+1 for [ Option 4]
At 2025-04-16 17:25:09, "Wang Critas" <cri...@outlook.com> wrote: >+1 for [ Option 1] >Putting bat and sh scripts together is not very intuitive, and [Option1] like >Kafka[1]. > >[1]: https://github.com/apache/kafka/tree/trunk/bin > >Best regards, >----------------------- >Xuan Wang > > >发件人: 王艺儒 <yiru.w...@timecho.com> >日期: 星期三, 2025年4月16日 17:07 >收件人: dev <dev@iotdb.apache.org> >主题: [DISCUSS]Adjustments to sbin and tools Scripts > >Hi all, >As the number of scripts continues to grow, the current count within a single >sbin directory has reached as high as 27. Moreover, these scripts are >scattered across various projects such as datanode, confignode, cli, and >node-commons, making the search and maintenance of scripts quite inconvenient. >Therefore, we plan to migrate the scripts in the next version, with the main >content as follows: >• Script Central Management: Migrate scripts scattered across different >projects to the scripts/sbin and scripts/tools directories under the root >directory. >• Script Functional Classification: Categorize and move scripts to different >files or subdirectories based on their functionality. For frequently used >scripts, their current locations will be preserved to minimize the impact on >existing workflows. >• Cross-Platform Script Separation: Due to the excessive number of scripts, we >are considering separating Windows and Unix scripts and have proposed the >following four options: > • Option 1: Create a Windows subfolder under the sbin directory (sbin, > sbin/windows). > • Option 2: Create a Windows folder parallel to the sbin directory (sbin, > sbin-windows). > • Option 3: Distinguish during packaging to generate installation packages > for different platforms (apache-iotdb-xxx-SNAPSHOT-all-bin-windows, > apache-iotdb-xxx-SNAPSHOT-all-bin-unix). > • Option 4: Maintain the status quo for the time being (mixed Windows and > Unix). >We sincerely invite community members to vote on these options, with a limit >of two votes per person. Your choice is very important to us and will directly >affect the implementation of the script migration plan.
