Package: egoboo-data Version: 1:2.8.1-1.1 Severity: serious Tags: upstream Justification: Policy 2.1
Dear Maintainer, It appears that egoboo-data contains some likely non-free audio, and a lot with an unclear license, which is likely non-free as well. $ for i in $(find -iname *.ogg); do ogginfo $i | grep right && echo $i; done Copyright=(c) 1999 Westwood Studios ./modules/cobolemperor.mod/objects/hostage.obj/sound5.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./modules/soldier.mod/objects/evilforce.obj/sound0.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./modules/imprisoned5.mod/objects/demogorgon.obj/sound2.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./modules/imprisoned5.mod/objects/demogorgon.obj/sound1.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./modules/imprisoned5.mod/objects/demogorgon.obj/sound0.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./modules/imprisoned5.mod/objects/demogorgon.obj/sound13.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./modules/imprisoned5.mod/objects/demogorgon.obj/sound16.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./modules/imprisoned5.mod/objects/demogorgon.obj/sound11.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./modules/imprisoned5.mod/objects/demogorgon.obj/sound14.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./modules/imprisoned5.mod/objects/demogorgon.obj/sound17.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./modules/imprisoned5.mod/objects/demogorgon.obj/sound12.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./modules/imprisoned5.mod/objects/demogorgon.obj/sound15.ogg Copyright=(c) 2004 PCB Productions ./modules/archmage.mod/objects/devildoor.obj/sound8.ogg Copyright=(c) 2004 PCB Productions ./modules/abyss2.mod/objects/devildoor.obj/sound8.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./modules/imprisoned3.mod/objects/layna.obj/sound2.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./modules/imprisoned3.mod/objects/layna.obj/sound1.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./modules/imprisoned3.mod/objects/layna.obj/sound3.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./basicdat/globalobjects/monsters/vampyre.obj/sound2.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./basicdat/globalobjects/monsters/vampyre.obj/sound1.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./basicdat/globalobjects/monsters/vampyre.obj/sound3.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./basicdat/globalobjects/monsters/vampyre.obj/sound10.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./basicdat/globalobjects/monsters/vampyre.obj/sound9.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./basicdat/globalobjects/monsters/vampyre.obj/sound8.ogg Copyright=(c) 1999 Westwood Studios ./basicdat/globalobjects/players/tourist.obj/sound5.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./basicdat/globalobjects/misc/smithy.obj/sound0.ogg Copyright=A1 Free Sound Effects ./basicdat/globalobjects/unique/vorpalblade.obj/sound2.ogg Copyright message=(c) 2010 Sounddogs.com, All Rights Reserved ./basicdat/globalobjects/magic/glacialspike.obj/sound1.ogg Copyright message=Adam Frechette ./basicdat/music/Once_lost.ogg Copyright message=Adam Frechette ./basicdat/music/Irish_Night.ogg Copyright message=Adam Christopher Frechette ./basicdat/music/Safe_Haven.ogg using ogginfo on separate files yields more info IF we assume that those headers are correct (I do not know if all of them are, the music ones should be though, see below), there's quite a bit of a problem. It MIGHT be the case that they are incorrect and all sound effects are indeed original content created by the Egoboo team, though I think that's unlikely... The Westwoods studios stuff *may* be "freeware" at best. The Sounddogs stuff is NOT ARReserved, but likely some sort of freeware (they provide both gratis and paid sounds), encumbered by a EULA: http://www.sounddogs.com/htm/licensemx.htm Maybe the source isn't actually Sounddogs though, so maybe if the originals were hunted down...? Adam Frechette appears to be a composer which created free user content for modding Newerwinter Nights, e.g: http://nwvault.ign.com/View.php?view=Sounds.Detail&id=127 There is no mention of license anywhere, though as per http://egoboo.sourceforge.net/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=548&p=40332#p40332 they are suppossedly "open content" (whatever that means). That thread has some more info regarding music that might be relevant as well, it would seem that there is a small set which is created by the Egoboo team, so those pieces should be fine I'm guessing. A large portion of the sound effects appears to be long-lost things which we're unlikely to get license clarification for at all :( -- System Information: Debian Release: wheezy/sid APT prefers testing APT policy: (500, 'testing') Architecture: amd64 (x86_64) Kernel: Linux 3.1.0-1-amd64 (SMP w/4 CPU cores) Locale: LANG=en_GB.utf8, LC_CTYPE=en_GB.utf8 (charmap=UTF-8) Shell: /bin/sh linked to /bin/dash -- no debconf information -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-bugs-rc-requ...@lists.debian.org with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact listmas...@lists.debian.org
