On Nov 14, 2014, at 2:50 PM, Daniele Venturino <daniele.ventur...@m3s.it> wrote:
> You're right, it's used only in rstp_port_set_admin_point_to_point_mac__()
> where it's set, if the old value change. The action on
> oper_point_to_point_mac it's inside that function.
>
Thanks! For now this can be as it is. Maybe you look into making this clearer
at the same time when you implement the AUTO mode?
Jarno
> Maybe it would be clearer to have a function
> "update_oper_point_to_point_mac__()" that updates oper_point_to_point_mac
> accordingly to admin_point_to_point_mac, instead of calling
> rstp_port_set_oper_point_to_point_mac__() in
> rstp_port_set_admin_point_to_point_mac__() ? Something like:
>
> diff --git a/lib/rstp.c b/lib/rstp.c
> index 46414bf..03d5b06 100644
> --- a/lib/rstp.c
> +++ b/lib/rstp.c
> @@ -1212,29 +1212,22 @@ static void
> rstp_port_set_admin_point_to_point_mac__(struct rstp_port *port,
> VLOG_DBG("%s, port %u: set RSTP port admin-point-to-point-mac to %d",
> port->rstp->name, port->port_number, admin_p2p_mac_state);
> - if (port->admin_point_to_point_mac != admin_p2p_mac_state) {
> - if (admin_p2p_mac_state == RSTP_ADMIN_P2P_MAC_FORCE_TRUE) {
> - port->admin_point_to_point_mac = admin_p2p_mac_state;
> - rstp_port_set_oper_point_to_point_mac__(port,
> - RSTP_OPER_P2P_MAC_STATE_ENABLED);
> - } else if (admin_p2p_mac_state == RSTP_ADMIN_P2P_MAC_FORCE_FALSE) {
> - port->admin_point_to_point_mac = admin_p2p_mac_state;
> - rstp_port_set_oper_point_to_point_mac__(port,
> - RSTP_OPER_P2P_MAC_STATE_DISABLED);
> - } else if (admin_p2p_mac_state == RSTP_ADMIN_P2P_MAC_AUTO) {
> - /* If adminPointToPointMAC is set to Auto, then the value of
> - * operPointToPointMAC is determined in accordance with the
> - * specific procedures defined for the MAC entity concerned, as
> - * defined in 6.5. If these procedures determine that the MAC
> - * entity is connected to a point-to-point LAN, then
> - * operPointToPointMAC is set TRUE; otherwise it is set FALSE.
> - * In the absence of a specific definition of how to determine
> - * whether the MAC is connected to a point-to-point LAN or not,
> - * the value of operPointToPointMAC shall be FALSE. */
> - port->admin_point_to_point_mac = admin_p2p_mac_state;
> - rstp_port_set_oper_point_to_point_mac__(port,
> - RSTP_OPER_P2P_MAC_STATE_DISABLED);
> - }
> + /* If adminPointToPointMAC is set to Auto, then the value of
> + * operPointToPointMAC is determined in accordance with the
> + * specific procedures defined for the MAC entity concerned, as
> + * defined in 6.5. If these procedures determine that the MAC
> + * entity is connected to a point-to-point LAN, then
> + * operPointToPointMAC is set TRUE; otherwise it is set FALSE.
> + * In the absence of a specific definition of how to determine
> + * whether the MAC is connected to a point-to-point LAN or not,
> + * the value of operPointToPointMAC shall be FALSE. */
> +
> + if (port->admin_point_to_point_mac != admin_p2p_mac_state
> + && (admin_p2p_mac_state == RSTP_ADMIN_P2P_MAC_FORCE_TRUE
> + || admin_p2p_mac_state == RSTP_ADMIN_P2P_MAC_FORCE_FALSE
> + || admin_p2p_mac_state == RSTP_ADMIN_P2P_MAC_AUTO)) {
> + port->admin_point_to_point_mac = admin_p2p_mac_state;
> + update_oper_point_to_point_mac__(port)
> }
> }
>
> where update_oper_point_to_point_mac__() sets oper_point_to_point_mac to
> RSTP_OPER_P2P_MAC_STATE_ENABLED if admin_point_to_point_mac is
> RSTP_ADMIN_P2P_MAC_FORCE_TRUE, it sets oper_point_to_point_mac to
> RSTP_OPER_P2P_MAC_STATE_DISABLED if admin_point_to_point_mac is
> RSTP_ADMIN_P2P_MAC_FORCE_FALSE and it sets oper_point_to_point_mac to
> RSTP_OPER_P2P_MAC_STATE_DISABLED if admin_point_to_point_mac is
> RSTP_ADMIN_P2P_MAC_AUTO (for now, later on it will be the correct auto
> procedure).
