Dear Simon,

Le lundi 19 juin 2023, 20:50:35 CEST Simon McVittie a écrit :
> Package: desktop-base
> Version: 12.0.6
> Severity: normal
> Tags: trixie sid
> 
> Now that Debian 12 has been released, the version of desktop-base in
> testing should no longer include Debian 12 branding, so that the testing
> installer will be visually distinct from the Debian 12 stable release.

I think this makes sense.

> The simplest possible implementation of this would be to remove the "12"
> from all the art components, but I think it would be better to use artwork
> that is obviously different.

Yes, I can do that.

> One simple "programmer-art" way to do that would be to desaturate the
> Debian 12 artwork down to greyscale to make it obviously a placeholder,
> or rotate the hue to make it a different colour.

I probably won’t do that.

> However, it might be nicer (and definitely more fun!) to have a theme
> specifically for Debian in its alpha/beta state, with a sense of "this is
> under construction", to be replaced by a proper Debian 13 theme closer
> to the Debian 13 freeze. Some of the contributors who were helping with
> debian-cd testing during the Debian 12 release process had a similar
> thought a while ago, and got as far as preparing a background image for
> this purpose - I'll ask them to follow up here.

Well I was not convinced at all by the last proposal I saw.

Obviously theming and art are very personal but I wouldn’t want to replace 
quality artwork we’ve been having for the last couple of releases with 
something I consider less attractive just for the sake of it.

OK for the artwort to convey the idea of work-in-progress but the art itself 
cannot be work-in-progress…

And yes I know people can change it if they like but defaults count, especially 
since it will be part first impressions for new users of testing.


Happy hacking,
--
Aurélien

Reply via email to