I'm sorry I don't know what modelidation means.

The elevation field doesn't allow a many relationship, it simply creates the possibility of having one. A design flaw is not in itself a bug unless it breaks some existing functionality which isn't the case here. Additionally the change is broken as I mentioned on the other commit and should never have been backported as is anyway. I think you'll find that creating a many-to-many relationship is what is needed and that will require some design effort which will ultimately end up looking more like a new feature than any sort of bug fix.

Regards
Scott

On 6/11/2009, at 11:52 AM, Jacques Le Roux wrote:

Scott,

Actually it's a bug in the modelidation as we forgot the elevation field which allows a many relationship betwen PostalAddress and GeoPoint (flats in building). Same for Facility as Adrian suggested.
I may revert but we will then lose this ability in R9.04

Jacques

From: "Scott Gray" <scott.g...@hotwaxmedia.com>
Hi Jacques,

I don't agree with back porting the data model change, I think
changing the relationship title is fine but changing the relationship
from one to many (which I don't think is right anyway) shouldn't be
backported unless it is addressing a bug.

Regards
Scott

HotWax Media
http://www.hotwaxmedia.com

On 6/11/2009, at 7:29 AM, jler...@apache.org wrote:

Author: jleroux
Date: Thu Nov  5 18:29:15 2009
New Revision: 833114

URL: http://svn.apache.org/viewvc?rev=833114&view=rev
Log:
"Applied fix from trunk for revision: 833113"
------------------------------------------------------------------------
r833113 | jleroux | 2009-11-05 19:26:27 +0100 (jeu. 05 nov. 2009) | 3 lignes

Change "Geo Point" title to "Point"
Change the type of relation for Postal Address to GeoPoint from one to many. Because of the elevation field in GeoPoint. A bit scifi for now, but maybe useful one day...) Thanks to a discussion with Erwan "Relation title not needed on Facility entity" at https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/ OFBIZ-3153 - OFBIZ-3153
------------------------------------------------------------------------


Modified:
  ofbiz/branches/release09.04/   (props changed)
ofbiz/branches/release09.04/applications/party/entitydef/ entitymodel.xml ofbiz/branches/release09.04/applications/product/entitydef/ entitymodel.xml

Propchange: ofbiz/branches/release09.04/
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--- svn:mergeinfo (original)
+++ svn:mergeinfo Thu Nov  5 18:29:15 2009
@@ -1 +1 @@
-/ofbiz/trunk: 765933,766011,766015,766293,766307,766316,766325,766462,766522,766800,767060,767072,767093,767098-767099,767102,767123,767125,767127,767279,767287,767671,767688,767694,767822,767845,768358,768490,768550,768675,768686,768705,768811,768815,768960,769030,769500,770272,770308,770997,771073,772401,772464-772465,773076,773557,773628,773659,773697,774014,774632,774661,774995,775292,775667,776227,776594,776620,776922,777004,777020,777768,777792,777893,777947,778078,778094,778107,778273,778278,778280,778364,778374,778402,778576,778594,778628,779020,779477,779496,779639,779834,779856,779866,779873,780111,780138,780180,780199,780203,780906,780945,781201,781534,781549,781669,781680,781694,782663,783257,783266,783833,783913,783917,785123,785764,785967,786778,787126,787435-787436,787442,787520,788965,788983,788987,789329,789337,789506,789548,796769,799185,800461,800846,801023,802346,804364,805307,806127,806377,808786-808787,808792,809141,810370,810438,810465,810807,810809,810
814,810832,810836,810878,810917,811020,811280,811297,811419,811528,811708,811714,811716,811793,811838,811860,811865,811870,812159,812182,812192,812456,812540,813126,813131,813283,813672,813702,814168,814205,814251,814349,814531,814576,814681,814731,815158,815165,815350,815687,815977,816255,816863,818030,818049,818150,818494,818500,818716,818976,819275-819276,819282,819337,821263,821270,822659,823877-823878,823883,823888,823892,824511,825181-825182,826253,827730,828971,829085,829376,829412,829416,829527,830091,830112,830366,830528,830677,830874,830880,831238,831801,832361,832698,832776,832908
+/ofbiz/trunk: 765933,766011,766015,766293,766307,766316,766325,766462,766522,766800,767060,767072,767093,767098-767099,767102,767123,767125,767127,767279,767287,767671,767688,767694,767822,767845,768358,768490,768550,768675,768686,768705,768811,768815,768960,769030,769500,770272,770308,770997,771073,772401,772464-772465,773076,773557,773628,773659,773697,774014,774632,774661,774995,775292,775667,776227,776594,776620,776922,777004,777020,777768,777792,777893,777947,778078,778094,778107,778273,778278,778280,778364,778374,778402,778576,778594,778628,779020,779477,779496,779639,779834,779856,779866,779873,780111,780138,780180,780199,780203,780906,780945,781201,781534,781549,781669,781680,781694,782663,783257,783266,783833,783913,783917,785123,785764,785967,786778,787126,787435-787436,787442,787520,788965,788983,788987,789329,789337,789506,789548,796769,799185,800461,800846,801023,802346,804364,805307,806127,806377,808786-808787,808792,809141,810370,810438,810465,810807,810809,810
814,810832,810836,810878,810917,811020,811280,811297,811419,811528,811708,811714,811716,811793,811838,811860,811865,811870,812159,812182,812192,812456,812540,813126,813131,813283,813672,813702,814168,814205,814251,814349,814531,814576,814681,814731,815158,815165,815350,815687,815977,816255,816863,818030,818049,818150,818494,818500,818716,818976,819275-819276,819282,819337,821263,821270,822659,823877-823878,823883,823888,823892,824511,825181-825182,826253,827730,828971,829085,829376,829412,829416,829527,830091,830112,830366,830528,830677,830874,830880,831238,831801,832361,832698,832776,832908,833113

