On 18 March 2016 at 21:46, Philippe Mouawad <[email protected]> wrote: > Hello, > > Sebb opened a bug 59173 reporting a problem of "spurious" save message when > 4 elements are selected. > > > I fixed 1/4 of these. > The problem is that fixing the 3/4 other "issues" is if not impossible not > simple at all: > > 1/ Access Log Sampler: > > AFAIU (but I may not understand well) , nothing seems to be available > for this case when using > XXXXBeanInfo
True, but it could be added fairly easily. > > 2/ JMS Publisher: > > There was a mistake made in previous release (my fault) when adding 2 > properties. > > Fixing the bug makes code ugly. I personally prefer the spurious > message vs the ugly code. Yes, but you are a developer who understands why this message occurs. I am too, but I still find it very disconcerting when I'm told my test plan has been changed without having done anything. > > > 3/ Backend Listener : > - A new parameter was added , AFAIK (but I may be wrong) we have > nothing currently to handle this case. But it does not hurt me, as > JMeter 3.0 adds a new parameter, the test plan really changed. But this is precisely the issue. The test plan from 2.13 behaves exactly the same in 3.0 (if not, there's another bug). The new parameter defaults to false, so if it is missing the test behaves as before. > - This informs indirectly the user of this new property. But the new property does not change the test unless it is changed from the default, so it's really not helpful. Imagine if your favourite word processor behaved like this. You write a document and save it. Later on you open it in a new version of the program; you don't make any changes. Yet when you close the document the word processor asks you to save it. That would be very disconcerting. You would wonder if you had changed anything by mistake. > > For 1/ and 3/, maybe we can implement it in a future release but I > don't think it should be blocker for the 3.0 release. We have either got to do it now or not at all. Otherwise we have the same issue for plans created in 3.0. > > Regards > Philippe
