After the allotted 72 hours, the results stand as:
Full proposal: 9 (7 PMC, 2 committers): Brett, Arnaud, Emmanuel,
Trygve, Dennis, Fabrizio, Lukas, Rahul, Milos
Partial proposal: 6 (6 PMC): Joakim, John T, Kenney, Jesse, John C,
Jason
Abstained: 3 (3 PMC): Mike, Vincent S, Stephane
Against: None.
Not yet voted: 3 PMC: Vincent M, Carlos, James
This is in favour of the full proposal. I will follow up with the PMC
about how we execute this.
- Brett
On 09/01/2007, at 10:50 AM, Brett Porter wrote:
> Hi,
>
> Since there was no objection to calling a vote, as discussed in the
> proposal, I'd like to call a vote on this.
>
> To see the proposal and discussion: http://mail-archives.apache.org/
> mod_mbox/maven-dev/200612.mbox/%3c67FC84B5-4510-469B-AEC1-
> [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
> Vote to operate as
> - requiring 2/3rds of the PMC to vote (13), with a majority within
> those votes for it to pass (ie, add them all and if the result is >
> 0). Other votes would be welcome with reasons as advisory, but not
> binding.
> - Votes can be changed at any time before result is posted.
> - Vote is open for at least 72 hours, completing once enough have
> voted after that.
> - There are two different +1 options. If there is a majority for
> "collapse all groups" against both other options, then it will
> pass. If it fails, then all votes will be transferred to the
> "retain subproject access restrictions" and recounted.
>
> The proposal is to collapse all access groups into a single ACL for
> Maven, with the following list of 37 committers: Fabrice
> Bellingard, David Blevins, John Casey, Maria Ching, Joakim Erdfelt,
> Dan Fabulich (pending), Brian Fox, Fabrizio Giustina, Arnaud
> Heritier, Jeff Jensen, Shinobu Kawai, Milos Kleint, Trygve
> Laugstol, Felipe Leme, Dennis Lundberg, Vincent Massol, Jesse
> McConnell, Stephane Nicoll, Mike Perham, Brett Porter, Edwin
> Punzalan, Daniel Rall, Allan Ramirez, Carlos Sanchez, Vincent
> Siveton, Wendy Smoak, Torbjorn Smorgrav, James Strachan, Chris
> Stevenson, Rahul Thakur, Lukas Theussl, John Tolentino, Dan Tran,
> Emmanuel Venisse, Kenney Westerhof, Andrew Williams, Henri Yandell,
> and Jason van Zyl.
>
> The alternate proposal is to retain subproject access restrictions,
> so the groups will be (PMC members removed, as they retain access
> to all areas):
> maven=wsmoak,felipeal,jjensen,shinobu,dlr,mkleint,handyande,epunzalan,
> aramirez,dantran,chrisjs,brianf,bellingard,oching (/maven-1,/
> components,/plugins,/archetype,/core-integration-testing,/jxr,/
> release,/skins,/resources,/release-testing)
> doxia=dblevins
> archiva=bayard,epunzalan,oching
> continuum=dblevins,rinku
> scm=dantran,smorgrav
> wagon=<empty at this time>
> surefire=<empty at this time>
>
> All of the above groups will have access to: /pom, /project, /
> site, /shared in this proposal, so it is essentially to collapse
> the @maven group, making the permission groups match the existence
> of a corresponding dev lists.
>
> [ ] +1 for the full proposal - collapse all groups (implies a vote
> for the next option if vote doesn't pass)
> [ ] +1 for the partial proposal - retain subproject access
> restrictions
> [ ] 0 abstain from vote
> [ ] -1 do not alter the current permissions
>
> Cheers,
> Brett
>
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
> For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
