Hi Christopher, On 18.08.2016 22:41, Christopher Hoskin wrote: > I'm considering how to remove .jar files and convenience copies of other > libraries from upstream tar balls. It seems to me that there are several > ways of approaching repacking: > > 1) Add Files-Excluded to debian/copyright > 2) Create a debian/orig-tar.sh script and call it from debian/watch > 3) Call jh_repack from debian/watch > 4) Create a debian/gbp.conf and add filters to the import-orig section > > Possibly there are other options I haven't thought of. > > 4) is what is recommended at https://wiki.debian.org/Java/JavaGit, > whilst https://wiki.debian.org/Java/JavaVcs suggests 2). 3) wouldn't > cover convenience copies of libraries. > > 1) seems the best approach to me, since it is declarative rather than > scripted, is independent of the choice of VCS, and also allows one to > check the repacked tarball before importing it to pristine-tar. The > files being excluded don't have anything to do with copyright though. > > Is there a team preference for a particular approach?
I guess nobody has written down any team preferences yet but we use
option 1 for the majority of new packages for the reasons you have
already mentioned. You can still find a lot of the debian/orig-tar.sh
scripts in older packages because that was consensus back then but in
the meantime debian/copyright has grown support for the Files-Excluded
paragraph and I find it quite useful and it is also much simpler in
combination with a get-orig-source target like:
get-orig-source:
uscan --download-current-version --force-download --repack
--compression xz
Since we usually remove only non-free files or files without source
(jars), debian/copyright is a good place to document this. Sometimes we
also use this field for removing cruft but I think this is still
proportionate. Thus said you can choose one of the other approaches too
but option 1 is most likely the simplest one.
Regards,
Markus
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