>
> Regards,
> Daniele
>
> 2014-11-14 23:30 GMT+01:00 Jarno Rajahalme <jrajaha...@nicira.com>:
>
> On Nov 14, 2014, at 11:09 AM, Daniele Venturino <daniele.ventur...@m3s.it>
> wrote:
>
>>
>>
>> 2014-11-14 19:46 GMT+01:00 Jarno Rajahalme <jrajaha...@nicira.com>:
>>
>> On Nov 14, 2014, at 9:36 AM, Daniele Venturino <daniele.ventur...@m3s.it>
>> wrote:
>>
>>> A possible commit message:
>>> "Admin-port-state is the Administrative Bridge Port state variable defined
>>> in the 802.1D-2004 standard.
>>> It can be set to include or exclude a port from the active topology by
>>> management (see 7.4).
>>>
>>
>> IMO we should use the user-visible (configuration database) names in the
>> commit messages ('rstp-admin-p2p-mac' and 'rstp-admin-port-state’).
>>
>> I think you're right about this. Let's use the visible names.
>>
>>
>>> operPointToPointMAC and adminPointToPointMAC are a pair of parameters that
>>> permit inspection of, and control over, the administrative and operational
>>> state of the point-to-point status of the MAC entity by the MAC Relay
>>> Entity.
>>> adminPointToPointMAC can be set by management and its value is reflected on
>>> operPointToPointMAC."
>>>
>>
>> I still do not see ‘admin_point_to_point_mac’ being used for anything, and I
>> do not see operPointToPointMAC anywhere in this patch. Are these added in
>> the following patches? If so, we should mention that in the commit message.
>>
>> admin_point_to_point_mac is not used in other places, but it's a per-bridge
>> variable and should be present.
>> operPointToPointMAC is named oper_point_to_point_mac in the code.
>> They're already present in the rstp_port struct in lib/rstp-common.h.
>> There's a little of misalignment between the naming in the code and the
>> naming in the standard I guess.
>>
>
> I forgot about this and pushed this patch into master already.
>
> However, could you show me where in the code the variable
> ‘admin_point_to_point_mac’ is read and then used for anything. I only see it
> being set (and the old value being compared against while doing so). In
> short, it seems to me like a write-only variable. I guess it should have some
> effect on ‘opera_point_to_point_mac’?
>
> Jarno
>
>>
>>> The AUTO mode should work as reported in the 802.1D-2004 standard (6.4.3),
>>> by setting operPointToPointMAC to false if the described procedure is not
>>> available.
>>> For now, I would only add this change:
>>>
>>> diff --git a/lib/rstp.c b/lib/rstp.c
>>> index 144f2ba..2a2a60c 100644
>>> --- a/lib/rstp.c
>>> +++ b/lib/rstp.c
>>> @@ -1217,8 +1217,18 @@ static void
>>> rstp_port_set_admin_point_to_point_mac__(struct rstp_port *port,
>>> rstp_port_set_oper_point_to_point_mac__(port,
>>> RSTP_OPER_P2P_MAC_STATE_DISABLED);
>>> } else if (admin_p2p_mac_state == RSTP_ADMIN_P2P_MAC_AUTO) {
>>> + /* If adminPointToPointMAC is set to Auto, then the value of
>>> + * operPointToPointMAC is determined in accordance with the
>>> + * specific procedures defined for the MAC entity concerned, as
>>> + * defined in 6.5. If these procedures determine that the MAC
>>> + * entity is connected to a point-to-point LAN, then
>>> + * operPointToPointMAC is set TRUE; otherwise it is set FALSE.
