Thomas, Wouldn't you need to call a separate procedural vote for whether changes cannot be allowed into 3.x without requiring they be submitted to 4.x as there was a disagreement there? Also, I am not sure that the procedural vote argument can be used here for 4.x given that it involves modifications to existing code. I would say we should drive towards getting a consensus by addressing the concerns folks have about 4.x.
On Thu, Aug 31, 2017 at 8:24 PM, Thomas Weise <t...@apache.org> wrote: > There wasn't any more discussion on this, so here is the result: > > 1. Version 4.0 as major version change from 3.x > ==================================== > > +1 (7) > > Thomas Weise (PMC) > Ananth G > Vlad Rozov (PMC) > Munagala Ramanath (committer) > Pramod Immaneni (PMC) > Sanjay Pujare > David Yan (PMC) > > -1 (3) > > Amol Kekre (PMC) > Sergey Golovko > Ashwin Chandra Putta (committer) > > > 2. Version 1.0 with simultaneous change of Maven artifact IDs > =============================================== > > +1 (5) > > Thomas Weise (PMC) > Ananth G > Vlad Rozov (PMC) > Munagala Ramanath (committer) > David Yan (PMC) > > -1 (5) > > Pramod Immaneni (PMC) > Sanjay Pujare > Amol Kekre (PMC) > Sergey Golovko > Ashwin Chandra Putta (committer) > > > RESULT > ======= > > Vote for option 1 (major version 4.x) *passes* with majority rule [1]. > > Thanks, > Thomas > > > [1] https://www.apache.org/foundation/voting.html > > > On Mon, Aug 21, 2017 at 6:39 PM, Thomas Weise <t...@apache.org> wrote: > > > This is to formalize the major version change for Malhar discussed in > [1]. > > > > There are two options for major version change. Major version change will > > rename legacy packages to org.apache.apex sub packages while retaining > file > > history in git. Other cleanup such as removing deprecated code is also > > expected. > > > > 1. Version 4.0 as major version change from 3.x > > > > 2. Version 1.0 with simultaneous change of Maven artifact IDs > > > > Please refer to the discussion thread [1] for reasoning behind both of > the > > options. > > > > Please vote on both options. Primary vote for your preferred option, > > secondary for the other. Secondary vote can be used when counting primary > > vote alone isn't conclusive. > > > > Vote will be open for at least 72 hours. > > > > Thanks, > > Thomas > > > > [1] https://lists.apache.org/thread.html/bd1db8a2d01e23b0c0ab98a785f6ee > > 9492a1ac9e52d422568a46e5f3@%3Cdev.apex.apache.org%3E > > >
