Hello Andreas, I don't think this has been discussed for MINA3 yet but it should be sometime in the future. For Mina 2.0 I guess your best option would be to write wrapper classes - and you can provide patches for these, of course.
2010/4/7 Andreas Sahlbach <andr...@sahlbach.com>: > Well, that depends on my coding style, I guess. :-) > > But the reason for my question is, that there is no simple right or > wrong answer. It's possible to extend the class to provide support for > spring or to write a wrapper class to decouple the spring support from > the core classes. So I just want to know the overall strategy > regarding spring. And then it's no problem to provide patches. > > On Wed, Apr 7, 2010 at 10:50 AM, Norman Maurer > <norman.mau...@googlemail.com> wrote: >> Hi Andreas, >> >> I'm not a mina dev but I'm sure they love patches which make the code >> more usable ;) >> >> Bye, >> Norman >> >> >> 2010/4/7 Andreas Sahlbach <andreas.sahlb...@gmail.com>: >>> Hi guys! >>> >>> I am a new user of your framework (great stuff!) and I have a short >>> question regarding the spring framework. I am using mina 2.x and >>> noticed that you removed a lot of special spring stuff in favor of a >>> more general support for injection frameworks. >>> >>> Still there are a number of classes in the framework that are pretty >>> spring-unfriendly and cannot be used from within spring without user >>> modifications (like extending them or wrapping them). So my question >>> is: >>> >>> What is your midterm plans regarding spring integration? >>> Are you going to modify your classes so that they can be easily from >>> within spring? >>> If so, should I file a bug (with patch) for classes that don't work >>> currently? >>> Or are you going to implement more helper classes in the xbean package? >>> >>> I am referring for example to DemuxingProtocolCodecFactory or >>> DemuxingIoHandler, which can't be initialized easily from within >>> spring. >>> >>> Best regards, >>> >>> Andreas >>> >>> -- >>> Andreas Sahlbach >>> >> > > > > -- > Andreas Sahlbach >
