Control: affects -1 src:ntp

Am 13.01.20 um 02:02 schrieb Michael Biebl:

Hi Michael,

On Fri, 1 Jul 2005 13:49:45 -0400 Justin Pryzby
<justinpry...@users.sourceforge.net> wrote:
Package: chrony, ntp
Severity: normal

Only openntpd provides, conflicts, replaces: time-daemon.

Seems all NTP clients (ntpsec, chrony, openntpd) aside from ntp itself have

Conflict/Replaces/Provides: time-daemon

nowadays to prevent multiple implementations being installed and enabled
at the same time. This is a common mechanism defined in policy [1]

It's kinda annyoing that they all have to special case ntp and must
declare explicit Conflicts against ntp.

Would be great if you can reconsider this and consider adding
Conflict/Replaces/Provides: time-daemon
to ntp

Hrm, I wasn't involved in this discussion. Right now I don't see a major blocker. There are a few packages that need time sync and only depend on ntp without time-daemon (bwctl-server, lava, openstack-cloud-services, openstack-compute-nodes), we should probably file bugs against them if they only need some timekeeping facility.

I remember that some time ago some monitoring solutions also depended on ntp to use and parse the output of ntpq or ntpdc, possibly on remote servers. I only see hobbit-plugins doing that right now, and only using Suggests.

Unless I find a major issue I'll do this in the next upload.

Bernhard

Reply via email to