On Wed, 22 Jun 2022 14:13:29 +0200 Bastian Germann <b...@debian.org>
wrote:
> On Sat, 18 Jun 2022 17:58:24 -0500 "David (Plasma) Paul"
> <davidp...@librem.one> wrote:
> > markdown-it-py fails to build from source with versions of flit
> > earlier than 3.4 according to the package's pyproject.toml.[0]
> > Attached is a patch to fix the declared build dependency on flit in
> > the debian/control file to match the supported versions listed in
> > the package's pyproject.toml file.
> > 
> > [0] However, I was able to get markdown-it-py to build with flit
> > 3.3.0-1~bpo11+1, so maybe the value in the pyproject.toml file is
> > higher than it strictly needs to be. Regardless of what the actual
> > exact minimum value is, I can confirm that flit 3.0.0 is
> > insufficient.
> 
> Please do not file RC bugs when a bookworm/sid only package does not
> build for bullseye-backports. If you want a backport please express
> that intend otherwise this is invalid.

Apologies for the being overzealous with regards to Build-Depends
versioning. I will file this sort of report as a wishlist severity bug
in the future. Sorry for overstepping.


FWIW, my original reasoning for filing this bug went like this: For the
sake of ensuring bootstrappability of any release N of Debian by the
previous Debian release N-1, the build-dependencies of any release N
source package ought to be satisfiable solely by some combination of

(A) binary packages from the release N-1 binary archive
(B) binary packages built from release N source packages using
build-dependencies consisting solely of some combination of A and B

In order to aid in this bootstrapping process, the allowed versions of
the declared build dependencies of release N source packages should be
constrained such that combinations of A and B which satisify the
declared dependencies but fail to build the package are eliminated.


Again, I'm sorry for being a nuisance and I will try to do better in
the future.

-- 
Plasma

Reply via email to