On Thu, Jun 19, 2025 at 7:42 PM Ori Kam <or...@nvidia.com> wrote: > > > Nice idea, > Some comments: > > > 1. The first link is broken for me.
Yes. https://github.com/DPDK/dpdk-ai-code-review is the proposed name of the repository. It is not created yet. > > 2. I like the idea that there is a separate GitHub repository. If I > understand correctly the new repository is a clone of the main one, > and only used by the bot is that correct? Yes. > > 3. I think main usage is also for the reviewer, just like in your example. Yes > > 4. The only thing I’m missing is that there is no “personal touch” > meaning that each reviewer puts emphasis on different things. It will > be great if the AI can learn from previous reviews of the reviewer > and add review accordingly. Yes. However, It looks like https://docs.sourcery.ai/Code-Review/ dont have that feature. > > 5. It will also be great if the AI could target people who may be > interested in this patch. And send them some notification or tell > the developer to add them in the to Good input. Adding @Aaron Conole . He has some plans to implement this workflow. > > Best, > Ori > > On 13/06/2025 13:03, Jerin Jacob wrote: > > > > Goals > > ------- > > > > # Leverage modern AI-powered code review tools to accelerate and supplement > > human review efforts. > > # Prevent AI-generated comments from cluttering the mailing list or > > polluting the main DPDK GitHub repository. > > > > Setup > > ------- > > > > # Create a dedicated repository: > > Set up a new repository, for example: > > https://github.com/DPDK/dpdk-ai-code-review, under the official DPDK GitHub > > organization. > > This ensures that AI-generated pull requests do not interfere with the main > > repository (https://github.com/DPDK/dpdk). > > > > # Select an AI review tool: > > Use a free, open-source-friendly AI code review service. > > One potential candidate is Sourcery: https://sourcery.ai/pricing > > > > # Connect the tool: > > Integrate Sourcery with the new repository via: > > https://app.sourcery.ai/?product=prod_opensource > > > > # Trigger AI reviews: > > Once integrated, any pull request to this repository will automatically > > trigger a code review by the AI tool. > > Example of a test PR reviewed by the AI bot: > > https://github.com/MarvellEmbeddedProcessors/dao/pull/2 > > > > Workflow > > ------------- > > > > # When a patch is sent to the DPDK mailing list, a bot will convert it into > > a GitHub pull request on the dpdk-ai-code-review repository. > > # The AI tool will review the pull request and leave comments directly on > > the PR. > > # Once the AI review is complete, the bot will close the PR and share the > > PR URL: > > - As a comment in Patchwork URL for the given patch > > - With the patch author directly. > > # The author can review the AI-generated comments by visiting the PR URL, > > if they choose to do so. > > > > >
