>
>
> Hi Steve,

Some follow-up questions:

1) Symantec stated "This information was in their management assertions,
and repeated in the audit findings. So the poor audit situation was ongoing
and known."
  a) Symantec did not meaningfully provide any explanation, now, or in the
past, as to why it took multiple audit periods to resolve these issues. In
order to establish for Relying Parties that Symantec is trustworthy and
competent, please supply additional details as to why it took so long.
  b) On the basis of the provided information, it does not appear Symantec
asked their GeoRoot partners for audits. This is also consistent with the
reports from UniCredits management, and we would be happy to reach out to
other GeoRoot partners regarding Symantec's communications over the past
several years. Given the issues such as Aetna, do you believe Symantec had
a material obligation to be diligent in obtaining an audit?
  c) What provisions, if any, did Symantec contractually have to ensure
such audits and compliance with Symantec's CP/CPS?
  d) Did such provisions include the ability for Symantec to revoke such
certificates for non-compliance, as required by the Baseline Requirements,
Section 9.6.3?
  e) If not, what steps have been taken to address this in all existing and
future business relationships?
  f) If it already existed, why did Symantec not exercise that option, as
required by the Baseline Requirements, Section 4.9.1.2?
  g) What assurances, if any, should Relying Parties have that Symantec
will execute its Baseline Requirements required obligations in the future,
given its documented failures in the past?

2) Symantec states "Because GeoRoot only operates under GeoTrust roots and
the associated CPS, the Symantec Trust Network and Thawte audits are fairly
stated."
  a) It has been identified that Symantec has failed to provide
BR-compliant audits for your RAs. Do you still believe this statement is
accurate?
  b) If so, why?
  c) If not, have you re-evaluated every statement Symantec has made in
response to these issues, to ensure that Symantec has not overlooked any
other material or contradictory evidence?

3) Do you believe the actions taken with respect to Aetna and Unicredit
were consistent with the Baseline Requirements?
  a) If so, specifically, what provisions?
  b) If not, what steps have you taken to ensure Symantec will abide by the
Baseline Requirements in the future, as is necessary and expected for
continued trust?
_______________________________________________
dev-security-policy mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-security-policy

Reply via email to