>>> + * In the absence of a specific definition of how to determine
>>> + * whether the MAC is connected to a point-to-point LAN or not,
>>> + * the value of operPointToPointMAC shall be FALSE. */
>>> port->admin_point_to_point_mac = admin_p2p_mac_state;
>>> - /* FIXME add auto procedure*/
>>> + rstp_port_set_oper_point_to_point_mac__(port,
>>> + RSTP_OPER_P2P_MAC_STATE_DISABLED);
>>> }
>>> }
>>> }
>>>
>>> but we are going to implement this mechanism soon.
>>
>> OK, I added the above.
>>
>> Jarno
>>
>>>
>>> Here an extract from the 802.1D-2004 standard for a better explanation:
>>>
>>> operPointToPointMAC: This parameter can take two values, as follows:
>>> a) True. The MAC is connected to a point-to-point LAN; i.e., there is at
>>> most one other system attached to the LAN.
>>> b) False. The MAC is connected to a non-point-to-point LAN; i.e., there can
>>> be more than one other system attached to the LAN.
>>>
>>> adminPointToPointMAC: This parameter can take three values, as follows:
>>> a) ForceTrue. The administrator requires the MAC to be treated as if it is
>>> connected to a point-to-point LAN, regardless of any indications to the
>>> contrary that are generated by the MAC entity.
>>> b) ForceFalse. The administrator requires the MAC to be treated as
>>> connected to a non-point-to-point LAN, regardless of any indications to the
>>> contrary that are generated by the MAC entity.
>>> c) Auto. The administrator requires the point-to-point status of the MAC to
>>> be determined in accordance with the specific MAC procedures defined in 6.5.
>>> If adminPointToPointMAC is set to ForceTrue, then operPointToPointMAC shall
>>> be set True. If adminPointToPointMAC is set to ForceFalse, then
>>> operPointToPointMAC shall be set False.
>>> If adminPointToPointMAC is set to Auto, then the value of
>>> operPointToPointMAC is determined in accordance with the specific
>>> procedures defined for the MAC entity concerned, as defined in 6.5. If
>>> these procedures determine that the MAC entity is connected to a
>>> point-to-point LAN, then
>>> operPointToPointMAC is set TRUE; otherwise it is set FALSE. In the absence
>>> of a specific definition of how to determine whether the MAC is connected
>>> to a point-to-point LAN or not, the value of
>>> operPointToPointMAC shall be FALSE.
>>>
>>> Regards,
>>> Daniele
>>>
>>> 2014-11-14 0:07 GMT+01:00 Jarno Rajahalme <jrajaha...@nicira.com>:
>>> This patch needs a proper commit message. The user visible changes are in
>>> the corresponding configuration settings. Maybe briefly introduce them in
>>> the commit message?
>>>
>>> More comments inline below.
>>>
>>> I have a working copy with the white-space changes, so if you provide the
>>> commit message and the answer to the AUTO question below, I can accept and
>>> push this patch.
>>>
>>> Thanks!
