Over the past months there has been much consternation over Symantec and the idea of "too big to fail". That is a reasonable idea but makes difficult the discussion of remedies for Symantec's past behavior: How does one impose a meaningful sanction without causing Symantec to fail outright since the impact would be catastrophic?

I'd like to offer an alternate perspective on the situation in the hope that it might simplify the discussions of sanctions. The central point is this: Symantec is too big and too complicated to function properly.

Consider:

* Symantec has demonstrated an inability to exercise sufficient oversight and control over the totality of their PKI systems. Undoubtedly there are parts which have been and continue to be well-run, but there are parts for which management has been unacceptably poor.

* No cases have been identified of a breach or other compromise of Symantec's PKI technology/infrastructure, nor of the infrastructure of a subordinate PKI organization for which Symantec is responsible. The possibility does exist, however, that compromises have occurred but might never be known because of management lapses.

* Many of Symantec's customers play a critical role in the global economy and rely on the so-called "ubiquitous roots" to provide their services. Any disruption in those services can have global impacts. Symantec, therefore, plays a significant role in the global economy but only insofar as it is the gatekeeper to the "ubiquitous roots" upon which the global economy relies.

* ‎Symantec has demonstrated admirable commitment to its customers but appear less so when it comes to the policies, recommendations, and openness of the global PKI community. Whether this indicates a willful disregard for the community‎ or difficulty in incorporating these viewpoints into a large organization (or something else?) is unclear.


From this standpoint, the focus of sanctions would be on Symantec's size. Obviously Mozilla is in no position to mandate the breakup of a company but Mozilla (and others) can mandate a reduced role as gatekeeper to the "ubiquitous roots". In fact, Symantec has already agreed to do just that.

In addition, this viewpoint would discourage increasing Symantec's size or adding to the complexity of their operations. I question Symantec's ability to do either one successfully. Symantec is certainly welcome to become bigger and more complex if that's what they should choose, but not as a result of some external mandate.


Comments and corrections are welcome.



_______________________________________________
dev-security-policy mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-security-policy

Reply via email to