martin f krafft wrote: > Package: tumgreyspf > Version: 1.31-1 > Severity: important > > The package description reads: > > Because of it's design, legitimate e-mail is never trapped or > rejected. Only spam and viruses are caught. If you add tumgreyspf > to your mail server (also compatible when using Spam Assassin, > ClamAV, and an outsourced anti-spam system), your spam level will > be dropped by an order of magnitude. > > this is clearly wrong and misleading. First of all, legitimate mail > sent from broken mail servers or those without SPF records may well > be dropped. And second, spam and viruses these days often originate > from proper, queuing mail servers *with* SPF records, so the package > does not guarantee that these are dropped. > > Please rephrase the description.
Hi, Where did you see that this description says it's compatible with broken mail server or that spam and viruses are always trapped? The only thing I understand when reading this is that it reduces the "spam level" by "an order of magnitude", and that "legitimate e-mail is never trapped" as when the SPF check is passed, greylisting doesn't occure. The fact that it's written that Spamassassin and ClamAV are compatible clearly shows that it might be wise to use them at the same time. I would agree to rephrase, but: 1/ This description is the one of the upstream that you can see here: http://www.tummy.com/Community/software/tumgreyspf/ on the project home page. And 2/ I find it quite accurate. Let me know if you still do not agree, and maybe give a proposal for something better if you can. Anyway, thanks for having a look at the package. Thomas -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]
