Le lundi, 25 février 2019, 14.58:09 h CET Didier 'OdyX' Raboud a écrit : > I call for vote immediately on the following resolution. > > === Resolution === > > The Technical Committee resolves to decline to override the debootstrap > maintainers. > > Furthermore, using its §6.1.5 "Offering advice" power, the Technical > Committee considers that the desirable solution at the time of `bullseye` > is: > > * W: `weak`: both directory schemes are allowed, but packages should only > be built on hosts with classical directory schemes (or in such > chroots) > > * M: `middle`: both directory schemes are allowed, and packages (including > official packages) can be built on hosts with either > classical or "merged `/usr`" directory schemes > > * H: `hard`: both directory schemes are allowed, but packages should only > be built on hosts with "merged `/usr`" directory schemes (or in > such chroots) > > * FD: Further Discussion > > === End Resolution ===
Dear all,
with 6 votes in, and one week gone, the outcome of this vote is still in
doubt; here's an abstract of the vote calculation (a clearsigned verbose
version is attached):
/--WMHF
V: 3214 odyx
V: 2134 bremner
V: 4213 gwolf
V: 3124 ntyni
V: 2134 marga
V: 4213 fil
Option
W M H F
=== === === ===
Option W 0 2 4
Option M 6 3 6
Option H 4 3 6
Option F 2 0 0
Option W Reached quorum: 4 >= 2
Option M Reached quorum: 6 >= 2
Option H Reached quorum: 6 >= 2
Option W passes Majority. 2.000 (4/2) > 1
Option M defeats Option W by ( 6 - 0) = 6 votes.
Option H defeats Option W by ( 4 - 2) = 2 votes.
Option W defeats Option F by ( 4 - 2) = 2 votes.
Option M defeats Option F by ( 6 - 0) = 6 votes.
Option H defeats Option F by ( 6 - 0) = 6 votes.
- -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
The winners are:
Option M `middle`
Option H `hard`
- -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
So. We have a tie, and the voting period is over. I am quite confident we can
neither continue discussing (FD lost to M and H unanimously, and to W by 2),
nor allow smcv to vote (the voting period is over). We're left with the
Chair's casting vote (as per §6.3.2). So…
Dear Marga, as Chair, could you please make use of your casting vote to break
this tie?
Cheers,
OdyX-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA512
Starting results calculation at Mon Mar 4 15:34:31 2019
/--WMHF
V: 3214 odyx
V: 2134 bremner
V: 4213 gwolf
V: 3124 ntyni
V: 2134 marga
V: 4213 fil
Option W "`weak`: both directory schemes are allowed, but packages should only
be built on hosts with classical directory schemes (or in such chroots)"
Option M "`middle`: both directory schemes are allowed, and packages (including
official packages) can be built on hosts with either classical or "merged
`/usr`" directory schemes"
Option H "`hard`: both directory schemes are allowed, but packages should only
be built on hosts with "merged `/usr`" directory schemes (or in such chroots)"
Option F "Further Discussion"
In the following table, tally[row x][col y] represents the votes that
option x received over option y.
Option
W M H F
=== === === ===
Option W 0 2 4
Option M 6 3 6
Option H 4 3 6
Option F 2 0 0
Looking at row 2, column 1, M
received 6 votes over W
Looking at row 1, column 2, W
received 0 votes over M.
Option W Reached quorum: 4 >= 2
Option M Reached quorum: 6 >= 2
Option H Reached quorum: 6 >= 2
Option W passes Majority. 2.000 (4/2) > 1
Option M defeats Option W by ( 6 - 0) = 6 votes.
Option H defeats Option W by ( 4 - 2) = 2 votes.
Option W defeats Option F by ( 4 - 2) = 2 votes.
Option M defeats Option F by ( 6 - 0) = 6 votes.
Option H defeats Option F by ( 6 - 0) = 6 votes.
The Schwartz Set contains:
Option M "`middle`: both directory schemes are allowed, and packages
(including official packages) can be built on hosts with either classical or
"merged `/usr`" directory schemes"
Option H "`hard`: both directory schemes are allowed, but packages
should only be built on hosts with "merged `/usr`" directory schemes (or in
such chroots)"
- -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
- -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
The winners are:
Option M "`middle`: both directory schemes are allowed, and packages
(including official packages) can be built on hosts with either classical or
"merged `/usr`" directory schemes"
Option H "`hard`: both directory schemes are allowed, but packages
should only be built on hosts with "merged `/usr`" directory schemes (or in
such chroots)"
- -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
- -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----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=u0bf
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part.
