Could you add an example to the FLIP for how a user can register a state with the methods in the RichFunction interface?
Currently it only contains an example for the annotation option.

These methods look like they are called by the user, but that doesn't really make sense to me as after all the user has to
implement them.

To me a more intuitive signature would be

|void registerKeyedState(StateDescriptorRegistry registry);|

that is called by the system when a UDF is provided by a user who then registers all the state descriptors he has.

On 04.07.2017 20:00, Tzu-Li (Gordon) Tai wrote:
Hi Flink devs!

I would like to propose the following FLIP - Eager State Declaration for Flink 
managed state: 
https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/FLINK/FLIP-22%3A+Eager+State+Declaration.
The proposal is a result of some offline discussions with Aljoscha Krettek, 
Stephan Ewen, and Stefan Richter.

With how the current managed state declaration interfaces work, users may 
declare state lazily while jobs are running.
This behavior is a direct blocker for several state management features we wish 
to make a reality in the future.
I also see it as an opportunity to make the interfaces for keyed / operator 
managed state declarations more unified at the API level, as well as improved 
user experience for general use cases.

The most important part of the required changes is the deprecation of existing 
APIs and introducing new state declaration interfaces.
Since this would be a rework of the state interfaces, it would be great to hear 
thoughts on this and make sure that the proposal is what we want in the long 
run!

Happy to hear feedback on this :)

Cheers,
Gordon


Reply via email to