I33Buckler commented on issue #1287:
URL: https://github.com/apache/age/issues/1287#issuecomment-1783935480
A factor that I've noticed with regard to the noticeable performance
difference between joining the PostgreSQL tables in the database and and
joining the nodes is the difference in estimated cost.
The native query below in response to EXECUTION PLAN returns a total cost
score of 296852.63.
```SQL
select st.* from
allservices.stops s,
allservices.trips t,
allservices.stop_times st
where s.tc_date=t.tc_date and t.tc_date=st.tc_date
and s.stop_id=st.stop_id and t.trip_id=st.trip_id
;
```
Whereas the graph query in response to the EXECUTION PLAN returns a total
cost score of 2115202.70
```SQL
CREATE OR REPLACE FUNCTION create_stop_times(graph_name text, tc_date date,
trip_id text, stop_id text,
arrival_time text,
arrival_time_sec bigint, departure_time text, departure_time_sec bigint,
stop_sequence bigint,
pickup_type int, drop_off_type int)
returns text
LANGUAGE plpgsql
VOLATILE
as $stop_times$
declare
nodename text := graph_name || '.' || 'stop_times';
BEGIN
execute
format ('select * from
cypher(''%1$s'',
$$match (t:trips),(s:stops)
where t.id=%2$s and s.id=%3$s
and t.tc_date=%11$s and t.tc_date=s.tc_date
create(t)<-
[:PART_OF_TRIP]-
(st:stop_times {tc_date: %11$s,
arrival_time: %4$s, arrival_time_seconds: %5$s, departure_time: %6$s,
departure_time_seconds: %7$s,
stop_sequence: %8$s,
pickup_type: %9$s, drop_off_type: %10$s})-
[:LOCATED_AT]->(s)$$) as (st agtype);',
quote_ident(graph_name),quote_ident(trip_id),quote_ident(stop_id),
quote_ident(arrival_time),to_char(arrival_time_sec,'999999'),
quote_ident(departure_time),to_char(departure_time_sec,'999999'),
to_char(stop_sequence,'9999'),to_char(pickup_type,'9'),to_char(drop_off_type,'9'),
format('"%s"',to_char(tc_date,'yyyy-mm-dd')));
return nodename;
END
$stop_times$
;
select
create_stop_times('transport_network',a.tc_date,a.trip_id,a.stop_id,a.arrival_time,a.arrival_time_sec,a.departure_time,a.departure_time_sec,a.row_num,a.pickup_type,a.drop_off_type)
from stop_times a
;
```
This about 7:1 difference between the native SQL and the graph query.
--
This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service.
To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the
URL above to go to the specific comment.
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at:
[email protected]
