Control: tags -1 moreinfo
Control: severity -1 wishlist

On Sat, Apr 30, 2016 at 09:50:01PM +0200, Holger Levsen wrote:
> Package: monkeysign
> Version: 2.0.2
> Severity: normal
> 
> Hi,
> 
> I've read the package description and while I like the funny tone, I
> also find it confusing for two reasons:
> 
> 1.)
> 
>  monkeysign is a tool to overhaul the OpenPGP keysigning experience
>  and bring it closer to something that most primates can understand.
> [...]
>  Monkeysign is the commandline signing software.
> 
> -> most primates can't understand commandline software?!

That is correct. What do you find find confusing here?

> 2.) 
> 
>  The project makes use of cheap digital cameras and the type of bar
>  code known as a QRcode to provide a human-friendly yet still-secure
>  keysigning experience.
> [...]
>  Monkeysign is the commandline signing software, a caff
>  replacement.
> 
> -> is it a caff replacement or does it rely on QRcodes?

It's funny that you quote only the first sentence of that paragraph, the
full paragraph is:

 Monkeysign is the commandline signing software, a caff
 replacement. Monkeyscan is the graphical user interface that scans
 qrcodes.

So Monkeysign is the caff replacement, and monkeyscan is the GUI.    
 
> Please clarify the package description to make these things
> clear(er).

I would appreciate a suggestion on how to phrase this better. With the
above, I am not sure I can find a proper formulation that would be
satisfactory.

> Also it might be appropriate to explain that monkeysign is a
> commandline tool, just like caff or pius… (and that only monkeyscan
> does all the monkey QR stuff and therefore has a gui…)

Again, I felt that the last paragraph did exactly that.

> Also, I'm kinda surprised that I have recommends enabled and get this
> after installing monkeysign:
> 
> $ monkeyscan some modules missing for scanning functionality: No
> module named zbar

That seems like a completely different issue...

python-zbar and python-zbarpygtk and both in Recommends - are they
installed on your computer?

A.

-- 
Il est sage de nous réconcilier avec notre adolescence ; haїr, mépriser,
nier ou simplement oublier l’adolescent que nous fûmes est en soi une
attitude adolescente.
                        - Daniel Pennac, Comme un roman

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Digital signature

Reply via email to