[ 
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/FELIX-6565?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel
 ]

Amit Mondal updated FELIX-6565:
-------------------------------
    Description: 
Currently, the Felix HealthCheck core bundle mandatorily imports 
org.osgi.service.http package which is used by 
{_}*HealthCheckExecutorServlet*{_}. In our current system, we don't use HTTP at 
all, hence, neither _*javax.servlet*_ nor _** *org.osgi.service.http*_ is 
available in the runtime. Hence, the health checks don't work as it mandatorily 
requires _*org.osgi.service.http*_ package dependency. Since, 
_*HealthCheckExecutorServlet*_ is not a core component for the health checks, 
we can consider the following options:
 # Provide a separate bundle with HTTP dependency (invasive approach)
 # Make _*org.osgi.service.http*_ an optional package for HealthCheck core and 
conditionally enable _*HealthCheckExecutorServlet*_ component if 
_*org.osgi.service.http*_ is wired to the HealthCheck core bundle (similar 
approach we did for Quartz to check the availability of Quartz in runtime)

  was:
Currently, the Felix HealthCheck core bundle mandatorily imports 
_*javax.servlet*_ package which is used by {_}*HealthCheckExecutorServlet*{_}. 
In our current system, we don't use HTTP at all, hence, _*javax.servlet*_ is 
not available in the runtime. Hence, the health checks don't work as it 
mandatorily requires _*javax.servlet*_ package dependency. Since, 
_*HealthCheckExecutorServlet*_ is not a core component for the health checks, 
we can consider the following options:
 # Provide a separate bundle with HTTP dependency (invasive approach)
 # Make _*javax.servlet*_ an optional package for HealthCheck core and 
conditionally enable _*HealthCheckExecutorServlet*_ component if 
_*javax.servlet*_ is wired to the HealthCheck core bundle (similar approach we 
did for Quartz to check the availability of Quartz in runtime)


> Make HTTP Servlet dependency optional in HealthCheck core bundle
> ----------------------------------------------------------------
>
>                 Key: FELIX-6565
>                 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/FELIX-6565
>             Project: Felix
>          Issue Type: Improvement
>          Components: Health Checks
>            Reporter: Amit Mondal
>            Priority: Minor
>              Labels: easyfix
>
> Currently, the Felix HealthCheck core bundle mandatorily imports 
> org.osgi.service.http package which is used by 
> {_}*HealthCheckExecutorServlet*{_}. In our current system, we don't use HTTP 
> at all, hence, neither _*javax.servlet*_ nor _** *org.osgi.service.http*_ is 
> available in the runtime. Hence, the health checks don't work as it 
> mandatorily requires _*org.osgi.service.http*_ package dependency. Since, 
> _*HealthCheckExecutorServlet*_ is not a core component for the health checks, 
> we can consider the following options:
>  # Provide a separate bundle with HTTP dependency (invasive approach)
>  # Make _*org.osgi.service.http*_ an optional package for HealthCheck core 
> and conditionally enable _*HealthCheckExecutorServlet*_ component if 
> _*org.osgi.service.http*_ is wired to the HealthCheck core bundle (similar 
> approach we did for Quartz to check the availability of Quartz in runtime)



--
This message was sent by Atlassian Jira
(v8.20.10#820010)

Reply via email to