>>>
>>> Jarno
>>>
>>> On Nov 6, 2014, at 7:31 AM, Daniele Venturino <daniele.ventur...@m3s.it>
>>> wrote:
>>>
>>> > Signed-off-by: Daniele Venturino <daniele.ventur...@m3s.it>
>>> > ---
>>> > lib/rstp-common.h | 6 ------
>>> > lib/rstp.c | 31 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++-
>>> > lib/rstp.h | 9 ++++++++-
>>> > ofproto/ofproto-dpif.c | 4 +++-
>>> > ofproto/ofproto.h | 2 ++
>>> > utilities/ovs-vsctl.8.in | 9 +++++++++
>>> > vswitchd/bridge.c | 10 ++++++++++
>>> > 7 files changed, 62 insertions(+), 9 deletions(-)
>>> >
>>> > diff --git a/lib/rstp-common.h b/lib/rstp-common.h
>>> > index 587f88c..cd43079 100644
>>> > --- a/lib/rstp-common.h
>>> > +++ b/lib/rstp-common.h
>>> > @@ -240,12 +240,6 @@ struct rstp_bpdu {
>>> > uint8_t padding[7];
>>> > });
>>> >
>>> > -enum rstp_admin_point_to_point_mac_state {
>>> > - RSTP_ADMIN_P2P_MAC_FORCE_TRUE,
>>> > - RSTP_ADMIN_P2P_MAC_FORCE_FALSE,
>>> > - RSTP_ADMIN_P2P_MAC_FORCE_AUTO
>>> > -};
>>> > -
>>> > enum rstp_info_is {
>>> > INFO_IS_DISABLED,
>>> > INFO_IS_RECEIVED,
>>> > diff --git a/lib/rstp.c b/lib/rstp.c
>>> > index 0f96749..e3007e2 100644
>>> > --- a/lib/rstp.c
>>> > +++ b/lib/rstp.c
>>> > @@ -110,6 +110,9 @@ static void rstp_port_set_admin_edge__(struct
>>> > rstp_port *, bool admin_edge)
>>> > OVS_REQUIRES(rstp_mutex);
>>> > static void rstp_port_set_auto_edge__(struct rstp_port *, bool auto_edge)
>>> > OVS_REQUIRES(rstp_mutex);
>>> > +static void rstp_port_set_admin_point_to_point_mac__(struct rstp_port *,
>>> > + enum rstp_admin_point_to_point_mac_state admin_p2p_mac_state)
>>> > + OVS_REQUIRES(rstp_mutex);
>>> > static void rstp_port_set_mcheck__(struct rstp_port *, bool mcheck)
>>> > OVS_REQUIRES(rstp_mutex);
>>> > static void reinitialize_port__(struct rstp_port *p)
>>> > @@ -922,6 +925,8 @@ rstp_port_set_administrative_bridge_port__(struct
>>> > rstp_port *p,
>>> > uint8_t admin_port_state)
>>> > OVS_REQUIRES(rstp_mutex)
>>> > {
>>> > + VLOG_DBG("%s, port %u: set RSTP port admin-port-state to %d",
>>> > + p->rstp->name, p->port_number, admin_port_state);
>>>
>>> Add an empty line here.
>>>
>>> > if (admin_port_state == RSTP_ADMIN_BRIDGE_PORT_STATE_DISABLED
>>> > || admin_port_state == RSTP_ADMIN_BRIDGE_PORT_STATE_ENABLED) {
>>> >
>>> > @@ -1120,6 +1125,27 @@ rstp_port_set_auto_edge__(struct rstp_port *port,
>>> > bool auto_edge)
>>> > }
>>> > }
>>> >
>>> > +/* Sets the port admin_point_to_point_mac parameter. */
>>> > +static void rstp_port_set_admin_point_to_point_mac__(struct rstp_port
>>> > *port,
>>> > + enum rstp_admin_point_to_point_mac_state admin_p2p_mac_state)
>>> > + OVS_REQUIRES(rstp_mutex)
>>> > +{
>>> > + VLOG_DBG("%s, port %u: set RSTP port admin-point-to-point-mac to %d",
>>> > + port->rstp->name, port->port_number, admin_p2p_mac_state);
>>>
>>> Add an empty line here.
>>>
>>> > + if (admin_p2p_mac_state == RSTP_ADMIN_P2P_MAC_FORCE_TRUE) {
>>> > + port->admin_point_to_point_mac = admin_p2p_mac_state;
>>>
>>> Remove extra space after ‘=‘.
>>>
>>> > + rstp_port_set_oper_point_to_point_mac__(port,
>>> > + RSTP_OPER_P2P_MAC_STATE_ENABLED);
>>> > + } else if (admin_p2p_mac_state == RSTP_ADMIN_P2P_MAC_FORCE_FALSE) {
>>> > + port->admin_point_to_point_mac = admin_p2p_mac_state;
>>>
>>> Remove extra space after ‘=‘.
