Thanks. Which version of APR / APR-UTIL are you using? Regards
Rüdiger > -----Original Message----- > From: Joachim Achtzehnter [mailto:joac...@kraut.ca] > Sent: Donnerstag, 4. Februar 2016 03:56 > To: dev@httpd.apache.org > Subject: Re: HTTPS connections lock-up with 2.4.18 > > Perhaps, there is an important clue this time. When I retrieve a file > that works we see the following log messages near the time when the > reply is being written: > > > [Wed Feb 03 18:13:51.402289 2016] [ssl:notice] [pid 1676] [client > 205.159.216.185:55978] bio[9dabd50] out: pass 271 bytes > > [Wed Feb 03 18:13:51.402463 2016] [ssl:notice] [pid 1676] [client > 205.159.216.185:55978] bio[9dabd50] out: pass 4020 bytes > > [Wed Feb 03 18:13:51.402515 2016] [core:notice] [pid 1676] [client > 205.159.216.185:55978] core_output_filter: sent 4291 on 4291 bytes > > [Wed Feb 03 18:13:51.402527 2016] [ssl:notice] [pid 1676] [client > 205.159.216.185:55978] bio[9dabd50] out: METADATA EOS > > [Wed Feb 03 18:13:51.402581 2016] [ssl:notice] [pid 1676] [client > 205.159.216.185:55978] bio[9dabd50] out: METADATA EOR > > [Wed Feb 03 18:13:51.406356 2016] [ssl:notice] [pid 1676] [client > 205.159.216.185:55978] bio[9db96d8] in: read 5 bytes > > [Wed Feb 03 18:13:51.406375 2016] [ssl:notice] [pid 1676] [client > 205.159.216.185:55978] bio[9db96d8] in: read 26 bytes > > [Wed Feb 03 18:13:51.406392 2016] [http:notice] [pid 1676] (70014)End of > file found: [client 205.159.216.185:55978] check_pipeline: no data > > [Wed Feb 03 18:13:51.406476 2016] [http:notice] [pid 1676] (70014)End of > file found: [client 205.159.216.185:55978] check_pipeline: > data_in_input_filters = 0 > > [Wed Feb 03 18:13:51.406492 2016] [ssl:notice] [pid 1676] [client > 205.159.216.185:55978] bio[9dabd50] out: METADATA FLUSH > > [Wed Feb 03 18:13:51.406591 2016] [ssl:notice] [pid 1676] [client > 205.159.216.185:55978] bio[9dabd50] out: METADATA FLUSH > > [Wed Feb 03 18:13:51.406613 2016] [ssl:notice] [pid 1676] [client > 205.159.216.185:55978] bio[9dabd50] out: METADATA EOC > > [Wed Feb 03 18:13:51.406624 2016] [ssl:notice] [pid 1676] [client > 205.159.216.185:55978] bio[9dabd50] out: pass 31 bytes > > [Wed Feb 03 18:13:51.406673 2016] [ssl:notice] [pid 1676] [client > 205.159.216.185:55978] bio[9dabd50] out: FLUSH > > [Wed Feb 03 18:13:51.406723 2016] [core:notice] [pid 1676] [client > 205.159.216.185:55978] core_output_filter: sent 31 on 31 bytes > > [Wed Feb 03 18:13:51.406735 2016] [ssl:debug] [pid 1676] > ssl_engine_io.c(1029): [client 205.159.216.185:55978] AH02001: Connection > closed to child 0 with standard shutdown (server localhost:443) > > Notice the call to check_pipeline returns quickly. Now the same part of > the log for the failing file: > > > [Wed Feb 03 17:56:55.424124 2016] [ssl:notice] [pid 1663] [client > 205.159.216.185:55962] bio[8158d50] out: pass 271 bytes > > [Wed Feb 03 17:56:55.424192 2016] [ssl:notice] [pid 1663] [client > 205.159.216.185:55962] bio[8158d50] out: pass 1727 bytes > > [Wed Feb 03 17:56:55.424223 2016] [ssl:notice] [pid 1663] [client > 205.159.216.185:55962] bio[8158d50] out: METADATA EOS > > [Wed Feb 03 17:56:55.424235 