Big +1 with Julian :) regards,
François [email protected] [email protected] Le 10/09/2021 à 17:10, Julian Hyde a écrit : > Separately from release 1.0, I think Hop should be considering graduation. A > reminder of the process: the community decides that they are ready to > graduate, passes a vote, the Incubator has a discussion and a vote, then > submits a motion for the next Board meeting. > > I am glad that we are keeping releases separate from graduation. But “Apache > Hop 1.0” sounds a bit more impressive than “Apache Hop 1.0 (Incubating)”. > Just saying. ;) > > Julian > >> On Sep 10, 2021, at 7:47 AM, Matt Casters <[email protected]> >> wrote: >> >> Hi Hops! >> >> The list of tickets >> <https://issues.apache.org/jira/projects/HOP/versions/12350233> for 1.0 >> seems to be getting shorter every day so I think it's time to release our >> iconic 1.0 lest we want to end up in a Duke Nukem Forever scenario. >> >> Anyway, Hop is looking fantastic and I detect some pressure left and right >> to dig in again with new and bigger features and improvements. Doing those >> on 1.0 seems like a bad idea. Let's cut a 1.0 release instead somewhere >> next week and move the master snapshot version to 1.1.0 >> >> I would propose to do the sensible and simple thing and release minor >> versions going forward in a Major.Minor.Patch version naming scheme. I >> know a lot of other projects like Beam only release patch level 0 but it >> doesn't hurt to have it just in case we make a horrible mistake >> <https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/VFS-807> along the way. >> >> The major versions I would reserve for the larger architectural changes and >> in fact I wouldn't wait too long to start working on 2.x with support for >> Java 11. >> >> As far as compatibility is concerned I would first and foremost focus on >> the Hop execution engines on existing metadata. The integration tests are >> our best friends. Java API changes shouldn't concern us too much unless >> they occur in the core of our stack and IMO are of lesser importance for >> plugins. >> >> Ideas for making noise about 1.0 are also welcome! >> >> Cheers, >> Matt