>>>
>>> > + rstp_port_set_oper_point_to_point_mac__(port,
>>> > + RSTP_OPER_P2P_MAC_STATE_DISABLED);
>>> > + } else if (admin_p2p_mac_state == RSTP_ADMIN_P2P_MAC_AUTO) {
>>> > + port->admin_point_to_point_mac = admin_p2p_mac_state;
>>> > + /* FIXME fix auto behaviour */
>>>
>>> Elaborate on this. How the AUTO mode should work? Why not implement it now?
>>>
>>> > + }
>>> > +}
>>> > +
>>> > /* Sets the port mcheck parameter.
>>> > * [17.19.13] May be set by management to force the Port Protocol
>>> > Migration
>>> > * state machine to transmit RST BPDUs for a MigrateTime (17.13.9)
>>> > period, to
>>> > @@ -1289,7 +1315,8 @@ rstp_port_get_status(const struct rstp_port *p,
>>> > uint16_t *id,
>>> > void
>>> > rstp_port_set(struct rstp_port *port, uint16_t port_num, int priority,
>>> > uint32_t path_cost, bool is_admin_edge, bool is_auto_edge,
>>> > - bool do_mcheck, void *aux)
>>> > + enum rstp_admin_point_to_point_mac_state
>>> > admin_p2p_mac_state,
>>> > + bool admin_port_state, bool do_mcheck, void *aux)
>>> > OVS_EXCLUDED(rstp_mutex)
>>> > {
>>> > ovs_mutex_lock(&rstp_mutex);
>>> > @@ -1299,6 +1326,8 @@ rstp_port_set(struct rstp_port *port, uint16_t
>>> > port_num, int priority,
>>> > rstp_port_set_path_cost__(port, path_cost);
>>> > rstp_port_set_admin_edge__(port, is_admin_edge);
>>> > rstp_port_set_auto_edge__(port, is_auto_edge);
>>> > + rstp_port_set_admin_point_to_point_mac__(port, admin_p2p_mac_state);
>>> > + rstp_port_set_administrative_bridge_port__(port, admin_port_state);
>>> > rstp_port_set_mcheck__(port, do_mcheck);
>>> > ovs_mutex_unlock(&rstp_mutex);
>>> > }
>>> > diff --git a/lib/rstp.h b/lib/rstp.h
>>> > index ccf8292..458aecf 100644
>>> > --- a/lib/rstp.h
>>> > +++ b/lib/rstp.h
>>> > @@ -120,6 +120,12 @@ enum rstp_port_role {
>>> > ROLE_DISABLED
>>> > };
>>> >
>>> > +enum rstp_admin_point_to_point_mac_state {
>>> > + RSTP_ADMIN_P2P_MAC_FORCE_FALSE,
>>> > + RSTP_ADMIN_P2P_MAC_FORCE_TRUE,
>>> > + RSTP_ADMIN_P2P_MAC_AUTO
>>> > +};
>>> > +
>>> > struct rstp;
>>> > struct rstp_port;
>>> > struct ofproto_rstp_settings;
>>> > @@ -211,7 +217,8 @@ uint32_t rstp_convert_speed_to_cost(unsigned int
>>> > speed);
>>> >
>>> > void rstp_port_set(struct rstp_port *, uint16_t port_num, int priority,
>>> > uint32_t path_cost, bool is_admin_edge, bool
>>> > is_auto_edge,
>>> > - bool do_mcheck, void *aux)
>>> > + enum rstp_admin_point_to_point_mac_state
>>> > admin_p2p_mac_state,
>>> > + bool admin_port_state, bool do_mcheck, void *aux)
>>> > OVS_EXCLUDED(rstp_mutex);
>>> >
>>> > enum rstp_state rstp_port_get_state(const struct rstp_port *)
>>> > diff --git a/ofproto/ofproto-dpif.c b/ofproto/ofproto-dpif.c
>>> > index 2302073..95298f2 100644
>>> > --- a/ofproto/ofproto-dpif.c
>>> > +++ b/ofproto/ofproto-dpif.c
>>> > @@ -2402,7 +2402,9 @@ set_rstp_port(struct ofport *ofport_,
>>> > }
>>> >
