Am 2006-02-09 17:01:35, schrieb Digby Tarvin:
> Hi - thanks for the link.
> 
> A quick survey and it does indeed seem that 'Reply-To munging' is
> what is used on nearly all of the other lists I am subscribed to.

I do not know, on which lists you are, but I am on:

+---[ '/home/michelle.konzack/.mutt/mailinglists' ]---+
|                                                     |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]          |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                     |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                     |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                        |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                       |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]           |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]           |
| subscribe courier-users@lists.sourceforge.net       |
| subscribe debian-68k@lists.debian.org               |
| subscribe debian-alpha@lists.debian.org             |
| subscribe debian-amd64@lists.debian.org             |
| subscribe debian-announce@lists.debian.org          |
| subscribe debian-boot@lists.debian.org              |
| subscribe debian-cd@lists.debian.org                |
| subscribe debian-changes@lists.debian.org           |
| subscribe debian-commercial@lists.debian.org        |
| subscribe debian-consultants@lists.debian.org       |
| subscribe debian-curiosa@lists.debian.org           |
| subscribe debian-desktop@lists.debian.org           |
| subscribe debian-devel-announce@lists.debian.org    |
| subscribe debian-devel-changes@lists.debian.org     |
| subscribe debian-devel@lists.debian.org             |
| subscribe debian-doc@lists.debian.org               |
| subscribe debian-edu@lists.debian.org               |
| subscribe debian-embedded@lists.debian.org          |
| subscribe debian-events-eu@lists.debian.org         |
| subscribe debian-firewall@lists.debian.org          |
| subscribe debian-handheld@lists.debian.org          |
| subscribe debian-hppa@lists.debian.org              |
| subscribe debian-i18n@lists.debian.org              |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]      |
| subscribe debian-isp@lists.debian.org               |
| subscribe debian-jobs@lists.debian.org              |
| subscribe debian-jr@lists.debian.org                |
| subscribe debian-kernel@lists.debian.org            |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]       |
| subscribe debian-l10n-english@lists.debian.org      |
| subscribe debian-l10n-french@lists.debian.org       |
| subscribe debian-l10n-german@lists.debian.org       |
| subscribe debian-l10n-turkish@lists.debian.org      |
| subscribe debian-laptop@lists.debian.org            |
| subscribe debian-legal@lists.debian.org             |
| subscribe debian-mentors@lists.debian.org           |
| subscribe debian-mips@lists.debian.org              |
| subscribe debian-mirrors@lists.debian.org           |
| subscribe debian-multimedia@lists.debian.org        |
| subscribe debian-newmaint@lists.debian.org          |
| subscribe debian-news-french@lists.debian.org       |
| subscribe debian-news-german@lists.debian.org       |
| subscribe debian-news@lists.debian.org              |
| subscribe debian-nonprofit@lists.debian.org         |
| subscribe debian-openoffice@lists.debian.org        |
| subscribe debian-policy@lists.debian.org            |
| subscribe debian-powerpc@lists.debian.org           |
| subscribe debian-project@lists.debian.org           |
| subscribe debian-qa@lists.debian.org                |
| subscribe debian-release@lists.debian.org           |
| subscribe debian-science@lists.debian.org           |
| subscribe debian-security-announce@lists.debian.org |
| subscribe debian-security@lists.debian.org          |
| subscribe debian-ssh@lists.debian.org               |
| subscribe debian-testing@lists.debian.org           |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]   |
| subscribe debian-user-french@lists.debian.org       |
| subscribe debian-user-german@lists.debian.org       |
| subscribe debian-user-turkish@lists.debian.org      |
| subscribe debian-user@lists.debian.org              |
| subscribe debian-vote@lists.debian.org              |
| subscribe debian-win32@lists.debian.org             |
| subscribe debian-wnpp@lists.debian.org              |
| subscribe debian-women@lists.debian.org             |
| subscribe debian-www@lists.debian.org               |
| subscribe debian-x@lists.debian.org                 |
| subscribe developer@arabeyes.org                    |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                         |
| subscribe doc@arabeyes.org                          |
| subscribe exim-users@exim.org                       |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]          |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                        |
| subscribe fvwm@fvwm.org                             |
| subscribe general@arabeyes.org                      |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]         |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]             |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]    |
| subscribe lartc@mailman.ds9a.nl                     |
| subscribe leaf-user@lists.sourceforge.net           |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]              |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                    |
| subscribe linux-audio-dev@music.columbia.edu        |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]       |
| subscribe linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org              |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]              |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                 |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                      |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                     |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]              |
| subscribe mc@gnome.org                              |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED] |
| subscribe mp3encoder@minnie.tuhs.org                |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]      |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                |
| subscribe mutt-users@mutt.org                       |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]             |
| subscribe pgsql-admin@postgresql.org                |
| subscribe pgsql-announce@postgresql.org             |
| subscribe pgsql-docs@postgresql.org                 |
| subscribe pgsql-general@postgresql.org              |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]               |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                 |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                  |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                |
| subscribe php-db@lists.php.net                      |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]              |
| subscribe php-general@lists.php.net                 |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]             |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]               |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                           |
| subscribe speedtouch@ml.free.fr                     |
| subscribe squid-users@squid-cache.org               |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                       |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                       |
| subscribe users@httpd.apache.org                    |
| subscribe users-de@httpd.apache.org                 |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                   |
| ################################################    |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                         |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]            |
| subscribe akgul-duyuru@inet-tr.org.tr               |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                    |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]           |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                       |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                 |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]             |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                       |
| subscribe dnsadmin@inter7.com                       |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                       |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]       |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                    |
| subscribe freebsd-small@freebsd.org                 |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]             |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                  |
| subscribe grrltalk@linuxchix.org                    |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]       |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                     |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]               |
| subscribe linuxberg.com                             |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                      |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                             |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                        |
| subscribe linux-net@vger.rutgers.edu                |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                    |
| subscribe lkd-duyuru@linux.org.tr                   |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                          |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]               |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                         |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                   |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                   |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                    |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]            |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]            |
| subscribe openldap-software@openldap.org            |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                      |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                 |
| subscribe qmailadmin@inter7.com                     |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                  |
| subscribe reiserfs-list@namesys.com                 |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                       |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                       |
| subscribe techtalk@linuxchix.org                    |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                  |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                        |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                     |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]               |
| subscribe [EMAIL PROTECTED]                    |
+-----------------------------------------------------+

and they are working perfectly.

> The arguments made against it in that link certainly make sense,
> although the author's prefered solution seems to be the
> 'reply to all' option which sends to the list and the originator,
> and hence seems to cause so many complaints here.

I regulyr blacklist such posters which bother me with Cc's.

> A 'reply-to-list' command does seem like a good solution, although
> I don't know how universally applicable it is. 

Sorry, but IF I WRITE HERE, I am subscribed and I do not
need Cc: for each message.
 
> Not all of the mailing lists seem to be adding a 'X-Mailing-List'
> header into the message. Or does 'reply-to-list' use something
> else?

Mailing-List
Sender
X-List
X-Mailing-List
...
List:

> Regards,
> DigbyT

Greetings
    Michelle Konzack
    Systemadministrator
    Tamay Dogan Network
    Debian GNU/Linux Consultant


-- 
Linux-User #280138 with the Linux Counter, http://counter.li.org/
##################### Debian GNU/Linux Consultant #####################
Michelle Konzack   Apt. 917                  ICQ #328449886
                   50, rue de Soultz         MSM LinuxMichi
0033/3/88452356    67100 Strasbourg/France   IRC #Debian (irc.icq.com)


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] 
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to