[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/FELIX-2673?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel
]
Emily Jiang closed FELIX-2673.
------------------------------
Resolution: Not A Problem
This jira is caused by the different behaviour for mandatory directive
handling. However, it might save me a lot of time if any committer can comment
or offer any help for my questions in this jira regarding whether there is any
mandatory directive handling changes between the releases.
> Mandatory directive stoped working on OBR 1.6.4. It worked OBR 1.4.1
> --------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: FELIX-2673
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/FELIX-2673
> Project: Felix
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: Bundle Repository (OBR)
> Affects Versions: bundlerepository-1.6.4
> Reporter: Emily Jiang
>
> I moved up to bundlerepository-1.6.4 from bundlerepository-1.4.1 and found
> the mandatory directive stoped working. I have three bundles obr.bundle121,
> obr.bundle122 and obr.bundle123. Their manifest.mf files are shown below:
> bundle obr.bundle121:
> Manifest-Version: 1.0
> Bundle-ManifestVersion: 2
> Bundle-Name: Bundle Plug-in
> Bundle-SymbolicName: obr.bundle121
> Bundle-Version: 3.0.0
> Bundle-Vendor: IBM
> Export-Package:obr.bundle121
> Import-Package:org.componenttest.logging,
> obr.bundle122;version="2.3";company=mood;local=yes
> bundle obr.bundle122:
> Manifest-Version: 1.0
> Bundle-ManifestVersion: 2
> Bundle-Name: Bundle Plug-in
> Bundle-SymbolicName: obr.bundle122
> Bundle-Version: 1.0.0
> Bundle-Vendor: IBM
> Import-Package: org.componenttest.logging
> Export-Package:
> obr.bundle122;version=3;company=mood;local=yes;security=yes;mandatory:="company,security"
> bundle obr.bundle123:
> Manifest-Version: 1.0
> Bundle-ManifestVersion: 2
> Bundle-Name: Bundle Plug-in
> Bundle-SymbolicName: obr.bundle123
> Bundle-Version: 3.0
> Bundle-Vendor: IBM
> Import-Package: org.componenttest.logging
> Export-Package:
> obr.bundle122;version=2.4;company=mood;local=yes;security=yes;mandatory:="company,local"
> When I provision obr.bundle121, obr.bundle122 was identified as required
> instead of obr.bundle123. As a conseqence, the obr.bundle121 cannot be
> started after installation, as the obr.bundle122 has mandatory requirement of
> 'company' and 'security', which obr.bundle121 does not provide. However,
> obr.bundle121 provides the mandatory attributes required by obr.bundle123,
> which also exports the package at the version of which obr.bundle121 needs.
> The OBR provisioner should wire the obr.bundle121 to the bundle obr.bundle123
> instead of obr.bundle122. It suggests the mandatory directive is not
> functioning in the new OBR level.
> Below is the repository.xml to represent the bundle manifest.
> <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
> <repository name="obr.eba12.eba_1.0.0">
> <resource id="org.componenttest.logging/1.0.0" presentationname="Logging
> Plug-in" symbolicname="org.componenttest.logging" uri="" version="1.0.0">
> <capability name="bundle">
> <p n="presentationname" v="Logging Plug-in"/>
> <p n="version" t="version" v="1.0.0"/>
> <p n="symbolicname" v="org.componenttest.logging"/>
> <p n="Bundle-ManifestVersion" v="2"/>
> <p n="mandatory" v=""/>
> </capability>
> <capability name="package">
> <p n="package" v="org.componenttest.logging"/>
> <p n="version" t="version" v="0.0.0"/>
> <p n="bundle-symbolic-name" v="org.componenttest.logging"/>
> <p n="bundle-version" t="version" v="1.0.0"/>
> <p n="mandatory" v=""/>
> </capability>
> <capability name="service">
> <p n="service" v="service"/>
> <p n="osgi.service.blueprint.compname" v="ResultLoggerImpl"/>
> <p n="objectClass" t="set" v="org.componenttest.logging.ResultLogger"/>