>>> > rstp_port_set(rp, s->port_num, s->priority, s->path_cost,
>>> > - s->admin_edge_port, s->auto_edge, s->mcheck, ofport);
>>> > + s->admin_edge_port, s->auto_edge,
>>> > + s->admin_p2p_mac_state, s->admin_port_state, s->mcheck,
>>> > + ofport);
>>> > update_rstp_port_state(ofport);
>>> > /* Synchronize operational status. */
>>> > rstp_port_set_mac_operational(rp, ofport->may_enable);
>>> > diff --git a/ofproto/ofproto.h b/ofproto/ofproto.h
>>> > index 989747d..bb28376 100644
>>> > --- a/ofproto/ofproto.h
>>> > +++ b/ofproto/ofproto.h
>>> > @@ -126,6 +126,8 @@ struct ofproto_port_rstp_settings {
>>> > bool admin_edge_port;
>>> > bool auto_edge;
>>> > bool mcheck;
>>> > + uint8_t admin_p2p_mac_state;
>>> > + bool admin_port_state;
>>> > };
>>> >
>>> > struct ofproto_stp_settings {
>>> > diff --git a/utilities/ovs-vsctl.8.in b/utilities/ovs-vsctl.8.in
>>> > index 8cf13ae..2902a27 100644
>>> > --- a/utilities/ovs-vsctl.8.in
>>> > +++ b/utilities/ovs-vsctl.8.in
>>> > @@ -1073,6 +1073,15 @@ Set the auto edge value of port \fBeth0\fR:
>>> > .IP
>>> > .B "ovs\-vsctl set Port eth0 other_config:rstp-port-auto-edge=true"
>>> > .PP
>>> > +Set the admin point to point mac value of port \fBeth0\fR.
>>>
>>> Remove extra space after ‘value‘.
>>>
>>> > +Acceptable values are 0 (force false), 1 (force true) or 2 (auto).
>>> > +.IP
>>> > +.B "ovs\-vsctl set Port eth0 other_config:rstp-admin-p2p-mac=1"
>>> > +.PP
>>> > +Set the admin port state value of port \fBeth0\fR.
>>> > +.IP
>>> > +.B "ovs\-vsctl set Port eth0 other_config:rstp-admin-port-state=true"
>>> > +.PP
>>> > Set the mcheck value of port \fBeth0\fR:
>>> > .IP
>>> > .B "ovs\-vsctl set Port eth0 other_config:rstp-port-mcheck=true"
>>> > diff --git a/vswitchd/bridge.c b/vswitchd/bridge.c
>>> > index 20cfcba..a5fb361 100644
>>> > --- a/vswitchd/bridge.c
>>> > +++ b/vswitchd/bridge.c
>>> > @@ -1398,6 +1398,16 @@ port_configure_rstp(const struct ofproto *ofproto,
>>> > struct port *port,
>>> > port_s->priority = RSTP_DEFAULT_PORT_PRIORITY;
>>> > }
>>> >
>>> > + config_str = smap_get(&port->cfg->other_config,
>>> > "rstp-admin-p2p-mac");
>>> > + if (config_str) {
>>> > + port_s->admin_p2p_mac_state = strtoul(config_str, NULL, 0);
>>> > + } else {
>>> > + port_s->admin_p2p_mac_state = RSTP_ADMIN_P2P_MAC_FORCE_TRUE;
>>>
>>> Remove extra space after ‘=‘.
>>>
>>> > + }
>>> > +
>>> > + port_s->admin_port_state = smap_get_bool(&port->cfg->other_config,
>>> > + "rstp-admin-port-state",
>>> > true);
>>> > +
>>> > port_s->admin_edge_port = smap_get_bool(&port->cfg->other_config,
>>> > "rstp-port-admin-edge",
>>> > false);
>>> > port_s->auto_edge = smap_get_bool(&port->cfg->other_config,
>>> > --
>>> > 1.8.1.2
>>> >
>>>
>>>
>>
>>
>> Daniele
>
>
_______________________________________________
dev mailing list
dev@openvswitch.org
http://openvswitch.org/mailman/listinfo/dev
