James, looks great overall.  A few nits, and two fixes:

CD10 – “under under” – de-dup.

CD30 – “is can be” - delete “is”

CD50 – “First, is” –  “is” should be “it is”

LC50 – This doesn’t exactly answer the question.  It is a question about 
copyright, not licensing.  (eg, see the NOTICE files in github)


A better response would be:
“We document copyrights of all included source code in compliance with Apache 
licensing standards.”  

RE40 – It is not correct that we don’t distribute convenience binaries.  We are 
in the process of adding RPMs to the sub-components that don’t already have 
them.  A better response would be:
“Although we do provide convenience binaries for some parts of the project 
releases, (a) each release can be fully built from sources and used without 
reference to the convenience binaries, and (b) the convenience binaries are 
documented to not be warranted or guaranteed in any way.”
It might be advisable to check the documentation to confirm (b).

QU30 – “identified addressed” – insert “and”
“the Metron's” – delete “the”

QU50 – “Metorn” – should be “Metron”


Thanks,
--Matt


On 1/20/17, 9:38 AM, "James Sirota" <[email protected]> wrote:

    Guys,
    
    I went through the Apache Project Maturity document and documented how 
Metron meets each of these criteria.  My draft is available here.  What do you 
guys think?  Anything you would like to add/revise about this?
    
    https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=66852119
    
    
    ------------------- 
    Thank you,
    
    James Sirota
    PPMC- Apache Metron (Incubating)
    jsirota AT apache DOT org
    
    


Reply via email to