Thanks Geoffrey for confirming that. Will go through that presentation. I have a follow-up question though, Let’s say if a table does not have any indexes on it, will these co-processors still be triggered and try to calculate index updates, since these are loaded by default for any table that is created through phoenix OR will this write path be entirely skipped since there are no indexes on the table? Asking this because I could not find a flag check in the code which checks if the indexes are present or not in pre/post Mutate operations.
Regards, Abhishek On Tue, Oct 30, 2018 at 2:25 PM Geoffrey Jacoby <gjac...@apache.org> wrote: > Abhishek, > > You might want to check out Vincent Poon's excellent presentation at this > year's PhoenixCon about recent changes over the past couple of years to the > index pipeline. > > https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBONDM7sD40 > > One of those changes is the one you observed. Global mutable index writes > were moved later in the HBase write pipeline to avoid some nasty deadlock > and starvation cases that could occur when making MemStore writes / MVCC > advancement wait on cross-server index RPCs to complete. > > Geoffrey > > > On Tue, Oct 30, 2018 at 10:31 AM Abhishek Talluri > <abhishektall...@cloudera.com.invalid> wrote: > > > Hi All, > > > > I am referring to the presentation that is given in SF Hbase Meetup in > > 2013, attached it for your reference. The write path states that, > > co-processor calculates the index updates and wal edits > > -> Writes it to the WAL (Making it durable) > > -> Then write the index updates > > -> Then proceed to the Memstore. > > > > But after looking at the code base (looked into 4.7 and 4.14), it looks > > like the write to index tables happen in the postBatchMutate phase which > is > > after the MemStore write finishes. I wanted to check with the community > to > > see if the flowchart is outdated. I feel that series of steps should be: > > co-processor calculates the index updates and wal edits > > -> Writes it to the WAL (Making it durable) > > -> Then proceed to the Memstore. > > -> Then write the index updates > > > > Appreciate any input on this. I want to clarify this because we see a > case > > where the write path could be creating some delay between write to WAL > and > > MemStore and creating some out of sync issue when using hbase lily > indexer. > > > > Thanks, > > Abhishek Talluri > > > > > -- Thanks, Abhishek Talluri Ph:9292405270
