Tim Ellison wrote:
Gregory Shimansky wrote:
Tim Ellison wrote:
Gregory Shimansky wrote:
Tim Ellison wrote:
Maybe we do, i.e. where there is no value "-Dfoobar".  So perhaps we
need to say that GetSystemProperty returns VMI_ERROR_NONE and sets the
the *valuePtr to NULL if there is no value; and returns a
VMI_ERROR_NOT_FOUND if the property is undefined.
Now I am confused. What is the difference between a property which has
no value and an undefined property?
Sorry, I meant a property whose value is NULL.  So the three cases are:

1) key = "foo", value = "bar"
2) key = "foo", value = NULL
3) no key called "foo"

If (2) is disallowed then we should document that in SetSystemProperty().
I would prefer to have (2) to be illegal. Can we document this please?

No objection here.  So to attempt a new clarification ...

GetSystemProperty will return VMI_ERROR_NONE and a string value for
existing properties, or NULL value for a non-existent property.

We then rename VMI_ERROR_NOT_FOUND to VMI_ERROR_ILLEGAL_ARG and
SetSystemProperty will return VMI_ERROR_NONE for setting an existing
property to a string value, or VMI_ILLEGAL_ARG if there is an attempt to
set the property value to NULL.

How does that sound?

Why again do we want 2 to be illegal? (Sorry, was out of pocket for a while there yesterday...)

geir

Reply via email to