Richard,

I suspect your -1 reflects a misunderstanding of the proposal and the [discuss] thread brought some clarification. Are you staying at -1?

Hadrian


On 11/26/2015 06:09 AM, Richard Downer wrote:
* brooklyn - all files in the root (no subdirs)

-1

The files in the root are:

LICENSE
NOTICE
README.md
.gitignore
.gitattribues
pom.xml

All of these except pom.xml would also be present in every *other*
repository, with minor modifications. This repo is not pulling its
weight.

* brooklyn-dist
     usage/all
     usage/dist
     usage/scripts
     usage/downstream-parent
     usage/archetypes

My recommendation: drop `brooklyn-dist` and put all of this stuff into
`brooklyn`.

I'm with Mike on this one; 6 repositories - now 7 if there's a new one
for the Go CLI - risks overcomplicating things (and not just for
newcomers).

A top-level project for the distribution and odds and ends, plus
projects for "server", "web UI", "CLI" and "docs" is IMO acceptable -
to most observers it's a logical split and people would know where
they need to work. I'd accept "library" on the basis that we're trying
to obsolete it by having a catalog of pure-YAML blueprints, but I
suspect that it is going to hang around for quite a long time.

Richard.

Reply via email to