On 9 August 2015 at 19:42, Dennis E. Hamilton <[email protected]> wrote:
> General remark: > > My sense is that an assessment against the ASF maturity model is in > addition to other requirements for graduation from the incubator. > I think you are right here...for me it was a experiment (I made it too for another project we both know). I know there is a big discussion in IPMC and Incubator about graduation so it was an experiment to see how honest I could be. For sure when we come closer to graduation, all the question marks should be replaced with "yes, we interpret it as ....". > > Also, the footnotes matter. The Model is meant to be generic, which is > why it does not go down to specifics about libraries, etc. > I did read the footnotes, but found e.g. no explanation about libraries. And if you use the generic term libraries, where do we stop ? > > I also think that it will be very ASF-friendly if assessment remarks > simply declare how a particular element is taken to apply, and where > supporting information about further details is found. > I am not sure I understand what you mean, I have tried to keep answer neutral, and commented below, but maybe you mean something different ? rgds jan I. > > - Dennis > > [ ... ] > > > On 9 Aug 2015, at 11:20 pm, jan i <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > Hi. > > > > I just spent a few hours having fun. > > > > I made a wiki page, with the maturity model > > > https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/Corinthia/The+Apache+Project+Maturity+Model > > > > Actually quite an interesting job. Please have a look at my responses, > and > > let us see where we > > end up. > > > > I found some of the questions, directly wrong or at the very least > > misleading. I also lacked some questions about how the community is > > actually doing. > > > > My intention is to see your reactions (and incorporate that), and then > > start a new discussion on general@ because if this is something podlings > > should fill up, some of the questions need to > > be changed or better documented. > > > > rgds > > jan i. > > >
