40 hits of LSD and consuming between 12 and 18 beers a
day at the time of the murders. He refused a plea deal that would have seen him
avoid death row and spend the rest of his life in prison. 3 weeks later, he
pleaded guilty. He asked for and was given a death sentence.
Smith later had a change of heart and has had a number of execution dates set
and overturned. He is currently waiting to see if Montana Gov. Brian Schweitzer
will grant him clemency.
Waterman said he is surprised that the State of Montana is attempting to bypass
the current process but said he did expect it would attempt to do something. He
said it's obvious the attorney general's assessment of the legislative
challenges coincides with his belief that it would be difficult to achieve.
"They're seeing that as something they want to avoid if they can," he said,
adding he remains optimistic.
"I'm confident that what we have is a stay that is continuing and it's
obviously going to continue for a while yet."
(source: CTV News)
_______________________________________________
DeathPenalty mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.washlaw.edu/mailman/listinfo/deathpenalty
Search the Archives: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
A free service of WashLaw
http://washlaw.edu
(785)670.1088
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~