You are right. The citation was from 4.0.1. I looked into 4.1.0 and there this statement is gone and has been replaced by "If none of the old exports are used, then the old exports must be removed. Otherwise, all old exports must remain available for existing bundles and future resolves until the refreshPackages method is called or the Framework is restarted."
But even in this situation when I uninstall the obr bundle I would say that we are in the first situation "If none of the old exports are used, then the old exports must be removed.", And I do not think that ths should be related to the order I uninstall the bundles. It sounds like if the usage count for an exported package of an uninstalled bundle reaches 0 the exported package must be removed. Do you think is something more about the subject on 4.2? On Mon, Jul 28, 2008 at 9:23 PM, Richard S. Hall <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > From my interpretation of the spec, a bundle is only refreshed if it is > pending removal. In this case OBR, is not pending removal. > > For your example 2, I am pretty sure that this has been changed and that you > are free to use uninstalled packages to resolve new dependencies. I am not > sure if this was added in 4.1 or will be added in 4.2, but I am fairly > certain it was changed. > > -> richard > > Alin Dreghiciu wrote: >> >> Indeed the complete refresh worked as can be seen bellow on <Example >> 1>. But that still does not comply to the specs in my view as on doing >> refresh on a bundle the framework should re-resolve the bundle. At >> least that is what I got from the specs, but the specs are not very >> clear about this. Maybe I should post a clarification issue with OSGi >> Alliance. And equinox/kf does that but they may be wrong interpreting >> the specs. >> >> In <Example 2> you can find a different case with even uninstalling >> the obr bundle and then install it again. The obr bundle still gets >> resolved. And about this the specs are clear (section 4.3.8): >> "Packages of uninstalled bundles must not be used by newly installed >> bundles..." >> >> <Example 1> >> ------------------- >> -> ps >> START LEVEL 6 >> ID State Level Name >> [ 0] [Active ] [ 0] System Bundle (1.0.4) >> [ 1] [Active ] [ 5] Apache Felix Bundle Repository >> (1.1.0.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 2] [Active ] [ 1] osgi.compendium (4.0.1) >> [ 3] [Active ] [ 1] Apache Felix Shell Service (1.0.1) >> [ 4] [Active ] [ 1] Apache Felix Shell TUI (1.0.1) >> -> headers 1 >> >> Apache Felix Bundle Repository (1) >> ---------------------------------- >> Tool = Bnd-0.0.238 >> Bundle-Activator = org.apache.felix.bundlerepository.Activator >> Created-By = Apache Maven Bundle Plugin >> Bnd-LastModified = 1217270914325 >> Export-Service = org.osgi.service.obr.RepositoryAdmin >> Built-By = alindreghiciu >> Private-Package = >> >> org.apache.felix.bundlerepository,org.apache.felix.bundlerepository.metadataparser,org.apache.felix.bundlerepository.metadataparser.kxmlsax,org.kxml2.io,org.kxml2.kdom,org.kxml2.wap,org.kxml2.wap.syncml,org.kxml2.wap.wml,org.kxml2.wap.wv,org.xmlpull.v1 >> Export-Package = >> org.osgi.service.obr;uses:="org.osgi.framework";version="1.0" >> Bundle-Version = 1.1.0.SNAPSHOT >> Bundle-License = http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0.txt >> Build-Jdk = 1.5.0_13 >> Bundle-Source = >> >> http://oscar-osgi.sf.net/obr2/org.apache.felix.bundlerepository/org.apache.felix.bundlerepository-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT-src.jar >> Manifest-Version = 1.0 >> Bundle-Vendor = The Apache Software Foundation >> Bundle-ManifestVersion = 2 >> Bundle-Url = >> http://oscar-osgi.sf.net/obr2/org.apache.felix.bundlerepository/org.apache.felix.bundlerepository-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT.jar >> DynamicImport-Package = org.apache.felix.shell >> Bundle-DocURL = >> http://oscar-osgi.sf.net/obr2/org.apache.felix.bundlerepository/ >> Import-Package = >> >> org.osgi.framework;version="1.3",org.osgi.service.log;version="1.3.0",org.osgi.service.obr;version="1.0" >> Bundle-Name = Apache Felix Bundle Repository >> Ignore-Package = org.xml.sax,javax.xml.parsers >> Bundle-Description = Bundle repository service. >> Bundle-SymbolicName = org.apache.felix.bundlerepository >> -> uninstall 2 >> -> ps >> START LEVEL 6 >> ID State Level Name >> [ 0] [Active ] [ 0] System Bundle (1.0.4) >> [ 1] [Active ] [ 5] Apache Felix Bundle Repository >> (1.1.0.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 3] [Active ] [ 1] Apache Felix Shell Service (1.0.1) >> [ 4] [Active ] [ 1] Apache Felix Shell TUI (1.0.1) >> -> refresh 1 >> -> ps >> START LEVEL 6 >> ID State Level Name >> [ 0] [Active ] [ 0] System Bundle (1.0.4) >> [ 1] [Active ] [ 5] Apache Felix Bundle Repository >> (1.1.0.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 3] [Active ] [ 1] Apache Felix Shell Service (1.0.1) >> [ 4] [Active ] [ 1] Apache Felix Shell TUI (1.0.1) >> -> refresh >> -> ps >> START LEVEL 6 >> ID State Level Name >> [ 0] [Active ] [ 0] System Bundle (1.0.4) >> [ 1] [Installed ] [ 5] Apache Felix Bundle Repository >> (1.1.0.