I think the configuration is OK, but there are some big upgrade of
Jetty, jaxws, jaxb in the CXF 2.3.x will make the user to do adjustment
his runtime evironment. Fortunately camel-cxf have nothing to with it.
I just did some work to make camel-cxf work with CXF 2.2.x and CXF 2.3.x
at the same time.
The user can make their own choice now :)
On 11/5/10 4:33 AM, William Tam wrote:
I think there are reasons not to (not sure if they are good reasons though)
* Don't have to touch Camel 2.x camel-cxf component We can then direct
the effort/focus to Camel 3 to make it happen sooner.
* We probably still don't know this for sure yet. Besides the runtime,
spring configuration and camel-cxf APIs probably should be backward
compatible. Otherwise, Camel 2.6 upgrade could mean configuration change
exercises for users.
On 11/04/2010 03:28 PM, Hadrian Zbarcea wrote:
Is there a good reason not to?
One would use the camel-cxf component either to expose a route as a ws
(from) or to invoke a ws (to). From this point of view, the backward
compatibility we require is on the wire, which I am pretty certain we
do satisfy. The other issue is deployment, camel having a new set of
dependencies would require an app to upgrade. In an osgi environment
that should not be a problem. In a webapp it could be a bit
problematic, but if the camel piece is in a separate war, that should
be fine too.
By the way, this is a discussion for dev@, not us...@.
Cheers
Hadrian
On Nov 4, 2010, at 10:40 AM, William Tam wrote:
Willem and I would like to start a discussion regarding which release
of Camel should be upgraded to CXF 2.3. There is a lot of good
reasons to upgrade to CXF 2.3. However, upgrading it in Camel 2.6
could mean stopping supporting CXF 2.2.x in the future Camel 2.x
releases. (see https://issues.apache.org/activemq/browse/CAMEL-3308)
It also means that users who upgrade to Camel 2.6 will be forced to
upgrade to CXF 2.3. It is almost certain that Camel 3 will have CXF
2.3.x, which (Camel 3) is targeted from 1st quarter of 2011. It is
not that far away. So, let's hear your opinion on whether we should
upgrade to CXF 2.3 in Camel 2.6 or not?
Thanks,
Willem and William
--
Willem
----------------------------------
FuseSource
Web: http://www.fusesource.com
Blog: http://willemjiang.blogspot.com (English)
http://jnn.javaeye.com (Chinese)
Twitter: willemjiang
