Control: -1 tags confirmed On Sat, Jun 23, 2012 at 11:19:40AM +0200, email....@arcor.de wrote: > However, as the debian default is to use user(private)groups, > this leaves the general "users" group unpopulated. > > Please enable the standard "users" group as a default extra group, > to ensure it has the same consistent setup and meaning whether > user(private)groups are used or not.
I think that we should: (1) Augment the USERS_GID with a USERS_GROUP setting, throwing a warning if both are set. (2) Set the primary group of a new non-system user created with USERGROUPS=no to the USERS_GID or the GID of the USERS_GROUP (3) Set USERS_GROUP or the Group that has USERS_GID as supplementary group of newly created non-system users with USERGROUPS=yes (The suggestion for USERS_GROUP comes from the fact that the primary group is set via GID and supplementary group is set via name. Don't we all love those twisted UNIX traditions?) Greetings Marc