Your message dated Sat, 05 May 2007 17:02:06 +0200
with message-id <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
and subject line Bug#422172: Buggy initramfs-tools of "etch" when using MD with 
encryption and LVM
has caused the attached Bug report to be marked as done.

This means that you claim that the problem has been dealt with.
If this is not the case it is now your responsibility to reopen the
Bug report if necessary, and/or fix the problem forthwith.

(NB: If you are a system administrator and have no idea what I am
talking about this indicates a serious mail system misconfiguration
somewhere.  Please contact me immediately.)

Debian bug tracking system administrator
(administrator, Debian Bugs database)

--- Begin Message ---
Package: initramfs-tools
Version: Debian 4.0r0 network-CD or DVD1 "etch"

Hello,

when I setup following disc strukture: 

 /boot       SWAP           /       /var    /usr    /home    /misc
,--------, ,--------, ,--+--------+-------+-------+--------+--------+--, -----
| BOOT   | | SWAP   | |  |  ROOT  |  VAR  |  USR  |  HOME  |  MISC  |  |   ^
`---*----´ `---*----´ |  `--------+-------+-------+--------+--------´  |   |
    |          |      |                                                |  LVM
    |          |      |           LVM VG "SYSTEM"                      |   |
    |          |      |                                                |   |
,---*----, +---*----+ +------------------------------------------------+ -----
| md0    | | md1    | |               md2                              | raid1
`-*----*-´ `-*----*-´ `-------*---------------------*------------------´ -----
  |    |     |    |           |                     |
  |    |     |    |           |                     |
,-*--, |   ,-*--, |      ,----*-,                   |
|hda1| |   |hda2| |      | hda5 |                   |                 /dev/hda
`----´ |   `----´ |      `------´                   |
    ,--*-,     ,--*-,                             ,-*----,
    |hdc1|     |hdc2|                             | hdc5 |            /dev/hdc
    `----´     `----´                             `------´

                                                            (DVD-ROM) /dev/hdd

the system starts up and all works fine. :-)



But when I setup following

 /boot       SWAP           /       /var    /usr    /home    /misc
,--------, ,--------, ,--+--------+-------+-------+--------+--------+--, -----
| BOOT   | | SWAP   | |  |  ROOT  |  VAR  |  USR  |  HOME  |  MISC  |  |   ^
`---*----´ `---*----´ |  `--------+-------+-------+--------+--------´  |   |
    |          |      |                                                |  LVM
    |          |      |           LVM VG "SYSTEM"                      |   |
    |          |      |                                                |   |
    |      ,---*----, +------------------------------------------------+ -----
    |      |md1_cryp| |               md2_crypt                        |
    |      | key    | |                Key                             | crypt
    |      | random | |                Passphrase                      |
,---*----, +--------+ +------------------------------------------------+ -----
| md0    | | md1    | |               md2                              | raid1
`-*----*-´ `-*----*-´ `-------*---------------------*------------------´ -----
  |    |     |    |           |                     |
  |    |     |    |           |                     |
,-*--, |   ,-*--, |      ,----*-,                   |
|hda1| |   |hda2| |      | hda5 |                   |                 /dev/hda
`----´ |   `----´ |      `------´                   |
    ,--*-,     ,--*-,                             ,-*----,
    |hdc1|     |hdc2|                             | hdc5 |            /dev/hdc
    `----´     `----´                             `------´

                                                            (DVD-ROM) /dev/hdd

the partitioner/installer say at the point when it setup SWAP:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The attempt to mount a file system with type swap in Encrypted volume
(md1_crypt) at none failed.

You may resume partitioning from the partitioning menu.

Do you want to resume partitioning?

   <Go Back>                                   <Yes>   <NO>
---------------------------------------------------------------------------


so I try the followng (SWAP without MD-Device):

 /boot       SWAP           /       /var    /usr    /home    /misc
,--------, ,--------, ,--+--------+-------+-------+--------+--------+--, -----
| BOOT   | | SWAP   | |  |  ROOT  |  VAR  |  USR  |  HOME  |  MISC  |  |   ^
`---*----´ `---*----´ |  `--------+-------+-------+--------+--------´  |   |
    |          |      |                                                |  LVM
    |          |      |           LVM VG "SYSTEM"                      |   |
    |          |      |                                                |   |
    |      ,---*----, +------------------------------------------------+ -----
    |      |hda2_cry| |               md1_crypt                        |
    |      | key    | |                Key                             | crypt
    |      | random | |                Passphrase                      |
,---*----, `---*----´ +------------------------------------------------+ -----
| md0    |     |      |               md1                              | raid1
`-*----*-´     |      `-------*---------------------*------------------´ -----
  |    |       |              |                     |
  |    |       |              |                     |
,-*--, |     ,-*--,      ,----*-,                   |
|hda1| |     |hda2|      | hda5 |                   |                 /dev/hda
`----´ |     `----´      `------´                   |
    ,--*-,                                        ,-*----,
    |hdc1|                                        | hdc5 |            /dev/hdc
    `----´                                        `------´

                                                            (DVD-ROM) /dev/hdd

I mean the partitioner/installer setups all correctly!
I install the software.
I install the GRUB for booting.
Then I reboot at the end.

