Sorry for resuming the discussion - i've missed it last week:

2. All the patches should have an evaluation comment

I'm not fully agree with the word "all" and prefer something like "complex"
or "non-trivial" as usually the code says for itself without any additional
comments and the explanation is much longer then the patch itself. Just use
the common sense.

Thoughts?

Thanks,
Mikhail


On 2/5/07, Alexey Petrenko <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

Guys,

I think we need a little update for the "Good issue resolution guideline"
[1]

I suggest the following additions to the "Resolving Issues.If the
issue is a bug" to make committers life much easier :)
1. All the newly introduced message strings should be internationalized
2. All the patches should have an evaluation comment
3. If you change two lines of code please make sure that you patch
includes only these two lines and do not include any other changes
like code formatting.
4. Add yourself to the list of watchers to receive comments and
concerns on your patch.

Thoughts? Concerns? Objections?

SY, Alexey

[1] http://harmony.apache.org/issue_resolution_guideline.html

Reply via email to