[ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/AMBARI-13300?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel ]
Vijay Srinivasaraghavan updated AMBARI-13300: --------------------------------------------- Description: StackAdvisor component as of now can recommend and validate component layout and configurations. Precisely, we can request StackAdvisor API for any of these recommendations (host_groups, configurations, configuration-dependencies). Though StackAdvisor has got the host specific resouce details (memory, cpu, disks, os type, etc.,) it does not use these details while recommending the host-component mapping. Applications/Service Providers that are using Amabri Rest API/Blueprints to provision and manage Hadoop clusters will largely benefit if Stack Advisor component is enhanced to address following GAPs - Support for Heterogenous hosts (Master, Slaves, Clients) - Provide both host group and configuration recommendations in same blueprint output response instead of requesting one at a time (as of now we can request one of the following - host_groups, configurations, configuration-dependencies not a combination/al of them) - Provide HA blueprint recommendation in stack advisor (creating handcrafted blueprint without using StackAdvisor limits the potential of StackAdvisor component) - Recommend appropriate hosts to services based on the host resource availability and service resource requirements was: StackAdvisor component as of now can recommend and validate component layout and configurations. Precisely, we can request StackAdvisor API for any of these recommendations (host_groups, configurations, configuration-dependencies). Though StackAdvisor has got the host specific resouce details (memory, cpu, disks, os type, etc.,) it does not use these details while recommending the host-component mapping. Applications/Service Providers that are using Amabri Rest API/Blueprints to provision and manage Hadoop clusters will largely benefit if Stack Advisor component is enhanced to address following GAPs - Support for Heterogenous hosts (Master, Slaves, Clients) - Provide both host group and configuration recommendations in same blueprint output response instead of requesting one at a time (as of now we can request one of the following - host_groups, configurations, configuration-dependencies not a combination/al of them) -Provide HA blueprint recommendation in stack advisor (creating handcrafted blueprint without using StackAdvisor limits the potential of StackAdvisor component) - Recommend appropriate hosts to services based on the host resource availability and service resource requirements > Enhance Stack Advisor to support Blueprint recommendation > --------------------------------------------------------- > > Key: AMBARI-13300 > URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/AMBARI-13300 > Project: Ambari > Issue Type: Improvement > Components: ambari-server, blueprints > Reporter: Vijay Srinivasaraghavan > > StackAdvisor component as of now can recommend and validate component layout > and configurations. Precisely, we can > request StackAdvisor API for any of these recommendations (host_groups, > configurations, configuration-dependencies). > Though StackAdvisor has got the host specific resouce details (memory, cpu, > disks, os type, etc.,) it does not use these details while recommending the > host-component mapping. > Applications/Service Providers that are using Amabri Rest API/Blueprints to > provision and manage Hadoop clusters will largely benefit if Stack Advisor > component is enhanced to address following GAPs > - Support for Heterogenous hosts (Master, Slaves, Clients) > - Provide both host group and configuration recommendations in same blueprint > output response instead of requesting one at > a time (as of now we can request one of the following - host_groups, > configurations, configuration-dependencies not a combination/al of them) > - Provide HA blueprint recommendation in stack advisor (creating handcrafted > blueprint without using StackAdvisor limits > the potential of StackAdvisor component) > - Recommend appropriate hosts to services based on the host resource > availability and service resource requirements -- This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA (v6.3.4#6332)