Hi,
For the others, the incompatible stuff are:
- the version range in the OSGi import statement (it should be something
like [2.2,4) instead of [2.2,3)
- in Karaf 3.0 (trunk), we moved some packages from gogo to karaf, and
so the import statement should be improved
On the other hand, in Karaf 3.0, we introduce shell namespace 1.1
instead of 1.0 which is better for commands definition.
I'm not very in favour of extracting the commands from the camel-core
feature. However, it can make sense:
- if an user doesn't want to provide shell commands in its Karaf runtime
(for instance, to force management of routes via JMX or pro grammatically)
- to fix the current issue
However, I see different solutions:
- once Karaf 3.0 is out, why not to decide the "break" the Karaf 2.2 in
Camel or CXF. It's what we already did. For instance, with Karaf <
2.2.6, you can't install latest CXF version (due to a missing feature
provided by Karaf). So we "forced" users to upgrade to a new Karaf 2.2.x
version. It's right that it's a "minor" ugprade comparing to Karaf 3.0
- we can stay with shell 1.0.0 namespace, upgrade the version range to
[2.2,4) and define gogo and karaf import as optional. Like this we can
support both Karaf 2.2 and Karaf 3.0 version in the same CXF/Camel version.
- provide a "transition" package in Karaf 3.0 (gogo package) which use
the Karaf one.
Regards
JB
On 04/30/2012 11:18 AM, Christian Schneider wrote:
Hi all,
we provide some camel commands for karaf in our distro. With Karaf 3
there are some incompatible changes in the command API. So currently
camel does not install on Karaf 3.
I will try to work out a solution for the commands to ideally make them
compatible.
For the moment though I propose we remove the command bundle from the
camel-core feature and move it to a command that can be installed
spearately. So Camel can already be used and tested on Karaf 3. Is this
ok? If yes for what versions of camel should I do this change? I think
2.9.x and trunk could make sense.
Christian
--
Jean-Baptiste Onofré
jbono...@apache.org
http://blog.nanthrax.net
Talend - http://www.talend.com