Modified: ofbiz/branches/release09.04/applications/party/entitydef/ entitymodel.xml
URL: 
http://svn.apache.org/viewvc/ofbiz/branches/release09.04/applications/party/entitydef/entitymodel.xml?rev=833114&r1=833113&r2=833114&view=diff
= = = = = = = = = ===================================================================== --- ofbiz/branches/release09.04/applications/party/entitydef/ entitymodel.xml (original) +++ ofbiz/branches/release09.04/applications/party/entitydef/ entitymodel.xml Thu Nov 5 18:29:15 2009
@@ -1167,7 +1167,7 @@
<relation type="one" fk-name="POST_ADDR_PCGEO" title="PostalCode" rel-entity-name="Geo">
       <key-map field-name="postalCodeGeoId" rel-field-name="geoId"/>
     </relation>
- <relation type="one" fk-name="POST_ADDR_GEOPT" title="Geo Point" rel-entity-name="GeoPoint"> + <relation type="many" fk-name="POST_ADDR_GEOPT" title="Point" rel-entity-name="GeoPoint"> <!-- because of the elevation field in GeoPoint we may face a many relationship in future -->
       <key-map field-name="geoPointId"/>
     </relation>
     <index name="ADDRESS1_IDX">

Modified: ofbiz/branches/release09.04/applications/product/ entitydef/ entitymodel.xml
URL: 
http://svn.apache.org/viewvc/ofbiz/branches/release09.04/applications/product/entitydef/entitymodel.xml?rev=833114&r1=833113&r2=833114&view=diff
= = = = = = = = = ===================================================================== --- ofbiz/branches/release09.04/applications/product/entitydef/ entitymodel.xml (original) +++ ofbiz/branches/release09.04/applications/product/entitydef/ entitymodel.xml Thu Nov 5 18:29:15 2009
@@ -984,7 +984,7 @@
       <relation type="many" rel-entity-name="FacilityTypeAttr">
           <key-map field-name="facilityTypeId"/>
       </relation>
- <relation type="one" fk-name="FACILITY_GEOPT" title="Geo Point" rel-entity-name="GeoPoint"> + <relation type="one" fk-name="FACILITY_GEOPT" title="Point" rel-entity-name="GeoPoint">
         <key-map field-name="geoPointId"/>
       </relation>
   </entity>






Attachment: smime.p7s
Description: S/MIME cryptographic signature

Reply via email to