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 3] [Active ] [ 1] Apache Felix Shell Service (1.0.1) >> [ 4] [Active ] [ 1] Apache Felix Shell TUI (1.0.1) >> -> start 1 >> org.osgi.framework.BundleException: Unresolved package in bundle 1: >> package; (&(package=org.osgi.service.log)(version>=1.3.0))-> >> >> <Example 2> >> ------------------- >> -> ps >> START LEVEL 6 >> ID State Level Name >> [ 0] [Active ] [ 0] System Bundle (1.0.4) >> [ 1] [Active ] [ 5] Apache Felix Bundle Repository >> (1.1.0.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 2] [Active ] [ 1] osgi.compendium (4.0.1) >> [ 3] [Active ] [ 1] OPS4J Pax Url - classpath: (0.3.2.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 4] [Active ] [ 1] OPS4J Pax Url - mvn: (0.3.2.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 5] [Active ] [ 1] OPS4J Pax Url - war:, war-i: (0.3.2.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 6] [Active ] [ 1] OPS4J Pax Url - wrap: (0.3.2.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 7] [Active ] [ 1] Apache Felix Shell Service (1.0.1) >> [ 8] [Active ] [ 1] Apache Felix Shell TUI (1.0.1) >> -> uninstall 2 >> -> uninstall 1 >> -> ps >> START LEVEL 6 >> ID State Level Name >> [ 0] [Active ] [ 0] System Bundle (1.0.4) >> [ 3] [Active ] [ 1] OPS4J Pax Url - classpath: (0.3.2.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 4] [Active ] [ 1] OPS4J Pax Url - mvn: (0.3.2.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 5] [Active ] [ 1] OPS4J Pax Url - war:, war-i: (0.3.2.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 6] [Active ] [ 1] OPS4J Pax Url - wrap: (0.3.2.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 7] [Active ] [ 1] Apache Felix Shell Service (1.0.1) >> [ 8] [Active ] [ 1] Apache Felix Shell TUI (1.0.1) >> -> install >> mvn:org.apache.felix/org.apache.felix.bundlerepository/1.1.0-SNAPSHOT >> Bundle ID: 9 >> -> ps >> START LEVEL 6 >> ID State Level Name >> [ 0] [Active ] [ 0] System Bundle (1.0.4) >> [ 3] [Active ] [ 1] OPS4J Pax Url - classpath: (0.3.2.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 4] [Active ] [ 1] OPS4J Pax Url - mvn: (0.3.2.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 5] [Active ] [ 1] OPS4J Pax Url - war:, war-i: (0.3.2.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 6] [Active ] [ 1] OPS4J Pax Url - wrap: (0.3.2.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 7] [Active ] [ 1] Apache Felix Shell Service (1.0.1) >> [ 8] [Active ] [ 1] Apache Felix Shell TUI (1.0.1) >> [ 9] [Installed ] [ 5] Apache Felix Bundle Repository >> (1.1.0.SNAPSHOT) >> -> start 9 >> -> ps >> START LEVEL 6 >> ID State Level Name >> [ 0] [Active ] [ 0] System Bundle (1.0.4) >> [ 3] [Active ] [ 1] OPS4J Pax Url - classpath: (0.3.2.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 4] [Active ] [ 1] OPS4J Pax Url - mvn: (0.3.2.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 5] [Active ] [ 1] OPS4J Pax Url - war:, war-i: (0.3.2.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 6] [Active ] [ 1] OPS4J Pax Url - wrap: (0.3.2.SNAPSHOT) >> [ 7] [Active ] [ 1] Apache Felix Shell Service (1.0.1) >> [ 8] [Active ] [ 1] Apache Felix Shell TUI (1.0.1) >> [ 9] [Active ] [ 5] Apache Felix Bundle Repository >> (1.1.0.SNAPSHOT) >> -> >> >> >> On Mon, Jul 28, 2008 at 7:43 PM, Karl Pauls <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> >>> >>> I think the issue is that you did only refresh the obr bundle. The other >>> bundle is still around and can be used until the framework is refreshed. >>> Can >>> you try whether doing a complete refresh makes a difference? >>> >>> regards, >>> >>> Karl >>> >>> Von meinem iPhone gesendet >>> >>> Am 28.07.2008 um 18:58 schrieb "Alin Dreghiciu" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: >>> >>> >>>> >>>> Hi guys, >>>> >>>> While working on FELIX-482 I had the following (interesting) situation: >>>> >>>> 1. I had obr bundle importing org.osgi.service.log package (not optional >>>> import) >>>> 2. On a new felix instance I installed the the osgi compendium bundle >>>> that exports the log package >>>> 3. Installed obr bundle. The obr bundle gets resolved and could be >>>> started (as expected till now) >>>> 4. Uninstalled the cosgi compendium bundle >>>> 5. Refreshed packages for obr bundle. But the obr bundle was still >>>> resolved and could be started. This is the part I did not expect. >>>> >>>> Is this a known bug? Out of curiosity I did the same on equinox/kf and >>>> as expected on step 5 the obr bundle could not be resolved. >>>> >>>> -- >>>> Alin Dreghiciu >>>> http://www.ops4j.org - New Energy for OSS Communities - Open >>>> Participation Software. >>>> http://www.qi4j.org - New Energy for Java - Domain Driven Development. >>>> http://malaysia.jayway.net - New Energy for Projects - Great People >>>> working on Great Projects at Great Places >>>> >>> >>> >> >> >> >> > -- Alin Dreghiciu http://www.ops4j.org - New Energy for OSS Communities - Open Participation Software. http://www.qi4j.org - New Energy for Java - Domain Driven Development. http://malaysia.jayway.net - New Energy for Projects - Great People working on Great Projects at Great Places
