Carlos Balduz created PIG-4583: ---------------------------------- Summary: Allow UDFs to return multiple values (not inside a Bag or a Tuple) Key: PIG-4583 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/PIG-4583 Project: Pig Issue Type: Improvement Affects Versions: 0.14.0 Reporter: Carlos Balduz
When writing a UDF, you are forced to return only one value, or multiple values but inside a Tuple or a Bag. Although this may not seem a big problem, when using Pig in production and performing multiple JOINs, GROUP BYs and any operations that make your schema more and more complicated, it would be nice to create a UDF to reduce the size of your schema, for example: ``` rel1 = load 'a' using PigStorage(';', '-schema'); rel2 = load 'b' using PigStorage(';', '-schema'); joined = join rel1 by id_whatever, rel2 by id_whatever; ... perform operations another_rel = load 'c' using PigStorage('.'.'-schema'); final_rel = join another_rel by id_whatever, joined by id_whatever; ``` Will have an schema like: ``` describe final_rel; rel1::joined::id_whatever, rel1:joined::field_1, ...... ``` When you have scripts with hundreds or thousands of lines of code, you end up having more foreachs to rename fields than with actual code. Therefore, I wrote a UDF to handle this so I wouldn't have to write a foreach to rename 100 fields one by one. However, due to Pig's limitation of returning only one value, I must place my return values inside a Tupe or a Bag, flatten it, and have another `something::` for each of the fields. Can we remove this limitation? And if it is done, perhaps upload the UDF I wrote... I think it is a VERY useful function for production environments and large scripts. -- This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA (v6.3.4#6332)