But the output at boot time is following (initramfs-tools):
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
... start of the Kernel ...
...
Begin: Loading MD modules
md: md driver ...
md: bitmap Version 4.39
md raid1 personality registered for level 1
success: loaded module raid1.
Done.
Begin: Assembling all MD arrays
md: md0 stopped.
md: bind<hdc1>
md: bind<hda1>
raid1: raid set md0 active with 2 out of 2 mirrors
mdadm: /dev/md0 has been started with 2 drives
md: md1 stopped.
md: bind<hdc5>
md: bind<hda5>
raid1: raid set md1 active with 2 out of 2 mirrors
mdadm: /dev/md1 has been started with 2 drives
Success: assembled all arrays.
Done.
device-mapper: ioctl: 4.7.0-ioctl (2006-06-24) initialised: ...
  Volume group "SYSTEM" not found
Done.
Begin: Waiting for root file system... ...
Done.
        Check root= bootarg cat /proc/cmdline
        or missing modules, devices: cat /proc/modules ls /dev
ALERT! /dev/mapper/SYSTEM-ROOT does not exist. Dropping to a shell!

BusyBox v1.1.3 (Debian 1:1.1.3-4) Build-in shell (ash)
Enter 'help' for a list of built-in commands.

/bin/sh: can't access tty; job control turned off
(initramfs) _
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

initrd don't ask for the passphrase for md1_crypt :-(
Further I mean hda2_crypt are not initialiced with random key.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Now I install following strukture:


 /boot       SWAP           /       /var    /usr    /home    /misc
,--------, ,--------, ,--+--------+-------+-------+--------+--------+--, -----
| BOOT   | | SWAP   | |  |  ROOT  |  VAR  |  USR  |  HOME  |  MISC  |  |   ^
`---*----´ `---*----´ |  `--------+-------+-------+--------+--------´  |   |
    |          |      |                                                |  LVM
    |          |      |           LVM VG "SYSTEM"                      |   |
    |          |      |                                                |   |
,---*----, .--------. +--------------+-+--------------+-+--------------+ -----
| md0    | | md1    | |     md2      | |     md3      | |     md4      | raid1
`-*----*-´ `-*----*-´ `-----*---*----´ `-----*---*----´ `-----*---*----´ -----
  |    |     |    |         |   |            |   |            |   |
  |    |     |    |         |   |            |   |            |   |
,-*--, |   ,-*--, |    ,----*-, |       ,----*-, |       ,----*-, |
|hda1| |   |hda2| |    | hda5 | |       | hda6 | |       | hda7 | |   /dev/hda
`----´ |   `----´ |    `------´ |       `------´ |       `------´ |
    ,--*-,     ,--*-,      ,----*-,         ,----*-,         ,----*-,
    |hdc1|     |hdc2|      | hdc5 |         | hdc6 |         | hdc7 | /dev/hdc
    `----´     `----´      `------´         `------´         `------´
  (64MB)     (1GB)        (4GB)            (4GB)            (4GB)

                                                            (DVD-ROM) /dev/hdd


It works fine!



What I wish:


 /boot       SWAP           /       /var    /usr    /home    /misc
,--------, ,--------, ,--+--------+-------+-------+--------+--------+--, -----
| BOOT   | | SWAP   | |  |  ROOT  |  VAR  |  USR  |  HOME  |  MISC  |  |   ^
`---*----´ `---*----´ |  `--------+-------+-------+--------+--------´  |   |
    |          |      |                                                |  LVM
    |          |      |           LVM VG "SYSTEM"                      |   |
    |          |      |                                                |   |
    |      ,---*----, +--------------+-+--------------+-+--------------+ -----
    |      |md1_cryp| | md2_crypt    | | md3_crypt    | | md4_crypt    |
    |      | key    | |  key         | |  key         | |  key         | crypt
    |      | random | |  Passphrase1 | |  Passphrase2 | |  Passphrase3 |
,---*----, +--------+ +--------------+ +--------------+ +--------------+ -----
| md0    | | md1    | |     md2      | |     md3      | |     md4      | raid1
`-*----*-´ `-*----*-´ `-----*---*----´ `-----*---*----´ `-----*---*----´ -----
  |    |     |    |         |   |            |   |            |   |
  |    |     |    |         |   |            |   |            |   |
,-*--, |   ,-*--, |    ,----*-, |       ,----*-, |       ,----*-, |
|hda1| |   |hda2| |    | hda5 | |       | hda6 | |       | hda7 | |   /dev/hda
`----´ |   `----´ |    `------´ |       `------´ |       `------´ |
    ,--*-,     ,--*-,      ,----*-,         ,----*-,         ,----*-,
    |hdc1|     |hdc2|      | hdc5 |         | hdc6 |         | hdc7 | /dev/hdc
    `----´     `----´      `------´         `------´         `------´
  (64MB)     (1GB)        (4GB)            (4GB)            (4GB)

                                                            (DVD-ROM) /dev/hdd


Features:
SWAP encrypted (random key) and with a MD-Device.
More than one crypted MD-Devices for the LVM Volume Group "SYSTEM".
I want to give more than one different passphrases for "SYSTEM".

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

There is a further problem when hda have an error:
Then I must boot from hdc (in BIOS: HDD-2). But there ist no
grub installed and I don't know if the menu.lst ist korrekt for
booting from hdc (BIOS: HDD-2).

Regards
Andreas Gerlich
-- 
Dipl.-Ing.(FH) Andreas Gerlich, Puccini-Ring 14, D-86956 Schongau

Tel: +49 163 / 4 36 32 32 (mobile phone, www.simyo.de)
    +49 8861 / 6 90 95 11 (private, VoIP, answering machine after 20 seconds)
    +49 8861 / 219 - 4122 (computer department in www.herzogsaegmuehle.de)

project (Z80 emulator) --> http://www.mathematik.uni-ulm.de/users/ag/yaze-ag/

Mitspielen strengstens erlaubt!


--- End Message ---
--- Begin Message ---
Closing this report as it is a duplicate of #422319 which was filed as an 
installation report. Please do not file identical reports against 
different packages.

Cheers,
FJP

Attachment: pgpeLlIoAkBnE.pgp
Description: PGP signature


--- End Message ---

Reply via email to