> <p n="service.ranking" v="0"/>
> <p n="mandatory" v=""/>
> </capability>
> <require extend="false"
> filter="(&(package=org.osgi.framework)(version>=1.3.0)(version<=2.0.0)(!(version=2.0.0)))"
> multiple="false" name="package" optional="false">Requires package with
> attributes {package=org.osgi.framework, version=[1.3.0,2.0.0)}</require>
> </resource>
> <resource id="obr.bundle121/3.0.0" presentationname="Bundle Plug-in"
> symbolicname="obr.bundle121" uri="" version="3.0.0">
> <capability name="bundle">
> <p n="presentationname" v="Bundle Plug-in"/>
> <p n="version" t="version" v="3.0.0"/>
> <p n="symbolicname" v="obr.bundle121"/>
> <p n="Bundle-ManifestVersion" v="2"/>
> <p n="mandatory" v=""/>
> </capability>
> <capability name="package">
> <p n="package" v="obr.bundle121"/>
> <p n="version" t="version" v="0.0.0"/>
> <p n="bundle-symbolic-name" v="obr.bundle121"/>
> <p n="bundle-version" t="version" v="3.0.0"/>
> <p n="mandatory" v=""/>
> </capability>
> <require extend="false"
> filter="(&(package=org.componenttest.logging)(version>=0.0.0))"
> multiple="false" name="package" optional="false">Requires package with
> attributes {package=org.componenttest.logging, version=0.0.0}</require>
> <require extend="false"
> filter="(&(package=obr.bundle122)(version>=2.3.0)(local=yes)(company=mood)(mandatory:<*local,
> company))" multiple="false" name="package" optional="false">Requires package
> with attributes {package=obr.bundle122, version=2.3.0, local=yes,
> company=mood}</require>
> </resource>
> <resource id="obr.bundle122/1.0.0" presentationname="Bundle Plug-in"
> symbolicname="obr.bundle122" uri="" version="1.0.0">
> <capability name="bundle">
> <p n="presentationname" v="Bundle Plug-in"/>
> <p n="version" t="version" v="1.0.0"/>
> <p n="symbolicname" v="obr.bundle122"/>
> <p n="Bundle-ManifestVersion" v="2"/>
> <p n="mandatory" v=""/>
> </capability>
> <capability name="package">
> <p n="security" v="yes"/>
> <p n="mandatory" v="company,security"/>
> <p n="package" v="obr.bundle122"/>
> <p n="version" t="version" v="3"/>
> <p n="local" v="yes"/>
> <p n="bundle-symbolic-name" v="obr.bundle122"/>
> <p n="company" v="mood"/>
> <p n="bundle-version" t="version" v="1.0.0"/>
> </capability>
> <require extend="false"
> filter="(&(package=org.componenttest.logging)(version>=0.0.0))"
> multiple="false" name="package" optional="false">Requires package with
> attributes {package=org.componenttest.logging, version=0.0.0}</require>
> </resource>
> <resource id="obr.bundle123/3.0.0" presentationname="Bundle Plug-in"
> symbolicname="obr.bundle123" uri="" version="3.0.0">
> <capability name="bundle">
> <p n="presentationname" v="Bundle Plug-in"/>
> <p n="version" t="version" v="3.0"/>
> <p n="symbolicname" v="obr.bundle123"/>
> <p n="Bundle-ManifestVersion" v="2"/>
> <p n="mandatory" v=""/>
> </capability>
> <capability name="package">
> <p n="security" v="yes"/>
> <p n="mandatory" v="company,local"/>
> <p n="package" v="obr.bundle122"/>
> <p n="version" t="version" v="2.4"/>
> <p n="local" v="yes"/>
> <p n="bundle-symbolic-name" v="obr.bundle123"/>
> <p n="company" v="mood"/>
> <p n="bundle-version" t="version" v="3.0.0"/>
> </capability>
> <require extend="false"
> filter="(&(package=org.componenttest.logging)(version>=0.0.0))"
> multiple="false" name="package" optional="false">Requires package with
> attributes {package=org.componenttest.logging, version=0.0.0}</require>
> </resource>
> </repository>
> Are there any xml changes in mandatory directive expression between version
> 1.4.1 and 1.6.4? If not, there is a regression, as it works on
> bundlerepsoitory-1.4.1.
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
-
You can reply to this email to add a comment to the issue online.