2016] [ssl:notice] [pid 1663] [client > 205.159.216.185:55962] bio[8158d50] out: METADATA EOR > > [Wed Feb 03 18:09:56.652288 2016] [http:notice] [pid 1663] (11)Resource > temporarily unavailable: [client 205.159.216.185:55962] check_pipeline: no > data > > [Wed Feb 03 18:09:56.652376 2016] [http:notice] [pid 1663] (11)Resource > temporarily unavailable: [client 205.159.216.185:55962] check_pipeline: > data_in_input_filters = 0 > > [Wed Feb 03 18:09:56.652398 2016] [ssl:notice] [pid 1663] [client > 205.159.216.185:55962] bio[8158d50] out: METADATA FLUSH > > [Wed Feb 03 18:09:56.652444 2016] [core:notice] [pid 1663] [client > 205.159.216.185:55962] core_output_filter: sent 1998 on 1998 bytes > > [Wed Feb 03 18:09:56.652510 2016] [ssl:info] [pid 1663] (70014)End of > file found: [client 205.159.216.185:55962] AH01991: SSL input filter read > failed. > > [Wed Feb 03 18:09:56.652519 2016] [ssl:notice] [pid 1663] [client > 205.159.216.185:55962] bio[8158d50] out: METADATA FLUSH > > [Wed Feb 03 18:09:56.652525 2016] [ssl:notice] [pid 1663] [client > 205.159.216.185:55962] bio[8158d50] out: METADATA EOC > > [Wed Feb 03 18:09:56.652545 2016] [ssl:notice] [pid 1663] [client > 205.159.216.185:55962] bio[8158d50] out: pass 31 bytes > > [Wed Feb 03 18:09:56.652553 2016] [ssl:notice] [pid 1663] [client > 205.159.216.185:55962] bio[8158d50] out: FLUSH > > [Wed Feb 03 18:09:56.652568 2016] [core:notice] [pid 1663] [client > 205.159.216.185:55962] core_output_filter: sent 31 on 31 bytes > > [Wed Feb 03 18:09:56.652576 2016] [ssl:debug] [pid 1663] > ssl_engine_io.c(1029): [client 205.159.216.185:55962] AH02001: Connection > closed to child 0 with standard shutdown (server localhost:443) > > The check_pipeline call only returns when I kill the client. I first > noticed this in the debugger where httpd was sitting in a blocking read. > Somehow, in this case a blocking read is done instead of a non-blocking > read. > > To be specific, it ended up in the do/while loop that calls read in > function apr_socket_recv (sendrecv.c), called from socket_bucket_read in > apr_buckets_socket.c, called from ap_core_input_filter in > core_filters.c. The block parameter was APR_NONBLOCK_READ, but this > didn't stop the lower-level functions from blocking, somehow. The > apr_socket_recv function seems to do the select version of reading based > on the APR_INCOMPLETE_READ flag in sock->options. > > By the way, to answer an earlier question, this is a prefork server with > separate processes, not threaded. > > Thanks, > > Joachim > > > On 2016-02-03 8:06, Yann Ylavic wrote: > > On Wed, Feb 3, 2016 at 4:53 PM, Yann Ylavic <ylavic....@gmail.com> > wrote: > >> > >> I suggest you use the attached patch instead (replacing any previous > >> one), so that we log the output path taken when mod_ssl is in the > >> place. > > > > Forgot about the casting issue (SSL_get_app_data) with your compiler... > > This v5 (attached) should compile fine. > > > >> > >>> And maybe take network traces on the server side? > >> > >> That would be really nice too. > >> > >>> > >>> Thanks, > >>> Yann. > > -- > joac...@kraut.ca http://www.kraut.ca
