Ed,
Thanks for your review, all comments big and small certainly encouraged and welcome. Regarding the JIRAs that are not closed, the actual work has been done so there is nothing material pending. But I did not close them because I wanted @rvs to do that, since he was the one overseeing them. I will ask him to close them at his earliest convenience. Frank On Wed, May 3, 2017 at 8:58 AM, Ed Espino <esp...@apache.org> wrote: > Sorry about the piecemeal observations. I'm currently in Beijing and don't > have a lot of extra large time chunks to review the release in one sitting. > > 1) There are still three outstanding Jira issues in an "Unresolved" state > with a fix version of v1.11. Are they going to be resolved soon? They can > be seen with the following url: > > https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/MADLIB/fixforversion/12339592/? > selectedTab=com.atlassian.jira.jira-projects-plugin:version-summary-panel > > 2) As it relates to the convenience binary release, I noticed an > inconsistent MADLIB_GIT_REVISION value (rel/v1.10.0) spread throughout > several SQLCommon.m4 files. Shouldn't the reference be to v1.11 instead of > v1.10? > > -------------------------------------------- > MAC (notice rel/v1.10.0-30-g0ff829a value): > -------------------------------------------- > > ✔ /usr/local/madlib/Versions > 23:42 $ grep -n -i -r MADLIB_GIT_REVISION * > 1.11/ports/greenplum/modules/utilities/utilities.sql_in:122: 'git > revision: __MADLIB_GIT_REVISION__, ' > 1.11/ports/hawq/modules/utilities/utilities.sql_in:122: 'git > revision: __MADLIB_GIT_REVISION__, ' > 1.11/ports/postgres/9.4/madpack/SQLCommon.m4:20:m4_ > define(`__MADLIB_GIT_REVISION__', > `rel/v1.10.0-30-g0ff829a') > 1.11/ports/postgres/9.5/madpack/SQLCommon.m4:20:m4_ > define(`__MADLIB_GIT_REVISION__', > `rel/v1.10.0-30-g0ff829a') > 1.11/ports/postgres/9.6/madpack/SQLCommon.m4:20:m4_ > define(`__MADLIB_GIT_REVISION__', > `rel/v1.10.0-30-g0ff829a') > 1.11/ports/postgres/modules/utilities/utilities.sql_in:122: 'git > revision: __MADLIB_GIT_REVISION__, ' > > -------------------------------------------- > Linux (notice rel/v1.10.0-31-gd54be2b value): > -------------------------------------------- > > [root@ip-172-31-9-242 Versions]# rpm -qa | grep madlib > madlib-1.11-1.x86_64 > [root@ip-172-31-9-242 Versions]# pwd > /usr/local/madlib/Versions > [root@ip-172-31-9-242 Versions]# grep -n -i -r MADLIB_GIT_REVISION * > 1.11/ports/greenplum/4.2/madpack/SQLCommon.m4:20:m4_ > define(`__MADLIB_GIT_REVISION__', > `rel/v1.10.0-31-gd54be2b') > 1.11/ports/greenplum/4.3/madpack/SQLCommon.m4:20:m4_ > define(`__MADLIB_GIT_REVISION__', > `rel/v1.10.0-31-gd54be2b') > 1.11/ports/greenplum/4.3ORCA/madpack/SQLCommon.m4:20:m4_ > define(`__MADLIB_GIT_REVISION__', > `rel/v1.10.0-31-gd54be2b') > 1.11/ports/greenplum/modules/utilities/utilities.sql_in:122: 'git > revision: __MADLIB_GIT_REVISION__, ' > 1.11/ports/hawq/2/madpack/SQLCommon.m4:20:m4_define(`__ > MADLIB_GIT_REVISION__', > `rel/v1.10.0-31-gd54be2b') > 1.11/ports/hawq/modules/utilities/utilities.sql_in:122: 'git > revision: __MADLIB_GIT_REVISION__, ' > 1.11/ports/postgres/9.5/madpack/SQLCommon.m4:20:m4_ > define(`__MADLIB_GIT_REVISION__', > `rel/v1.10.0-31-gd54be2b') > 1.11/ports/postgres/9.6/madpack/SQLCommon.m4:20:m4_ > define(`__MADLIB_GIT_REVISION__', > `rel/v1.10.0-31-gd54be2b') > 1.11/ports/postgres/modules/utilities/utilities.sql_in:122: 'git > revision: __MADLIB_GIT_REVISION__, ' > [root@ip-172-31-9-242 Versions]# > > On Wed, May 3, 2017 at 12:15 PM, Ed Espino <esp...