Hi

I intend to use extra (optional) XML attributes with the Metatype Service. For 
this purpose I examined the
Felix metatype service implementation and found the class 
org.apache.felix.metatype.OptionalAttributes,
which is extended by AD, OCD, ... . But unluckily this class is neither 
inherited by LocalizedObjectClassDefinition
nor by LocalizedAttributeDefinition, which makes it quite useless for the 
moment.

Another Problem is that OptionalAttributes does not support XML namespaces for 
the attribute names.
The underlying Map should use something like javax.xml.namespace.QName as key 
and not just the name
of the attribute (String). Note, XML namespace support is crucial as extra XML 
attribute have to be in a different (##other) namespace
(see "Metatype Service Specifiaction" (Version 1.2), section 105.9 "XML 
Schema").

The above observations lead me to the following question:

1.      Is it still a requirement for Felix subprojects to avoid dependencies 
on packages like java.xml.** and rely on kxml2 instead?
a.      If so, then I could try create a patch for metatype service which will 
add support for extra XML attributes (including XML namespace support but not 
using javax.xml.namespace.QName),
            so that extra XML attributes could be retrieved from AD, OCD, ..., 
LocalizedObjectClassDefinition and LocalizedAttributeDefinition instances.
b.      If not, then I could try to create a similar patch as described above 
(a) but using javax.xml.namespace.QName instead.

Note, the class javax.xml.namespace.QName is part of JavaSE since version 1.5 
older versions as well as JavaME do not contain that class.

Alex


Reply via email to