Paul wrote: >> >> Hi again Paul, >> >> Sorry, for following up my own email, but I decided it was worthwhile in >> this case. >> >> Reading over the issue and thinking about it, I believe he is correct. >> The >> document should not be treated as being modified because it has not been. >> The spreadsheet contains a cell with a formula, that formula displays the >> current date in the cell, every time the document is opened. When the >> document is closed it still contains a formula in the cell that displays >> the >> current date, not the current date value. So the document has not been >> modified. The current rendering of the document is different from what it >> was when opened yesterday, that's all. >> >> As I said in my last email however, if you think that reasoning is wrong >> then you should by all means put your reasoning as a update to the issue. > > > That's cool. However if the spreadsheet only contains the formula then the > 'modified document' status does not get set when opened (regardless of > whether the formula results are different or not). It is only when you > insert a chart that is built on the changing results of the formula that > the > modified document value gets set each time it is opened. > > I'll wait for the original poster to reply and see what rationale he can > come up with. I think this is one that can be argued either way. However > <puts on overly cautious hat> I'm sure there are bigger issues to resolve > than this one so my opinion would still be to close it and look at it when > there is nothing else to do... > > Just my $0.02 worth... > > /paul >
If you close it, it will never be solved, I think. You can move the milestone, but not close. I think that since both behaviour can have their reasoning, the better solution would be, sorry to say, see what "famour rival program" from Readmond does. Right or wrong, probably will be the "expected behaviour", so for the user, that is what really worth, will be right. Regards Marco --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
