Hi all, the last few days and especially during the weekend I worked hard on the freemarker based code generation. After making the code-generation a lot better for C I extracted common code into a new BaseFreemarkerLanguageTemplateHelper class which is now the base of the Java and the C code generation helper. It generally contains methods for type, checks and generic operations (Like listing up the names of all types referenced in a given definition … It resolves the types of expressions etc.)
I completely overworked the discriminator code … you can now use as many discriminator fields as you like. And you no longer need to use these strange discriminatorValuex[0] expressions, which you actually have no reference to where they come from. Now everything is typesafe and should be a lot cleaner. As an example the S7 mspec changed from: [discriminatedType 'S7Payload' [uint 8 'messageType', S7Parameter 'parameter'] [typeSwitch 'parameter.discriminatorValues[0]', 'messageType' ['0x04','0x03' S7PayloadReadVarResponse [array S7VarPayloadDataItem 'items' count 'CAST(parameter, S7ParameterReadVarResponse).numItems' ['lastItem']] ] ['0x05','0x01' S7PayloadWriteVarRequest [array S7VarPayloadDataItem 'items' count 'COUNT(CAST(parameter, S7ParameterWriteVarRequest).items)' ['lastItem']] ] ['0x05','0x03' S7PayloadWriteVarResponse [array S7VarPayloadStatusItem 'items' count 'CAST(parameter, S7ParameterWriteVarResponse).numItems'] ] ['0x00','0x07' S7PayloadUserData [array S7PayloadUserDataItem 'items' count 'COUNT(CAST(parameter, S7ParameterUserData).items)' ['CAST(CAST(parameter, S7ParameterUserData).items[0], S7ParameterUserDataItemCPUFunctions).cpuFunctionType']] ] ] ] To: [discriminatedType 'S7Payload' [uint 8 'messageType', S7Parameter 'parameter'] [typeSwitch 'parameter.parameterType', 'messageType' ['0x04','0x03' S7PayloadReadVarResponse [array S7VarPayloadDataItem 'items' count 'CAST(parameter, S7ParameterReadVarResponse).numItems' ['lastItem']] ] ['0x05','0x01' S7PayloadWriteVarRequest [array S7VarPayloadDataItem 'items' count 'COUNT(CAST(parameter, S7ParameterWriteVarRequest).items)' ['lastItem']] ] ['0x05','0x03' S7PayloadWriteVarResponse [array S7VarPayloadStatusItem 'items' count 'CAST(parameter, S7ParameterWriteVarResponse).numItems'] ] ['0x00','0x07' S7PayloadUserData [array S7PayloadUserDataItem 'items' count 'COUNT(CAST(parameter, S7ParameterUserData).items)' ['CAST(CAST(parameter, S7ParameterUserData).items[0], S7ParameterUserDataItemCPUFunctions).cpuFunctionType']] ] ] ] Which is quite a bit more intuitive, I think. Also I had to extend the code generation plugin a bit … so we need to re-release that before we’re able to release something that contains my current changes. As the changes also affect mspec files, I would really like to merge things from my current “feature/c-code-generation-tagged-unions” back to develop. Feedback greatly appreciated. Chris