@apache.org> wrote: > > > I have taken a quick look at the DMG and a Linux RPM binary artifacts > > (sorry haven't had time to build and/or test the binaries yet). But this > > info might be of some benefit to the team sooner than later. > > > > Regards, > > -=e > > -- > > *Ed Espino* > > > > ====================================================================== > > PGP signature (source and convenience binaries): good > > ====================================================================== > > Hashes (source and convenience binaries): good > > ====================================================================== > > Source directory layout: good > > ====================================================================== > > Source LICENSE, DISCLAIMER & NOTICE: good > > ====================================================================== > > Apache Release Audit Tool (RAT): > > > > Observation: > > > > - I happened to open the file "CMakeLists.txt" in the root directory > > and noticed it does not have the standard ASF header. I know there > > were IP issues resolved globally for the project recently. I > > noticed many of them are excluded in the pom.xml file. Regardless > > of the IP issues, shouldn't these files contain the ASF header? > > > > ====================================================================== > > Source miscelaneous: HAWQ_Install.txt > > > > Observation: > > > > - The file references the product name as "MADlib" and not "Apache > > MADlib (Incubating). Is this file still valid? > > > > ====================================================================== > > CONVENIENCE BINARIES > > ---------------------------------------------------------------------- > > > > ---------------------------------------------------------------------- > > Mac Installer DMG file: apache-madlib-1.11-incubating-bin-Darwin.dmg > > ---------------------------------------------------------------------- > > > > Observation: > > > > - The DMG（apache-madlib-1.11-incubating-bin-Darwin.dmg) contains a > > pkg file named "madlib-1.11-Darwin.pkg". Shouldn't it be called > > "apache-madlib-1.11-incubating-Darwin.pkg"? > > > > Similarly, the DMG base folder name is madlib-1.11.Darwin. > > > > Mac Installer Package > > > > o Introduction screen > > > > Observation: > > > > - The introduction screen identifies the product name as > > "MADlib". Shouldn't there be a mention of the project name being > > "Apache MADlib (Incubating)". > > > > o Read Me screen > > > > Observation: > > > > - Similar to initial screen, there is no mention to the Apache > > project except for the link to the project's wiki. > > > > o Remaining screens look reasonable (with exception of no Apache > > references). > > > > o The default application window name is "Install MADlib" > > > > Observation: > > > > - Similar to Introduction sreen, should the name be "Install Apache > > MADlib (Incubating)"? > > > > - Look for other opportunities to reference the product name as > > "Apache MADlib (Incubating)". > > > > ---------------------------------------------------------------------- > > Linux RPM: apache-madlib-1.11-incubating-bin-Linux.rpm > > ---------------------------------------------------------------------- > > > > Observation: > > > > - It appears the SPEC file used (possibly generated) references the > > product name as "madlib". Again, shouldn't there be references to > > the product name as "Apache MADlib" scattered about? > > Unfortunately, I am not sure if this should change or not. It > > might help for someone on the team to review other Apache projects > > convenience binary RPMs to see if something should be > > addressed. The podling's mentor might be able to provide > > additional direction as well. > > > > This can be seen in the following "rpm -qi madlib" output: > > > > [root@e0f4d3349d2d MADlib]# rpm -qi madlib > > Name : madlib > > Version : 1.11 > > Release : 1 > > Architecture: x86_64 > > Install Date: Wed May 3 04:00:10 2017 > > Group : Development/Libraries > > Size : 83575356 > > License : ASL 2.0 > > Signature : (none) > > Source RPM : madlib-1.11-1.src.rpm > > Build Date : Tue May 2 19:03:21 2017 > > Build Host : gpdb1.eng.pivotal.io > > Relocations : /usr/local > > Vendor : MADlib > > Summary : Open-Source Library for Scalable in-Database > > Analytics > > Description : > > MADlib is an open-source library for scalable in-database > > analytics. It > > provides data-parallel implementations of mathematical, > > statistical and > > machine learning methods for structured and unstructured data. > > > > The MADlib mission: to foster widespread development of scalable > > analytic skills, by harnessing efforts from commercial practice, > > academic research, and open-source development. > > > > To more information, please see the MADlib wiki at > > https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/MADLIB > > > > ---------------------------------------------------------------------- > > > > On Wed, May 3, 2017 at 8:13 AM, Frank McQuillan <fmcquil...@pivotal.io> > > wrote: > > > >> Thanks for updating to RC-2, Rashmi. > >> > >> I just tried the dmg on OSX on PG9.6 on my local machine and the soft > link > >> seems to be set correctly now, since it upgraded 1.11 over 1.10 OK. > When > >> I > >> uninstalled MADlib and did a fresh install, that worked fine too for > 1.11. > >> So... > >> > >> +1 > >> > >> Frank > >> > >> On Tue, May 2, 2017 at 5:01 PM, Rashmi Raghu <rra...@pivotal.io> wrote: > >> > >> > Hello MADlib community, > >> > > >> > We have created a MADlib 1.11 RC-2, with the artifacts below (source > and > >> > convenience binaries) up for a vote. > >> > > >> > Note that voting for the RC-1 release has been cancelled due to the > need > >> > for minor corrections based on community feedback. Sorry for the > >> > inconvenience. > >> > > >> > RC-2 replaces RC-1 with the following minor changes: > >> > * Ensure source tarball unpacks into a folder > >> > * Ensure soft links are correct for OS X installations > >> > > >> > This will be the 5th release for Apache MADlib (incubating). > >> > > >> > The main goals of this release are: > >> > * new module (PageRank for graph analytics with grouping support > >> included) > >> > * improvements to existing modules (add grouping support to Single > >> Source > >> > Shortest Path, reduce memory footprint of DT and RF, include NULL > >> features > >> > in training DT, add support for array and svec output for Pivot > module, > >> > utility to unnest 2-D arrays into rows of 1-D arrays) > >> > * platform updates (GPDB 5) > >> > * updates for Apache Top Level Project readiness and build process on > >> > Apache infrastructure > >> > * bug fixes > >> > * doc improvements > >> > > >> > For more information including release notes, please see: > >> > https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/MADLIB/MADlib+1.11 > >> > > >> > *** Please download, review and vote by Fri May 05, 2017 @ 6pm PDT *** > >> > > >> > We're voting upon the source and convenience binaries below: > >> > > >> > Source Repository (tag): rc/1.11-rc2 > >> > https://github.com/apache/incubator-madlib/tree/rc/1.11-rc2 > >> > > >> > Source Files and convenience Binaries: > >> > https://dist.apache.org/repos/dist/dev/incubator/madlib/1. > >> > 11-incubating-rc2/ > >> > > >> > Commit: > >> > https://github.com/apache/incubator-madlib/commit/ > >> > d54be2b8574c5bf0ace96b94ba81f3e5cbf70a35 > >> > > >> > KEYS file containing PGP Keys we use to sign the release: > >> > https://dist.apache.org/repos/dist/dev/incubator/madlib/KEYS > >> > > >> > To help in tallying the vote, PMC members please be sure to indicate > >> > "(binding)" with the vote. > >> > > >> > [ ] +1 approve > >> > [ ] +0 no opinion > >> > [ ] -1 disapprove (and reason why) > >> > > >> > > >> > Regards, > >> > Rashmi Raghu > >> > > >> > -- > >> > Rashmi Raghu, Ph.D. > >> > Pivotal Data Science > >> > > >> > > > > > > > > > -- > *Ed Espino* >
