On Fri, 9 Jun 2017, Greg Woolsey wrote:
However, for unknown reasons not documented in Excel help as far as I can
see, the named range reference has to be specified as:

'workbook file name.xlsx'!named_range

however, when saving, the XML doesn't store the file name, but rather:

[0]!named_range

which of course is not recognized by POI's formula parsing.

I've come across this before. There's a little bit of support for these in XSSF, if you search the XSSF unit tests for "]!" you'll see some

My question is, does it seem reasonable, when the expression fails to parse
otherwise, to check if it starts with

[0]!

It can parse, but you have to supply the referenced workbooks for 1+. It's a bit messy though - some things expose the [#] form, some things can work with the [name.xlsx] form. Ideally we'd make it possible/easy to replicate the Excel behaviour

#56737 and #56752 are two bugs that spring to mind,
TestXSSFFormulaParser#formulaReferencesSameWorkbook() and
TestXSSFFormulaEvaluation#testReferencesToOtherWorkbooks() are two unit tests to start with

Nick

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]

Reply via email to